5 ms·
> But there are good cultural reasons why nerds avoid physical activity. North American cultural tropes, especially from high school on up, make out physical ac
by Aurornis 3y ago
> But there are good cultural reasons why nerds avoid physical activity. North American cultural tropes, especially from high school on up, make out physical activity to be a kind of war. It is supposed to require extreme discipline and a punitive degree of focus. It's supposed to separate winners from losers. Those who are lesser (too weak, too fat, too short, too... whatever) are just embarrassing and should not try to do physical things in public view, unless they are trying to atone for their weaknesses with self-flagellation.
As someone who grew up as a nerd and only later discovered the joys of sports and fitness:
This idea that physical fitness is "war" and excruciating painful and only for jocks is largely self-inflicted by nerds upon themselves. It comes from movies and TV and internet tropes more than the real world.
Once you step out of the nerd bubble and try some physical fitness or casual sports you realize it's nothing like the movies. It's also nothing like the fitness influencers who post about their daily Crossfit grind or other social media displays. In fact, your local amateur soccer club or climbing gym is probably full of nerds and even people you might think are "out of shape", but who still have a great time. I run into a lot of engineers at these activities.
I think the concept that sports are pain and only for the elite few and/or dumb jocks is a comforting myth for those who want to believe they're making the right choice by not exercising, but it's not true.
- neilk 3y agoYou're definitely right that the jock/nerd thing is more of a media trope than real. On the other hand, I just attended my nephews' football game. When I went to the bathroom at halftime, I happened to overhear the losing team's coach speaking to his players - the bathroom adjoined the locker room. Speaking? I mean screaming. I was disgusted by the level of toxic masculinity. I shared this with some of my colleagues later and some of them said they had quit team sports to get away from this sort of culture.
- Aurornis 3y agoPhysical fitness and competitive sports are two different things, though. It's another nerd trope that physical fitness means you must engaged in competitive team sports or toxic masculinity. Again, step out of these bubbles and you realize that competitive, organized team sports are only a tiny little slice of the physical activities that people do. Also, not all competitive team sports are like this. It's a mistake to think that the toxic masculinity, outraged coach yelling at kids is totally normal. It's not. Many coaches will push their students past their comfort zones and refuse to take any crap, but someone who is just plain toxic will gradually lose their team and get pushed out most of the time.
- WalterBright 3y ago> It's another nerd trope that physical fitness means you must engaged in competitive team sports or toxic masculinity. Oh please. As a lifelong nerd, I've never heard of these tropes.
- fatnoah 3y agoMy only anecdata as a parent is my son's recent decision to join the cross-country running team at his high school. I've been amazed by the level of positivity and support of the team as a whole. The coach doesn't take any crap, but is amazingly supportive. One of the reasons my son joined was the experience of his very nerdy, overweight, non-athletic in any way, friend that joined the previous year. His friend went from not being able to run more than 500 ft to being able to complete a 2 mile run, with all members of the team strongly supporting him throughout. So far, my son has experienced the same things. It's amazing the effect it's had on these kids. My son is learning how to push himself and how much mental strength translates to the real world. i.e. Are you really that tired? Are you sure you can't make it to the end of the next lap? etc. What makes me sad is how few opportunities kids have for organized sports as they get older. By the time they're in high school, it's basically only for the super-competitive.
- Aurornis 3y ago> What makes me sad is how few opportunities kids have for organized sports as they get older. By the time they're in high school, it's basically only for the super-competitive. There are actually a lot of recreational leagues available once you get into college. My local parks are booked out all summer with rec leagues for various ages.
- Arrath 3y agoThis is my experience too, it may take a little looking but you'll likely find everything from pick up basketball games to amateur soccer and rugby leagues, or hockey beer leagues.
- trogdor 3y agoIn most larger cities there are even adult leagues. Seattle, for example, has an adult recreational hockey league that has ~2,000 participants across ten divisions of ability. If you can ice skate (and there are lessons available if you can’t), there’s a place for you on an ice hockey team. And if you’re not “super competitive” but just want to have some fun skating around a rink, you can do that any day of the week. Same goes for many other sports.
- raverbashing 3y ago> more than the real world Nah I've seen these play out in the real world, High School, etc. A lot of times > nothing like the fitness influencers who post about their daily Crossfit grind or other social media displays If that's what they're posting then I don't agree with this being a "nerd bubble" issue only But you're right, there's a whole world of friendly fitness out there, that's why I keep the f out of "bro sports"
- tasuki 3y agoI wanted to reply to your comment, but see you've since edited it. Congrats, that was a good edit!
- dragonwriter 3y ago> As someone who grew up as a nerd and only later discovered the joys of sports and fitness: > This idea that physical fitness is "war" and excruciating painful and only for jocks is largely self-inflicted by nerds upon themselves. It comes from movies and TV and internet tropes more than the real world. As someone who was a nerd but also in a variety of sports through most of school, had parents who were active in coaching, and has been involved in some organized athletics beyond school: no, its not “self-inflicted by nerds upon themselves”. Its not inherent in athletics itself, but its deeply involved in a lot of sports culture, is extremely common in youth sports of all kinds (even sometimes in notionally non-competitive organizations) which is probably whwre most misperceptions of its universality comes from—not just through coaches, but very often through parents, many of whom will put pressure on coaches they don’t see as embracing it. Jock culture is not a product of nerd culture imagination, nor is it a fictional media invention. You can kind find social athletic groups/venues without it, but its pretty hard to predict where you will. > In fact, your local amateur soccer club or climbing gym is probably full of nerds. I run into a lot of engineers at these activities. Not all engineers are nerds and, contrary to media myths of an exclusive dichotomy, being a nerd or engineer doesn’t mean not having a stereotypical jock-culture attitude toward athletics. Amateur adult sports clubs are a mixed bag, but (IME, at least) generally better than what one generalizing from youth sports might expect, same with gyms.
- JohnBooty 3y agoJock culture is not a product of nerd culture imagination, nor is it a fictional media invention. You can kind find social athletic groups/venues without it, but its pretty hard to predict where you will. Toxic athletic culture exists. In many cases, though, there's an extreme mismatch between what athletes experience and what non-athletes perceive. Many athletes like to compete. They like to play hard, against other people who are doing the same thing. Winning is fun, but competition is really the thing. When you train and compete hard it is not a zero-sum game; even if you lose you have sharpened yourself so to speak. If it's a team sport this is going to involve some level of sacrifice and subsuming one's self into the whole. That level can be extremely small (the ultra casual darts team at your local pub) or quite large (a professional football team). This can be hard for non-athletes to understand in a sporting context, and it all just seems like a giant incomprehensible ball of toxic hate to them because they don't understand the appeal of any of this in the first place. Jock culture is not a product of nerd culture imagination, nor is it a fictional media invention. It certainly wasn't invented by nerds or the media, but it is amplified by the media. Obviously the media doesn't typically report on healthy sports participation, you know? And the dumb "jocks versus nerds" false dichotomy is such an easy and functional Hollywood trope. I would also note that a lot of "toxic sports culture" is the product of overbearing and overcompetitive parents living vicariously through their children and forcing their kids to do things they don't want to do. So, is that really a sports thing? No, it's a parenting thing. Those are toxic parents.
- gilbetron 3y agoIt is definitely not "self-inflicted by nerds upon themselves", at least not entirely. I grew up both a nerd and mildly athletic and became very athletic in college and later. While there are certainly areas of positive support athletics for adolescents, much of athletics is as the OP describes. I have a very talent athletic family in general, with several cousins and one nephew that are playing or have played professional, and nearly all my relatives highly active in sports their whole lives. I was an outlier! And I can say, from the internal view, competitive sports tends to be pretty rough on people. Friendships made, yes, and it can be a great experience, but it is typically very excluding and very, very harsh. It really depends on where you grow up, too. None of this is to say that physical activities have to be like that, and most aren't once you get into college and beyond. But middle and high school in much of america? It can be harsh!
- JeremyNT 3y ago> As someone who grew up as a nerd and only later discovered the joys of sports and fitness: > > This idea that physical fitness is "war" and excruciating painful and only for jocks is largely self-inflicted by nerds upon themselves. It comes from movies and TV and internet tropes more than the real world. I can refute this at least in my upbringing (boys athletics in rural US south public schools). I played organized baseball and basketball through middle school, and even in the earlier grades it was quite competitive. Parents were really pushing their kids. I sucked and loathed disappointing everybody including my father. In high school I was no longer in athletics but I was in band, and where I'm from band exists to support the football team. So we were always hanging out around the football players, and I got to witness the culture first hand. A lot of parents are convinced their kids are (or could be) stars, and that does rub off on them. It's a massive amount of pressure. Even if you already know you're not actually in the running, social status is still tied to performance, and in high school social status is everything. Later in life, free from such delusions, rec sports are totally different. Nobody is out there trying to get a scholarship. Nobody dreams of becoming a millionaire. Nobody thinks that if they just manage to perform a little bit better, finally they will be popular and cool. Nobody thinks that they can finally satisfy their hyper-critical fathers if they just execute that play correctly. Everybody knows the stakes are low. The "it's not whether you win or lose, it's how you play" finally makes sense. So I can't say it's universally true, but there's good reason that these tropes exist. p.s. - I now have a daughter in middle school soccer. It is very different than high school boy's football, but I still see a lot of pressure placed on these girls, especially the ones that are pretty good. The coach does a good job of supporting the less talented kids and promoting teamwork, but it's not easy and they still feel the pressure. I know my daughter beats herself up every time they lose and is very hard on herself when she makes a mistake.
- bluefirebrand 3y ago> Later in life, free from such delusions, rec sports are totally different. Nobody is out there trying to get a scholarship. Nobody dreams of becoming a millionaire. Nobody thinks that if they just manage to perform a little bit better, finally they will be popular and cool. Nobody thinks that they can finally satisfy their hyper-critical fathers if they just execute that play correctly. My experience with rec leagues is that there are always a few people who are hyper competitive from their youth sports days but they were not good enough to keep going. But they still act the same way in rec league. The amount of times I've been body checked by such people in no-checking hockey leagues is way too much
- ip26 3y agoIn retrospect my biggest obstacle in school was, nobody ever really taught me how to improve, and so I was never good enough to enjoy myself. The dominant culture focused on the value of grit and perseverance through suffering. I bought into it, and learned how to suffer, but your capacity for suffering is always limited. As a result, I would start to deplete my capacity and lose drive to practice before I got to see much in the way of results. Nobody taught me that you can slowly improve over months and years without having to dip into your capacity for suffering- and get better results. The sad part is, because you can get results this way, it’s easy to get stuck in this way of thinking. “If I was just a little tougher, I could shave 5 minutes off my half marathon time.” This is how people wind up permanently damaging their bodies, as they focus on ignoring the pain instead of getting better.