6 ms·
I wonder if studies support the effectiveness of doing anything productive. Exercise is good because it's easy to quantify the result: I ran 5 miles or I lifted
by SoftTalker 3y ago
I wonder if studies support the effectiveness of doing anything productive. Exercise is good because it's easy to quantify the result: I ran 5 miles or I lifted 5,000 lbs (cumulative) in that workout. Or I went X more distance or faster than last time. I can feel the results of that effort in my muscles and lungs.
But I've also noticed that simple stuff: I did the dishes, I folded a load of laundry, I fixed a leaky faucet, whatever. Anything that has an achievement or makes an objective improvement makes me feel better. I can see the result of what I've done.
Note that I don't get this from video games, social media, etc. Maybe some people do, but those things just feel more like escapes from reality. That is the difference for me. Sitting here reading HN occupies some time, but doesn't make me feel any better (in fact often I feel worse because I'll start thinking about what else I could have done with that time that would have been more productive).
- neilk 3y agoThis is an established theory in psychology. One model of depression is "learned helplessness". Something about your life has taught your mind and body that it's pointless to try. So literally anything that teaches you that you have agency is a counter to depression. It's probably best if it's a small thing, to start. I myself had a period where I "learned" agency by teaching myself vim shortcuts. I have wondered the same thing about exercise. It's a quick hack for learned agency. Very few people feel worse after a modest amount of exercise. Even a walk down to the corner store gets you a change of scenery, an amount of social interaction, and movement. It will improve anybody's day.
- Aurornis 3y agoThere's an entire field of therapy called "behavioral activation" that fosters exactly what you describe: Re-learning how to do things even when you don't initially feel like it. Part of the therapy is to recognize that your depressed brain isn't doing a good job of identifying things that will make you feel good. You then go through some exercises to identify activities that make you feel better and create plans to do them. Then you learn to observe how you feel after doing those activities, which starts the process of re-learning how to do things that make you feel better. There's obviously more to it than I'm describing here, but the underlying idea is that taking steps to relearn how to do and enjoy things actually does work.
- NavinF 3y ago> Note that I don't get this from video games That's highly surprising. What you just described (achievement, objective improvement, feeling better) is a major reason why people play video games.