6 ms·
Plans to cut speed limits ‘will significantly improve road safety' – minister
- bluGill 3y agoProbably not unless the plans start with a road redesign so people drive slower.
- dr_dshiv 3y agoYeah, make Irish roads even thinner and more twisty!
- HackeNewsFan234 3y agoThe walls are too smooth and need some spikes added
- fsniper 3y agoSome local backroads are not limited enough and some motorways are limited too much. This won't do any good if this fact is not taken into consideration.
- wiredfool 3y agoI’m not aware of motorway speeds other than 120km/h except on the M50 and near tool booths. That seems appropriate and broadly in line with the rest or Europe. (edit: and It's not like everyone is cruising along at or above the limit. I pass a lot of cars in free flowing traffic when driving with cruise control on at 120) The 80kph roads that are double track with grass down the center are a ... fixture of the Irish rural environment.
- jiofj 3y agoA limit of 120km/h in a good motorway is a bad joke. The only purpose is to be able to give tickets to take money from people.
- panki27 3y agoSure, the reduced rate of accidents and emissions is just a useful side catch.
- wiredfool 3y agoThere are 2 countries I've driven in in Europe with higher limits, France (130 in good weather) and Germany (unlimited in some sections). UK is 70mph. Max I've seen in the US is 75mph. Most traffic in Germany, even in the unlimited sections, tends to max out around 130. France tends to hit that 130 and not go above it. I stand by 120 as a generally reasonable speed for a motorway with a speed limit.
- koolba 3y agoThere’s some 85 mph in the USA in Texas. Mostly 65 mph in the rest of the country though.
- hulitu 3y ago> There are 2 countries I've driven in in Europe with higher limits, Austria, Hungary, Romania, Croatia, Italy all have 130 km/h speed limit on highways.
- jiofj 3y agoSo basically you are saying that you have seen 130, that it works well, but you still stand by 120. Makes no sense. Where I live the upper limit is 120. If you drive at 120 people won't stop overtaking you. It's done this way because they have those mobile car radars to give people tickets when they need money.
- wiredfool 3y agoWhat I'm saying is that the natural speed is around 120km/h, even on the far nicer roads in Germany and France. If the limits there are higher, and the bulk of drivers still aren't driving faster, then maybe 120 is just fine for what we have here.
- fsniper 3y agoI was directly pointing to m50 on that count. It's not even an even limit on the whole m50. Some parts are 100km/h some parts are 120km/h. And I can agree that part is not much of a problem. But most of the rural 80km/h road strands are too dangerous.
- silvester23 3y agoIs there any data showing that you can have too many limitations on e.g. motorways?
- lazzurs 3y agoAnyone that thinks this is going to change anything in Ireland has never driven around Ireland. To say speed limits as taken as an amusing suggestion here is the biggest understatement I’m going to make all day.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoThe other side of the announcement was an increase in the amount of enforcement using mobile speed cameras. I suspect that'll make more of an impact.
- Mandatum 3y agoSame issues in New Zealand. Good roads capable of driving fast, but there’s too much traffic and they should have invested in infrastructure 30 years ago.
- cameronh90 3y agoIn the UK we're starting to install average speed cameras in lots of places. Almost every major road in my area has an average speed camera on some stretch. And I, for one, I think it's great. It's not a popular position but I'm a speed limit enforcement maximalist. I think if you're going 31 in a 30, after accounting for measurement errors, there should be enforcement action. Driving is one of the most dangerous things we do so I'm not sure why we're all so blasé about breaking this particular law.
- xnx 3y agoAmen. Enforce the limit as written or change the limit.
- ReactiveJelly 3y agoMe too. There has to be a hard limit. It might as well be the posted limit. Encouraging everyone to break the law just means selective enforcement is a bigger problem. If safety depends on cars moving the same speed, then everyone else should slow down to the speed limit to match my speed. I really don't get this brinksmanship stuff. "Oh it's just 5 MPH, it's just 10 MPH." A limit was posted. The negotiation process doesn't happen _after_ the sign is put up. It's very simple. All that said, I don't like ALPRs. They're so bad for privacy. I just know that they'll be connected to the Internet and used to track people wherever they drive, many of them already are.
- saiya-jin 3y agoSwitzerland has 120kmh instead of typical EU limit of 130kmh. Slightly less pollution of all types, slightly safer roads, cars last slightly longer. Typical swiss driver is anything but typical driver basically anywhere - polite, respectful, and just doesn't break rules in mormal situations. I really like it this way, and couldnt care less for the limit, saving 1-2 minutes is neglible every time. That being said, anytime I cross the border to Germany there are these few first minutes of going faster, our roof box is basically the limit so somewhere around 160. Without it, maybe 220. After few minutes novelty wears off, you realize how dangerous and frustrating in actual traffic such speeds are, and go back to something closer to 130. With fully automated driving, this wouldnt be a topic, I would be reading a book or sleeping. Looking forward to this.
- serpix 3y ago130km/h is just ludicrous. The consumption compared to 100km/h is about 50% extra and the time saved is wiped out with just one bathroom break.
- xcskier56 3y agoBut that bathroom break is going to happen anyways
- Spooky23 3y agoDepends on the car. With a V6, it’s pretty negligible. My SUV gets better mileage at high speed cruising due to the gearing. As long as you’re not constantly accelerating/decelerating and going with the flow.
- tcfhgj 3y ago> My SUV gets better mileage at high speed cruising due to the gearing. what model would that be? > As long as you’re not constantly accelerating/decelerating and going with the flow. this can save even more fuel, if your SUV still uses fossil fuels and you accelerate at the optimal engine load and then glide. It's called pulse and glide.
- tadasZ 3y agofor me the worst part about speed limits is - a lot of people can't even reach it, they drive 10-15 km/h less than speed limit and it drives me crazy
- londons_explore 3y agoSpeed limits are a classic safety vs economy trade off.
- tcfhgj 3y agoIn Germany a speed limit of 130 would save a billion euros each year[0]. It would also save fuel, i.e. carbon and particulate matter emissions [0]: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0921800923001131?via%3Dihub https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S092180092...
- londons_explore 3y agoBut it would cost people's time. I almost guarantee that even if you pay people minimum wage, the savings in people's time outweigh any extra fuel use.
- tcfhgj 3y agowhen it matters, i.e. traffic hours in the morning and evening, it probably would rather save time as less traffic jams will occur (more likely the higher the variance of velocities) > the savings in people's time outweigh any extra fuel use. opinion
- acdha 3y agoTry following traffic laws for a week and time your commute. You’ll find that you’re not saving anything significant at all - and unless you have unlimited piece work you can swap to any time you have an extra 37 seconds there’s no economic value to cancel out the fuel and elevated wear and tear on your vehicle.
- acdha 3y agoSafety versus making fun vrooming noises. Collisions cost enormous sums even before you think of the thousands of people who have life-altering injuries, and the vast majority of the time the driver is not saving any time at all (just sitting longer at the next signal or patch of congestion), or an economically negligible amount of time. Because speeding causes traffic congestion, there is a fair chance this would even be an economic win since tamer traffic moving consistent speeds is better for commercial drivers. Speeding helps on very long trips through lightly trafficked areas: if you’re driving on a desert highway through the American southwest, sure, going 85 instead of 75 will shave an hour off of your all-day drive but the vast majority of trips are much, much shorter than that and the risks to others are much higher.
- wiredfool 3y agoFor reference, we've just had "Speed Day" where the Garda goes out and mans the speed cameras. There are generally a set of known locations where this happens, and motorists being motorists, there's a bunch of headlight flashing just out of view. The Garda then give statistics of 0.3% are speeding, but look how fast some people went (typically 160 in an 80 or similar). The RSA, when they did free flow analysis, found more than 50% speeding, and higher percentages in urban areas than rural motorway. Meanwhile, small roads have slowly had their speed limits upgraded without corresponding infrastructure changes, such that 2 lane N roads over bogs with no shoulders can have 100kph (up from 80), in places where you can see the scrapes from frames hitting the pavement. The boundaries of towns have moved in, so that places that used to be 50 are now 60.
- JeanMarcS 3y agoIdeal would be speed limit based on the road. I drove some "roads" in Ireland, where speed limit is 80km/h but driving faster than 40km/h is daredevil behavior. And don't mention the fact that some roads are not large enough for crossing another vehicule, but it can happen (and sometime the locals drive at 80... A lot of surprise braking !) But it's obviously more difficult to implement, and more difficult for the speed camera management. Yet, it would be better and certainly safer than the "one speed for those type of road fit all" (to be honest, this proposal is more advanced than other countries where you hav three or four types of speed limit, and that's all)
- throw3747874747 3y agoThis! Some country side roads are very narrow, surrounded by stone walls on both sides. There are no sidewalks obviously.
- comprev 3y agoThe road from Head of Dunloe down into the Black Valley is 80km/h. You'd be lucky to push 40 on the straight sections!
- super256 3y ago> and more difficult for the speed camera management. In Germany the police needs a specific reason for placing a speed camera. Like a statistic that there are a lot of accidents on that street at that particular spot, or that the street is exceeding noise levels. So, they already have to take into account every individual speed limit; and if the Germans can do this, the Irish can certainly too! :)
- comprev 3y agoThe statistics provided regarding deaths neglected to say most were probably _way_ over the speed limit. I'm talking 130km/h in a 50km/h zone. There was a tragic case a few weeks back (on exam results day I think) when a speeding car was totalled in an urban area killing 3/4 occupants. Reducing the speed from 100 to 80 won't change that behaviour.
- sachahjkl 3y agohow about 0 ? how about we do nothing and nobody moves ? this way we'll be 100% sure that no one can get in a car accident, that'd be sooo cool guys :D
- sixstringtheory 3y agoYes, but only for people as dumb as you
- dynm 3y ago> In urban, residential and other built-up areas the limit would be cut from 50km/h to 30km/h. > The limit on main arterial routes in towns and cities would be capped at 50km/h. > On national secondary roads, the baseline would fall from 100km/h to 80km/h. One thing I always wonder with changes like this is, why make such a dramatic change (a 40% reduction in urban areas) in a single step? It seems more sensible to make the the change more slowly and study the results. Or, even better, make the change in half the country and let it run for a year as an experiment. (This could be a multi-armed experiment when you compare to, e.g., increasing enforcement instead.)
- tcfhgj 3y agothese speed limits aren't anything new and their impact is well known
- wiredfool 3y agoBecause speed limits are quantized: 30, 50, 60, 80, 100, 120. The 50->30 (30->20 mph) is a well known baseline 0 change for built up areas. It's meant to be not for major roads, it's meant for neighborhoods and other areas with many pedestrians.
- diffeomorphism 3y agoFirst answer is simplicity: you have a few prototypical road types and speeds and easy to remember round numbers. E.g. 30 signs are common for inner cities, 50 for outer, but 40 or non-multiple of 10 is extremely rare. That is also reflected in gears for cars, i.e. going at those speed requires very little active input by the driver while going at exactly 42 would need constant manual adjustment. > It seems more sensible to make the the change more slowly and study the results. That was already done locally and other countries exist. So you would have to argue what makes Ireland that unique that further experiments are needed.