4 ms·
And why not? Does the presence of someone on a stage nullify the free speech rights of those in the audience? It's rude to be sure, but then many obnoxious stat
by anigbrowl 3y ago
And why not? Does the presence of someone on a stage nullify the free speech rights of those in the audience? It's rude to be sure, but then many obnoxious statements are made by prominent speakers; I see no reason they should be immunized from disagreement. A speaking platform's elevated surface is a proxy for elevated social status, which might be civil, political, or religious in form. The argument that communication should only flow one way is an implicit compulsion of obedience.
One can of course argue that an effective retort is for audience members to turn their backs on the speaker or just leave. That can have some impact in a group setting, but ignores the degree to which video and photography inform public discourse. An experienced speaker, even if booed or ignored, just carries on giving the same speech while looking unfazed, and the lack of exterior reaction to criticism is what people will remember in any subsequent news coverage. News coverage of a speaking event rarely involves more than one camera, and this is sometimes enforced contractually. Only at music concerts and similar light entertainment where everyone is having a good time are audience shots a staple.
Whatever you think of Donald Trump's politics/person, there's no question that he's an extremely effective public communicator. Early in his current political arc, he would exploit the rigid grammar of American news media by pausing he his speeches to urge the TV cameras to pan around the audience so TV viewers could witness the size of the crowd. Of course they wouldn't do thatl media outlets were there to report on his rallies, and wished neither to modify their cumbersome broadcast setups on the fly or be seen to be taking direction from the subject of their news coverage. Trump would then allege that their unwillingness to do so was motivated by the establishment's fear of his popularity, and the audience ate it up. As some of the novelty wore off and attendance at his rallies waned from early peaks, media access was limited to friendly digital outlets who feed had to be licensed by broadcasters.
The fact is that a great many humans don't rely on analysis and reason alone to evaluate incoming information, but also on social cues. This is why 'reaction videos' are so popular on youtube; people want to see feeling on others' faces, either for validation of their own feelings or figure out what they 'ought to' think. There's people having entire online careers doing nothing but sharing affect in response to third party media; some non-negligible part of YouTube is just people selling their facial expressions to other people with unsatisfying social lives.
- mhb 3y agoPreventing someone from speaking is not an exercise of free speech.
- catlover76 3y ago> Preventing someone from speaking is not an exercise of free speech. You mean as a legal matter, or are you arguing this from a normative perspective?
- mhb 3y agoThe matter of its legality is only relevant to the government or public universities, etc. So, normative.
- catlover76 3y agoI mean, it'd be relevant to anyone doing the heckling too who is subsequently punished by such a government institution and who wants to counter that their being punished constitutes an illegal restraint of their speech, etc. But anyways, I think, if it's a normative argument, you're going to have to try persuade those of who disagree that we should change our minds. I personally would never really even bother to protest or heckle anyone, but I also don't find the speakers who tend to get heckled or their "ideas" as meriting sympathy.
- mhb 3y agoIf you don't understand why preventing someone from speaking is different than, for example, making your own argument, I have no idea how I would convince you. Maybe: The ideas that many of these hecklers now hold so dear was, until relatively recently, anathema to large groups of people. If your view was dominant, would we have ever heard from MLK, Harvey Milk, voices in favor of abolishing sodomy laws, pro-choice speakers in anti-abortion regions, etc., etc.
- catlover76 3y ago