3 ms·
Genuine question: how big of a problem is this, really? Just because it seems like nobody was talking about it until a few months ago, now that there's growing
by crazygringo 3y ago
Genuine question: how big of a problem is this, really?
Just because it seems like nobody was talking about it until a few months ago, now that there's growing realization that while EV's reduce ICE pollution, the battery packs make them heavier and so tire pollution will be increasing.
But in the context of everything else that gets dumped into waterways and the air and the soil, how big of a deal is this? Like is this something that we really need to find a solution for soon, and is there even a solution? (Hard to imagine tires that don't wear out.) Or is this only really the 1,000th top priority, of all of the categories of things we pollute with?
I just have no idea, and none of the articles I've been reading have managed to put it into any kind of context.
- XorNot 3y agoI operate under the suspicion that there's a lot of fossil fuel astroturfing going on with things like this. They know full well anything which slows adoption is going to ultimately lead to sustained ICE usage, not some third option.
- arcticbull 3y agoSome of us would just rather invest in busses, bikes and trains if we're going to replace everything on the road right now. The reality is yes of course EVs are better than ICE cars - eventually. It takes some 20-90,000 miles driven for them to break even in terms of CO2 emissions thanks to all the lithium and copper that goes into them. The tire wear is yet another new and interesting challenge. They're being marketed as a panacea, but they're not. They're probably 1/2 to 1/4 as bad as a gas powered car for most people in most cases. For some people it's worse than a gas car - the ones who get big heavy cars like an electric hummer, or for people who don't put too many miles on their cars. The best car is the one you don't need because you have public transit around. That way you can use the roads for neat stuff like restaurants, and walking.
- rootusrootus 3y ago> 1/2 to 1/4 as bad as a gas powered car That right there is huge cause for celebration. > For some people it's worse than a gas car. Those people should wait, and let someone else use the EV. But for a good comparison, I think we should stick to lifecycle for the car and not individual owners. Few cars go from cradle to grave with only a single owner.
- arcticbull 3y agoIt's better, it's not best - we know what 'best' is and what it looks like, we're just choosing not to invest in it. The main issue I have is it's being marketed as something it isn't to placate entrenched interests. > Those people should wait, and let someone else use the EV. Why? Why shouldn't both people take a train? Same kind of argument really.
- rootusrootus 3y agoAre you suggesting 'best' is public transit? We know already that it doesn't come anywhere close to solving the myriad use cases for private transportation. I'd love a very healthy public transit system, but cars are always going to have their place. Public transit has a halfway decent use case for a good number of people, for sure.
- arcticbull 3y agoEach car costs $50-100K right now, times however many cars we're going to replace over the coming few years. Thats 290M * let's call it $75K = $21T. What kind of transit system do you think that would buy us? How much better for the environment do you think that would be? A transit system like Hong Kong MTR would get us down to 1 in 3 people owning a car. Down from 179% right now. If the rest were gas, so what? Could still swap them out for electric over time.
- rootusrootus 3y agoYou can buy any of a number of EVs for quite a bit less than 50K. And they'd be replacing an equivalent ICEV that's going to be replaced anyway, for a use case that will not 100% be replaceable by public transit. Comparing the US to Hong Kong is severely biased. Though it does explain why many people on HN are so delusional about what problems public transit can and cannot solve. Even in Europe, which everyone says has much better public transit than the US, the vast majority of people own cars. They're useful, and denying that just destroys the pro-transit argument before it can even be made.
- chongli 3y agoI couldn’t find numbers on tire wear, but road wear increases with the fourth power of vehicle mass [1]. I think it’s a fairly safe guess to assume tires wear similarly to roads at best. Unfortunately, vehicles have been getting dramatically heavier [2] before even taking EVs into account. It doesn’t take too many people driving around in 9000 pound Hummer EVs to make a big difference. Using the fourth power law, a single 9000-pounder is going cause the equivalent of 81 3000-pound compact cars worth of road wear. We may have to introduce some kind of vehicle weight tax! [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AASHO_Road_Test https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AASHO_Road_Test [2] https://www.axios.com/2023/04/28/evs-weight-safety-problems https://www.axios.com/2023/04/28/evs-weight-safety-problems
- rootusrootus 3y agoFortunately, 9000 pound hummers are essentially exotics, and not something that will sell in large numbers. I think a better context would be comparing the most popular EVs on our roads (e.g. Model 3, Y) with the most popular ICEV equivalents (RAV4? Camry?). And for extra data, box trucks and tractor-trailers. Probably we should just tax trucks and skip the expense of trying to tax individual consumers.
- chongli 3y agoPrepare to be depressed [1]. Just at a quick glance, it seems vehicle weight has a very high correlation with popularity. [1] https://www.caranddriver.com/news/g39628015/best-selling-cars-2022/ https://www.caranddriver.com/news/g39628015/best-selling-car...
- Y_Y 3y agoI always thought it would be interesting to try a "momentum limit" rather than a speed limit. I wonder how fast that would get people to move to lighter vehicles.
- chongli 3y agoThat would only work if each vehicle weight class had its own lane to work with. Otherwise you can’t mix vehicles of widely different speeds on the same road.
- Affric 3y agoRight, by the same token, why should any relatively small carbon intensive country decarbonise x/y/z sector when China, India, Nigeria et cetera are still out there? Tyres have costs that they successfully externalise. As a society we either accept them or we regulate them. It’s incredible that whenever the externalised costs of motor vehicles come up someone will come in and say “ah but there’s no direct carbon emissions”. (This is a reference to another child comment, not yours specifically). The context is that we exist in and depend on a biosphere that we don’t fully understand but we do know we are living through what amounts to a huge mass extinction where we are destroying assets that have taken about 66 million years to arise without having determined their true value. We seem to be in the middle of a demographic transition where we will gradually need less space and fewer resources as a society (all the while seemingly needing more care provided to us). And it’s a conversation that’s been going on my whole 30 something years on this planet. And from the article: > “We also assessed the effectiveness of a stormwater treatment device to capture and remove these contaminants from stormwater and evaluated the role of a constructed stormwater wetland for capturing microplastics in the sediment, removing it from stormwater runoff. > “The device is a bag made of 0.2 millimetre mesh which can be retrofitted to stormwater drains. Although originally designed to capture gross pollutants, sediment, litter and oil and grease, it significantly reduced microplastics from raw runoff, with up to 88% less microplastics in treated water which had passed through the device.” They even have a partial solution to this problem that can be retrofitted to existing infrastructure.
- pkulak 3y agoIt absolutely _feels_ like there's an anti-EV campaign to pump out FUD concerning tires. First it was long-tailpipe stuff, but that didn't really gain much traction (har har), so we're on to the next one. Not saying it's not a problem, but saving some car weight by making them all burn gas doesn't seem like the solution.
- charcircuit 3y ago>Not saying it's not a problem, but saving some car weight by making them all burn gas doesn't seem like the solution. The solution is good enough that many manufacturers make hybrid cars that do this.
- zik 3y agoTyre particulate pollution has been a big deal in environmental circles for some time, but it seems to be only recently that it's had a lot of media attention. Is this good news that it's finally gaining some attention or bad news that it's being used to astroturf? I'm really not sure.
- makeitdouble 3y agoThis article is about setting up devices to remove that plastic, I'm not sure to see your EV angle to this.
- orhmeh09 3y agoIt's a big deal for fish https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abd6951 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abd6951 A ubiquitous tire rubber–derived chemical induces acute mortality in coho salmon (2020) > In U.S. Pacific Northwest coho salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch), stormwater exposure annually causes unexplained acute mortality when adult salmon migrate to urban creeks to reproduce. By investigating this phenomenon, we identified a highly toxic quinone transformation product of N-(1,3-dimethylbutyl)-N′-phenyl-p-phenylenediamine (6PPD), a globally ubiquitous tire rubber antioxidant. Retrospective analysis of representative roadway runoff and stormwater-affected creeks of the U.S. West Coast indicated widespread occurrence of 6PPD-quinone (<0.3 to 19 micrograms per liter) at toxic concentrations (median lethal concentration of 0.8 ± 0.16 micrograms per liter). These results reveal unanticipated risks of 6PPD antioxidants to an aquatic species and imply toxicological relevance for dissipated tire rubber residues.
- makeitdouble 3y ago> Urban stormwater runoff typically requires treatment for the removal of suspended solids and nutrients [...] However, regulations are lagging behind when it comes to microplastics and tyre wear particles. The question is less about how big of a deal it is, and kpre about whether suspended plastic bits should be allowed to stay when other particles are required to be removed.
- ruined 3y agothis is, really, a big problem. tire particulate is particularly nasty. Internalization, reduced growth, and behavioral effects following exposure to micro and nano tire particles in two estuarine indicator species https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2022.133934 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2022.133934 >The presence of adverse effects in M. beryllina and A. bahia indicate that even at current environmental levels of tire-related pollution, which are expected to continue to increase, aquatic ecosystems may be experiencing negative impacts. Toxicity of micro and nano tire particles and leachate for model freshwater organisms https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhazmat.2022.128319 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhazmat.2022.128319 >TP leachate was the main driver of toxicity for D. magna and larval zebrafish. Exposure to nano TPs enhanced toxicity in comparison to leachate alone. A ubiquitous tire rubber–derived chemical induces acute mortality in coho salmon https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abd6951 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abd6951 >Regular acute mortality events are tied, in particular, to stormwater runoff, but the identity of the causative toxicant(s) has not been known. Starting from leachate from new and aged tire tread wear particles, Tian et al. followed toxic fractions through chromatography steps, eventually isolating a single molecule that could induce acute toxicity at threshold concentrations of ∼1 microgram per liter. Tire-wear-particle leachate toxicity to Americamysis bahia: analysis of sublethal and molecular effects https://cedar.wwu.edu/wwuet/1132/ https://cedar.wwu.edu/wwuet/1132/ >There were 80 dysregulated contigs across all tested weathered leachate concentrations and 139 dysregulated contigs across all tested un-weathered concentrations. [...] Many contig sequences mapped to gene descriptions that regulated physical body structure, inflammatory response, and mediated protein-protein interactions, signifying that TWP leachate exposure disrupts many internal molecular processes in A. bahia. Tribes Petition Environmental Protection Agency to Ban Toxic Chemical from Tires https://earthjustice.org/press/2023/tribes-petition-environmental-protection-agency-to-ban-toxic-chemical-from-tires https://earthjustice.org/press/2023/tribes-petition-environm... >When 6PPD reacts with ground-level ozone, it breaks down into 6PPD-q — the second most toxic chemical to aquatic species ever evaluated by the EPA. Exposure to 6PPD-q can kill coho salmon within hours, and the chemical is responsible for “urban runoff mortality syndrome,” which kills up to 100% of coho returning to spawn in urban streams. The Tribes contend that 6PPD in tires poses unreasonable risks to the environment, requiring the EPA to regulate the chemical under the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA).