3 ms·
There are certain other disabilities and neurodiversity’s that are “associated” with depression and it’s never quite clear whether it’s situational depression o
by hinkley 3y ago
There are certain other disabilities and neurodiversity’s that are “associated” with depression and it’s never quite clear whether it’s situational depression or intrinsic.
If all your grandparents die in six months, that’s situational depression. If dyslexia makes you feel like a failure with a secret, leading a double life, that’s situational. If ADHD means you keep hurting people you love and you never achieve your goals, situational.
Certain symptoms of ADHD respond well to repetitive motions. And walking/cycling/running/gum chewing/fidgeting/leg bouncing can help as a coping strategy. Successful coping means less situational depression, regardless of whether the activity also reduces depression.
I don’t think it’s a spectrum, I think it’s a grid. There are several things going on and there are quadrants that are dangerous and ones that are mediocre.
- wpietri 3y agoThis is a very good point. And I'd add that in a society tuned for the "normal" participant, I'd add that many differences create the opportunity for situational anxiety and depression that are invisible to people who are sufficiently "normal". E.g., living in San Francisco I know plenty of queer people who came here from more queer-hostile places. Or I remember a time before I moved out here when I spent a few days in a colo. It blew my mind that so many of the people walking in and out looked and talked like me. I realized that I had spent years being the odd nerdy person out without ever quite noticing how fraught that was. My baseline level of anxiety has dropped a lot living here.
- godelski 3y ago> I don’t think it’s a spectrum, I think it’s a grid. I'm a bit confused by what you mean here. A spectrum is continuous while a grid is discrete. It seems you're implying multiple dimensions but I'm not sure where I suggested one. I think I specifically gave 5, but will agree there's more than that.
- hinkley 3y agoIn a spectrum you can only move left or right to achieve relief. In a two dimensional problem, moving up or down may be the shortest route to getting from suffering to okay, and in some cases that transverse movement may take you from suffering to thriving.
- godelski 3y ago> In a spectrum you can only move left or right to achieve relief. We're going to have to agree to disagree then. Because that's definitely not the definition I use and find in plenty of textbooks. Those match what I said above
- rmwaite 3y agoI think you can have a 3-dimensional spectrum.
- godelski 3y agoI mean it can have n-dimensions. It's just common to discuss 1-d because we place things on a 1-d axis, not because the word itself means 1-d. Like political spectrum often refers to left vs right, but it can also refer to authoritarian vs anarchism. Really it just means a continuous function, there is no strict definition that this needs to be 1-d and that would be a weird thing to do in math. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spectrum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spectrum
- hinkley 3y agoOnly the social sciences section of that mentions anything greater than 1-d
- hinkley 3y agoSocial Sciences introduced the concept of a multidimensional 'spectrum'. I'm not a fan, and for the reason I more or less already stated: It conflates a multivariate problem with one having a single variable. The initial conditions affect success of any undertaking, and you're starting with your foot in a bucket. Newton and astrophysicists don't use it that way. They should have found a different word.