3 ms·
It is indeed quite common for poetry to violate the normal rules of the language. But that takes one of two forms: archaism, or a flaw in the poetry. (It's also
by thaumasiotes 3y ago
It is indeed quite common for poetry to violate the normal rules of the language. But that takes one of two forms: archaism, or a flaw in the poetry. (It's also common for poetry to violate the rules that govern the poetry itself. Composing poetry is very difficult!) Compare the opening of Mark Chesnutt's She Was:
She started her new life
Ten dollars in debt
That's all it took to get started back then
A trip to the courthouse across the state line
No one could stop her
She'd made up her mind
He was eighteen
And she wasn't
But she said she was / and never thought twice
And came back home as my daddy's wife
She just shook her head
When her mama said "Are you sure he's the one?"
But she was
Here we see some fairly complex temporal structure handled fluently, with no problems of any kind. The writing is better.
>> it can't be considered fluent English when seen as an isolated sentence
> Can't it? Why not? What's wrong with it?
The use of the simple past tense is not compatible with the sense of before that everyone here is trying to assign.