4 ms·
My natural first reaction is what unknown effect will this have on underwater life? We know other types of sonar have had negative effects. Knowing that, this s
by dylan604 3y ago
My natural first reaction is what unknown effect will this have on underwater life? We know other types of sonar have had negative effects. Knowing that, this should be studied and considered when making any new underwater sounding equipment. You don't get to go "we never thought about it" now that we know about it.
- awei 3y agoThis was also my first thought.
- backendanon 3y agoAt 1 million times less power than existing sound transmission systems I'd say it's probably less audio going into the water than a baby whale fart.
- Eduard 3y agothat's -60dB, no? like the reduction from gunshot (140dB) to alarm clock (80dB)... or jet plane take-off (120dB) to normal conversation (60dB). Depending on the actual, absolute values, one-millionth can therefore be still annoying — especially if it is pervasive and omnipresent.
- cogman10 3y agoThe innovation here is to make that unidirectional rather than omnidirectional. So seems reasonable to conclude that even if the beam is gunshot noisy, outside the beam is basically silent.
- nomel 3y agoMaybe I'm not understanding, but isn't this reflecting sound back, generated by something else? It seems the device uses one millionth the power, but the thing stimulating the device uses an unspecified amount, that would increase dramatically with distance. Unfortunately this is an MIT press release, so it will be impossible to understand what's actually going on. Does anyone have a more informative link?
- omniglottal 3y agoThere is no more information, as described in TFA, for reasons of this information having not been discovered yet by the researchers studying the new tech.
- wirelessR 3y agoThe press release links the two publications: - http://www.mit.edu/~fadel/papers/VAB-paper.pdf http://www.mit.edu/~fadel/papers/VAB-paper.pdf - http://www.mit.edu/~fadel/papers/PAB-theory-paper.pdf http://www.mit.edu/~fadel/papers/PAB-theory-paper.pdf
- nomel 3y ago> ... fix the input electrical power to 150 W ... The 20 dB DI transducers push the uplink decoding range up to several kilometers. That probably is close to a baby whale fart, but I doubt competing systems are running at 150,000,000 W, as the above comment suggests. In their test to get 60m, they used 1.8W. 1.8 MW seems unlikely, for the same distance, with competing tech. There's a fundamental misunderstanding of what's going on here. But, that's to be expected, with how these press releases are written.
- wirelessR 3y agoThis is asymmetric communication. The node itself uses backscatter thus operates at few micro-Watts. The remote acoustic projector is the 1.8W, and can communicate with 100s/1000s(?) of micro-watt power nodes - similar to RFIDs, but this tech works underwater.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nomel 3y agoI understanding that, but claiming that the backscatter energy, or the nodes power usage, is all the ocean life (the context of this comment chain) will see is incorrect, as the previous comment did. They primarily see the excitation energy, which appears to be ~23db greater (harvesting efficiency) than the backscatter, at the node. This is the same as something sitting between an RFID chip and the reader would. So, the sea life near the transmitter would still have a bad time. The sea life near the nodes would see 23db more* than an active node, assuming the same power could be used to transmit from the node. Correct? This seems logical, since the energy harvesting will come at a coupling and efficiency cost, which means significantly more energy in the water at that node. If you had a battery powered node, you wouldn't need all the extra energy, and instead could just transmit. All these numbers being thrown around are the power usage of the node, not what the sea life actually sees. * Maybe more, since the signal path is twice as short, meaning your SNR starts higher at the midpoint (node).
- dmd 3y agoThis is less energy put into the system than that given by a child splashing in the waves at the beach.
- yummypaint 3y agoIf many of the people replying to this comment had read the article, they would know that the low power device in question sends data by altering its reflectivity. It's metaphorically like covering and uncovering a retroreflector to send signals to a person a mile away with a powerful spotlight or laser pointed at you. It seems reasonable to be concerned about what this significantly stronger and likely highly-directed signal might do to biological things it encounters on its way.
- cogman10 3y agoI wish the article had a reference to the actual power used. It SOUNDS like it's quiet minimal. In which case, it'd be hard to imagine you are dealing with biologically devastating energy. That said, the unidirectional nature of this approach also means that actual life that could be affected is a lot smaller than what happens with sonar, where the signal is blasted in all directions at a very high power.
- isoprophlex 3y agoThis, or something very similar, was posted a long time ago here. I cant find it anymore, sadly, but it was a backscatter-based communication platform that used very low power in the underwater part... And illuminated that with 210 dB sound. I guess this is similar, and equally disruptive to sea life.