3 ms·
> As someone who grew up as a nerd and only later discovered the joys of sports and fitness: > This idea that physical fitness is "war" and excruciating painfu
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> As someone who grew up as a nerd and only later discovered the joys of sports and fitness:
> This idea that physical fitness is "war" and excruciating painful and only for jocks is largely self-inflicted by nerds upon themselves. It comes from movies and TV and internet tropes more than the real world.
As someone who was a nerd but also in a variety of sports through most of school, had parents who were active in coaching, and has been involved in some organized athletics beyond school: no, its not “self-inflicted by nerds upon themselves”.
Its not inherent in athletics itself, but its deeply involved in a lot of sports culture, is extremely common in youth sports of all kinds (even sometimes in notionally non-competitive organizations) which is probably whwre most misperceptions of its universality comes from—not just through coaches, but very often through parents, many of whom will put pressure on coaches they don’t see as embracing it.
Jock culture is not a product of nerd culture imagination, nor is it a fictional media invention. You can kind find social athletic groups/venues without it, but its pretty hard to predict where you will.
> In fact, your local amateur soccer club or climbing gym is probably full of nerds. I run into a lot of engineers at these activities.
Not all engineers are nerds and, contrary to media myths of an exclusive dichotomy, being a nerd or engineer doesn’t mean not having a stereotypical jock-culture attitude toward athletics.
Amateur adult sports clubs are a mixed bag, but (IME, at least) generally better than what one generalizing from youth sports might expect, same with gyms.
- JohnBooty 3y agoJock culture is not a product of nerd culture imagination, nor is it a fictional media invention. You can kind find social athletic groups/venues without it, but its pretty hard to predict where you will. Toxic athletic culture exists. In many cases, though, there's an extreme mismatch between what athletes experience and what non-athletes perceive. Many athletes like to compete. They like to play hard, against other people who are doing the same thing. Winning is fun, but competition is really the thing. When you train and compete hard it is not a zero-sum game; even if you lose you have sharpened yourself so to speak. If it's a team sport this is going to involve some level of sacrifice and subsuming one's self into the whole. That level can be extremely small (the ultra casual darts team at your local pub) or quite large (a professional football team). This can be hard for non-athletes to understand in a sporting context, and it all just seems like a giant incomprehensible ball of toxic hate to them because they don't understand the appeal of any of this in the first place. Jock culture is not a product of nerd culture imagination, nor is it a fictional media invention. It certainly wasn't invented by nerds or the media, but it is amplified by the media. Obviously the media doesn't typically report on healthy sports participation, you know? And the dumb "jocks versus nerds" false dichotomy is such an easy and functional Hollywood trope. I would also note that a lot of "toxic sports culture" is the product of overbearing and overcompetitive parents living vicariously through their children and forcing their kids to do things they don't want to do. So, is that really a sports thing? No, it's a parenting thing. Those are toxic parents.