2 ms·
> due to generalizations like this. I'm rather concerned seeing this response. My comment is about more nuance, not less. That example has qualifies and is cl
by godelski 3y ago
> due to generalizations like this.
I'm rather concerned seeing this response. My comment is about more nuance, not less.
That example has qualifies and is clearly not a catch all. The main thesis is that more nuance is required not... generalization. I do believe SSRIs work, just not for everyone. I'm very much not trying to discourage people from trialing them, so much as looking for other solutions if those trialing fail.
Personally, SSRIs almost killed me. They just made me suicidal. The problem was that it didn't match my specific case. That's okay. The bigger problem was that every psychiatrist I tried just tried giving me a different one or told me to keep using them "until I levelize." This is doing far more danger than me saying "we need more nuance and stop using a sledge hammer for every case." You know what's actually dangerous? A patient saying "I stopped taking this because it made me want to die" and a doctor responding "that was unwise, you should have continued taking it." Who isn't going to come away from that thinking their doctor is trying to kill them.
Experiences like mine are what drives the fear you are talking about. That's not on the patients, that's on the doctors. If instead they got SSRIs, found they don't work, and tried something else, found that it did work, people wouldn't write these stories. You're victim blaming. I could have personally gotten help more than a decade sooner if this nuance was in practice but instead it should be unsurprising that I used to be (note not now) passionate about not taking something that made me want to die. It's unsurprising that I refused to see any psychiatrist considering years of the same thing happening over and over. That's on the doctors, not on me. They taught me to be afraid. I'm saying there's absolutely no reason that should have happened.