4 ms·
What personally helped me a lot is listening to Robert Sapolsky's lectures[0,1]. The reason I really like them is because they decompose depression into differe
by godelski 3y ago
What personally helped me a lot is listening to Robert Sapolsky's lectures[0,1]. The reason I really like them is because they decompose depression into different causes. He breaks it down into: Anhedonia, Grief, Guilt, Self-injury, and Psychomotor retardation. For example, if you are exhibiting anhedonia and psychomotor retardation then the SSRIs probably aren't going to work for you. But at the same time, if you have self-injury and psychomotor retardation giving you energy may actually kill you (you now have the will to act).
I think mental illnesses are very personal. It is still good to do studies like these, but they are also too aggregated. We put autism on a spectrum, I don't understand why we don't do for other things like depression. The most I see is anxiety/depression, like this. There's far more nuance involved and it isn't surprising that in these experiments that there are high variances. I'm not saying the studies aren't useful, but that these have been done for decades and it's time to add complexity to the studies. Nuance is necessary, but few people are taught to perform multi-variate analysis. It is always rather surprising given how many statistical "paradoxes" are due to aggregation errors.
[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc
[1] HTTP link, you will get warnings http://www.robertsapolskyrocks.com/depression.html http://www.robertsapolskyrocks.com/depression.html
- hinkley 3y agoThere are certain other disabilities and neurodiversity’s that are “associated” with depression and it’s never quite clear whether it’s situational depression or intrinsic. If all your grandparents die in six months, that’s situational depression. If dyslexia makes you feel like a failure with a secret, leading a double life, that’s situational. If ADHD means you keep hurting people you love and you never achieve your goals, situational. Certain symptoms of ADHD respond well to repetitive motions. And walking/cycling/running/gum chewing/fidgeting/leg bouncing can help as a coping strategy. Successful coping means less situational depression, regardless of whether the activity also reduces depression. I don’t think it’s a spectrum, I think it’s a grid. There are several things going on and there are quadrants that are dangerous and ones that are mediocre.
- wpietri 3y agoThis is a very good point. And I'd add that in a society tuned for the "normal" participant, I'd add that many differences create the opportunity for situational anxiety and depression that are invisible to people who are sufficiently "normal". E.g., living in San Francisco I know plenty of queer people who came here from more queer-hostile places. Or I remember a time before I moved out here when I spent a few days in a colo. It blew my mind that so many of the people walking in and out looked and talked like me. I realized that I had spent years being the odd nerdy person out without ever quite noticing how fraught that was. My baseline level of anxiety has dropped a lot living here.
- godelski 3y ago> I don’t think it’s a spectrum, I think it’s a grid. I'm a bit confused by what you mean here. A spectrum is continuous while a grid is discrete. It seems you're implying multiple dimensions but I'm not sure where I suggested one. I think I specifically gave 5, but will agree there's more than that.
- hinkley 3y agoIn a spectrum you can only move left or right to achieve relief. In a two dimensional problem, moving up or down may be the shortest route to getting from suffering to okay, and in some cases that transverse movement may take you from suffering to thriving.
- godelski 3y ago> In a spectrum you can only move left or right to achieve relief. We're going to have to agree to disagree then. Because that's definitely not the definition I use and find in plenty of textbooks. Those match what I said above
- rmwaite 3y agoI think you can have a 3-dimensional spectrum.
- Aurornis 3y ago> For example, if you are exhibiting anhedonia and psychomotor retardation then the SSRIs probably aren't going to work for you. Way too many depressed people avoid SSRIs due to generalizations like this. SSRIs don't work for some with those symptoms, but they're a life saver for others. SSRIs can also be helpful for pulling people out of a deep depression and getting them to a place where they can rebuild healthy habits, then taper off the SSRIs. Please don't discourage people from trialing SSRIs if they're in serious depression. There are also modern antidepressants that act not only on the serotonin transporter but directly on certain serotonin receptors to create more favorable side effect profiles. I've known too many depressed people who spent years avoiding SSRIs due to things they read on the internet, then finally gave in and tried them and discovered that it was the spark needed to get their lives back on track. Do not waste years and years of your life on depression for fear of experiencing negative side effects you read about on the internet. Work with a doctor and be open to trialing proven treatments for a reasonable period of time (6+ months).
- godelski 3y ago> due to generalizations like this. I'm rather concerned seeing this response. My comment is about more nuance, not less. That example has qualifies and is clearly not a catch all. The main thesis is that more nuance is required not... generalization. I do believe SSRIs work, just not for everyone. I'm very much not trying to discourage people from trialing them, so much as looking for other solutions if those trialing fail. Personally, SSRIs almost killed me. They just made me suicidal. The problem was that it didn't match my specific case. That's okay. The bigger problem was that every psychiatrist I tried just tried giving me a different one or told me to keep using them "until I levelize." This is doing far more danger than me saying "we need more nuance and stop using a sledge hammer for every case." You know what's actually dangerous? A patient saying "I stopped taking this because it made me want to die" and a doctor responding "that was unwise, you should have continued taking it." Who isn't going to come away from that thinking their doctor is trying to kill them. Experiences like mine are what drives the fear you are talking about. That's not on the patients, that's on the doctors. If instead they got SSRIs, found they don't work, and tried something else, found that it did work, people wouldn't write these stories. You're victim blaming. I could have personally gotten help more than a decade sooner if this nuance was in practice but instead it should be unsurprising that I used to be (note not now) passionate about not taking something that made me want to die. It's unsurprising that I refused to see any psychiatrist considering years of the same thing happening over and over. That's on the doctors, not on me. They taught me to be afraid. I'm saying there's absolutely no reason that should have happened.
- xk_id 3y agoYour reasoning is correct. Depression is an umbrella term, which covers a range of disorders with different neurocognitive aetiologies. This is the reason why patients will respond to pharmacological interventions with distinct mechanisms of action, and not to others: dopaminergic stimulants, monoamine oxidase inhibitors, glutamate receptor antagonism, catecholamine reuptake inhibition, secretion of neurotrophic factors in a particular brain region, etc. – while other patients suffer still from refractory "depression".