5 ms·
US broadband grant rules shut out small ISPs and municipalities, advocates say
- exabrial 3y agoThe proponents of "getting a subsidy to pay for internet" of course were the entrenched players. More than likely, we'll see ISPs double dip: raise their prices to what they think the market is willing to pay (which they do now) AND collect the government subsidy, "raising prices to optimum cockbag levels": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0ilMx7k7mso&t=63s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0ilMx7k7mso&t=63s
- ToucanLoucan 3y agoThe idea that we need to give grants to utilities that are ostensibly better as private institutions since private companies allegedly "drive innovation" is so nonsensical on it's face. All it's led to is a cadre of entrenched corporations that do not give the slightest fuck about their quality of service or uptime, and competitive pricing is a fucking joke in the American broadband market. I have not heard any arguments in favor of this system that hold water in my entire life and it's only getting more and more true as consumers get screwed harder and harder with zero solutions on offer either by these mythical "competitors" or the Government that acts as defacto enforcer of their ability to choke customers out of more and more money for worse and worse service year over year.
- toast0 3y ago> The idea that we need to give grants to utilities that are ostensibly better as private institutions since private companies allegedly "drive innovation" is so nonsensical on it's face. If the idea was we needed to give grants to drive innovation, something was missed. There's not really an unmet need for innovation in broadband delivery; the issue is running new wires broadband has costs, and in a lot of places, the ROI on running new wires for broadband doesn't justify doing it. The grants were supposed to induce large providers to do the runs in areas that weren't commercially viable; of course, it's easier to ask for grants and then do nothing with them, which is even better for the bottom line. Really, we'd be a lot better off if last mile had mandatory line sharing (as the telecom act of 1996 provided), and if there was some cooperation from the major broadband providers to coalesce on some upgradable standard for it. A single fiber to the home built on GPON/10GPON/NG-PON2 could be leveraged by telco, cableco, and others, but since telco and cableco will only use their own lines and won't build unless there's demonstrable ROI, a GPON overbuild by a third network is doomed to poor financials: either the incumbents were right and you won't see the uptake, or the incumbents were wrong, will notice when you overbuild and will update their network and the 3rd network still won't get customer uptake. Where I live, I only get VDSL2; the cable company comes to the corner of my property but won't serve my house. Municipal fiber is available, but only if I pay to run it above ground a couple miles to the drive, and I've also got to pay for undergrounding from the pole to my house. If I could get a few people together, some of the costs would be shared, but not a lot of people are willing to pay tens of thousands of dollars to get better internet, when they have a serviceable alternative now, and the monthly costs are likely more with muni fiber too. Of course, if the cableco or telco decide to roll out to my house, the installation fees will probably be minimal, because those companies can account for the costs in other ways than a public agency.
- ToucanLoucan 3y ago> There's not really an unmet need for innovation in broadband delivery; the issue is running new wires broadband has costs, and in a lot of places, the ROI on running new wires for broadband doesn't justify doing it. This sounds like exactly the sort of thing a private company is going to be terrible at. And even with the grants, it seems they are and have been since I was in preschool.
- toast0 3y agoYeah, grants don't really seem to work here; my point was more that if you thought they were for innovation, that was way off-base. The grants can be helpful for upstarts, but not when the criteria exclude upstarts. If the goal is universal service, it really needs to be mandatory, not voluntary, even with incentives (especially poorly administered incentives). But mandatory service is usually connected with a granted monopoly, which isn't really what we want either. On the other hand, if it takes long enough to get everyone wired, wireless options will become competitive. Between LEO internet services (StarLink, maybe OneWeb and friends) and terrestrial 5G-NR, I think it's quite likely that few places without current wired broadband will ever get it.
- chiefalchemist 3y agoThe phrase you're looking for is Cronie Capitalism. It's "capitalism" (note the air quotes, please) with the gov putting it's thumb on the scale to benefit the few. The joke is the "free markets" are better narrative and Cronie Capitalism is anything but free markets. Welcome to The New America.
- rhino369 3y ago>I have not heard any arguments in favor of this system that hold water in my entire life One defense is that the old AT&T system was really expensive and slowed progress. Deregulation was a big win for consumers. I agree that well regulated monopoly ISPs could deliver better service. But I'm deeply skeptical that, in practice, we'd manage to actually regulate the ISPs properly. Our regulated power companies have shitty, underfunded grids that create massive forest fires. I would half expect really cheap nationwide DSL.
- bcrl 3y agoThe same thing happened here in the province of Ontario. The government handed out roughly $2.5 billion in subsidies through a reverse auction, but not a single smaller provider was able to participate. The lots were too big (my local area had a reserve bid of $51 million), and the bonding requirements were excessive (want to bid on that $51 million lot? Better be bonded for $51 million even if your planned bid is going to be a fraction of that). I don't know of any carriers that bond their projects -- if the builder doesn't make progress in a month, then they don't get paid. It's pretty sad that governments don't hand out telecom subsidies in a competitively neutral manner. Funding Make Ready costs for repairing pre-existing conditions and addressing lack of Spare Capacity on existing pole lines would make it easier for all carriers large and small to participate in the market. Beyond that, obligating pole owners to pre-engineer telecom attachments would really help. The region I live in is primarily served with aerial communications strand on poles as there are too many rocks, hills and trees to make wireless or burial viable for many of the unserved.
- sschueller 3y agoThe biggest problem with these grants is that it is tax payer money that is then used to build private non open network monopolies. Easiest solution would be what we have in Switzerland. If you want that government money, the fiber you lay needs to be accessible to any competitor otherwise you aren't getting any of it. This is the only reason we have 25gbit symmetrical available for only around $70/month [1] because the fiber has to be available for anyone to use. Recently the largest phone provider here tried to lay p2mp instead of p2p which would result in requiring splitters setting the max speed and features to what they define giving them a competitive advantage over anyone else. Luckily Init7 took them to court and they are now back peddling. Sadly that phone provider wasted an enormous amount of tax payers money and now need to undo the damage they did. [1] https://www.init7.net/en/internet/fiber7/ https://www.init7.net/en/internet/fiber7/
- networkchad 3y ago[dead]
- bcrl 3y agoP2MP is fine -- you can use EPON/GPON/XGSPON/10G-EPON that are designed for shared optical networks with passive splitters or even run DWDM over those splitters to provide P2P circuits over those same infrastructure (PLC splitters really don't care what you're doing with the optical signal so long as it meets the optical signal budget). Cutting the cost of feeder fibres is worthwhile unless you happen to have infinite money available.
- sschueller 3y agoThe addional cost per connection was estimated at only around $50. With the splitter any 3rd party will always be limited with what the ISP has installed or decides to allow. Who decides who gets which part of the optical budget? That is considered "market manipulation" here.
- bcrl 3y agoDepends on the market. If you're in a high density area the cost of feeder fibres is inconsequential. If you're in a low density rural market, additional feeder fibres are expensive. Smaller market players can't get the 30 year amortization that governments can which makes cost matter. The optical signal budget in a Passive Optical Network (PON) is a function of the split ratio (commonly 1:32 => 2^5 => 5 * 3dB = ~15dB) and distance involved (typically 0.35 dB/km), which both are a function of the network design. Passive optical networks are typically designed around a 20 km distance with a 1:32 (sometimes 1:64 for 10G PON variants) splitter ratio. You can trade splitter ratio for distance if needed. An 80km DWDM optic is tight at the extreme distance, but 120km is pretty close to the 1:32 / 20km link budget. My point is that it is viable to overlay DWDM on a network designed for PON.
- CuriouslyC 3y agoThe municipality should own the network and lease bandwidth to private providers. I'm sure private providers would be willing to help lay cable if they got a fixed fee for the work done along with a period of slightly reduced lease rates and first dibs on a fairly sizable chunk of the pipe's leases. The fixed rate would cover work expenses with a little profit and the cherry lease deal would pay out better than a bond and be fungible so it'd be easy to secure credit on that agreement.
- deepspace 3y agoThat is what the small city where I live did. As a result, we get gigabit symmetrical service for the equivalent of just over US$20 a month.