3 ms·
The mindset of sacrificing computing freedom for user convenience and corporation profitability. We should be absolutely uncompromising on this one value. The a
by matheusmoreira 3y ago
The mindset of sacrificing computing freedom for user convenience and corporation profitability. We should be absolutely uncompromising on this one value. The alternative is the destruction of everything the word "hacker" ever stood for.
> nothing but an endless digital mall to browse
Funny, that's essentially what the web feels like to me in 2023. Escaping it is the number one reason why I visit HN nearly every day. It's like the only sane website left. I don't even open the links posted here anymore, websites are just unbearable these days even with uBlock Origin turned up to the max. I just assume whatever's important enough will be directly quoted in the comments.
The "static web" you and the commenter below mentioned? I actually kind of want it.
- marginalia_nu 3y agoDude, my struggle is to be able to operate a non-profit service free of charge with no ads, and the aim is to help users find a way out of exactly the aforementioned digital mall and onto the free and independent, mostly static web. This is harder every day dude to all the bot traffic helping themselves to disproportionate usage of my service via a botnet that is all but indistinguishable from human traffic. But yeah, must be the corporate profits I'm hoarding...?
- matheusmoreira 3y agoWhy is it relevant whether the traffic is human or automated? The whole point of the internet is you can put a server out there and anyone anywhere can connect to it with any HTTP client. To me it seems like the only people who care about that are those who want to sell our attention to the highest bidder via advertising. Wouldn't you be having the same difficulties if there were just as much traffic coming from humans?
- marginalia_nu 3y agoI want to provide as many human beings as possible with value by distributing my processing power fairly between them. If I get DDoS:ed by a botnet, I won't provide anyone with anything other than optimistically an error page. If I had infinite money and computing resources, this would be fine, but I'm just one guy with a not very power computer hosted on domestic broadband, and even though I give away compute freely, it just takes one bag of dicks with a botnet to use it all up for themselves, and without bot mitigation, I'm helpless to prevent it. Oh and I actually do provide an API for free machine access, so it's not like they have to use headless browsers and go through the front door like this. But they still do. Serves me right for trying to provide a useful service I guess?
- matheusmoreira 3y agoI see. I respect that. The bot detection won't come without cost. It will centralize power in the hands of Cloudflare and other giants. I think it's only a matter of time until they start exercising their powers. Is this really an acceptable tradeoff? If we do accept it, I think the day will come when Cloudflare starts rejecting non-Chrome browsers, to say nothing of non-browser user agents.
- marginalia_nu 3y agoI don't see any good options at this point. The situation profoundly sucks for everyone involved. We're stuck between the almost absurdly adversarial open web, or bargaining with the devil at Cloudflare, and now Google's remote attestation which is basically Google taking a stab at the problem. To be clear I don't think remote attestation is a good solution, but it's at least a solution. Any credible argument against Cloudflare or remote attestation needs to address state of the open web and have some sort of plan how to fix it. Or at least acknowledge that's what Google and CF are trying to solve. Dismissing the problem as a bunch of mindless corporate greed just doesn't fly. It affects anyone trying to host anything on the Internet, and is only getting worse. The status quo and where it's heading is completely untenable. It's easy to say well just host static content, but that's ceding all of Internet discovery and navigation and discussion and interactivity to big tech, irreversibly pulling up the ladder on any sort of free and independent competition in these areas. That's, in my opinion, a far greater problem.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoYes, I agree with you. It sucks having to make these choices and compromises. The adversarial nature of the web is difficult for service providers but it's actually ideal for users. We all benefit from being able to connect to servers using any browser, any HTTP client. This is especially true when the service providers don't like it. Software like yt-dlp is an example of software that interoperates adversarially with websites, empowering us. I apologize if I came off as aggressive during my argument. It was not my intention. I think we reached the same conclusion though. Maybe the true problem is bandwidth is too expensive to begin with. Would the problem still exist if the costs were negligible?
- bryanrasmussen 3y ago>Why is it relevant whether the traffic is human or automated? because all traffic costs for the service provider, but the automated traffic can be run at thousands of users cheaper than it is to run one human user (who after all is bounded by time and cost of computation and bandwidth) whereas the automated is not bound by time, giving them the opportunity to DOS you - either on purpose or just accidentally.
- zb3 3y agoBut the solution for this is a rate limit, not captcha. The real reason they care about "human traffic" is because bots don't buy stuff.
- bryanrasmussen 3y agoyou're the first person to say anything about Captcha? The guy who started this argument needing some way to sort out human traffic operates a free service and is complaining the bot traffic makes it hard to offer a free service since bots cost money.
- zb3 3y agoBy captcha I meant "telling computers and humans apart", not necessarily a particular implementation. Why are you focusing on bot traffic? Doesn't human traffic also cost money? Who operates bots and why?
- marginalia_nu 3y agoThe problem is allocating resources fairly. A single human may operate tens of thousands of bots, and thus use disproportionate amount of resources, possibly all of them.
- marginalia_nu 3y agoRate limits do all of bupkis against a botnet. It's not possible to assume that each one IP or connection is one person. The crux that all of these initiatives like remote attestation are trying to solve is that as it is, one person may command tens of thousands of connections, and from a server-standpoint, there's really not much you can do to allocate resources fairly.