3 ms·
Wouldn't they be stealing power, then? Going from the murky world of copyright infringement, to straight-up stealing a service seems like a pretty terrible ide
by pavel_lishin 15y ago
Wouldn't they be stealing power, then?
Going from the murky world of copyright infringement, to straight-up stealing a service seems like a pretty terrible idea.
- sliverstorm 15y agoYeah, but the further we take this into the grey area the smaller the leap will be to adding anti-personnel defense capabilities!
- pavel_lishin 15y agoWhat grey area? It's illegally tapping a power line.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- marshray 15y agoPower distribution lines are already a major inefficiency loss to the power company. It's unclear if there would be any additional parasitic loss from the recharging bot, the efficiency of the system as a whole could in fact be greater than if the bot plugged into a metered outlet. Kind of suits the piracy debate rather well actually. :-)
- A1kmm 15y agoIf you put a coil up to a HVAC line and draw current from that coil, that is going to increase the impedance of the line and reduce the amount of power that can be delivered at the other end. Yes, the energy loss would probably be tiny in proportion to the energy transmitted and the resistive loss on a power line, but it is nevertheless a real loss to the power company. It could be more efficient than plugging the bot into a metered outlet, but the power company gets paid for energy drawn from a metered outlet. By analogy, it is more efficient for a retail shop if you steal goods from their warehouse before they are stocked on the shelves than if you buy them off the shelves, but the first case is a net loss for the retail shop, while more efficient, because they don't derive any revenues, and the second case, while less efficient, leads to an increase in profit for the shop. This is quite different from piracy, which has no direct marginal cost - copyright was created to allow the recovery of fixed costs on certain types of work when there are low marginal costs to production.
- marshray 15y agoMy understanding is that at transmission line voltages, a big source of power loss is via corona discharge. There are electrons and ions moving near the power lines. Perhaps it's possible to obtain a some of that power at a low rate without coupling back-EMF to the lines.
- weavejester 15y agoThe electric grid loses a lot of power through inefficiencies anyway. If anyone did try this, I've no doubt the electric companies would be (rightly) very pissed off, but more about the potential risk to their power lines than the actual power lost.
- chronomex 15y agohttp://message.snopes.com/showthread.php?t=9291 http://message.snopes.com/showthread.php?t=9291
- weavejester 15y agoLighting a barn requires a heck of lot more power than sending out a wifi signal, even a fairly strong one.
- pavel_lishin 15y agoI lose money through inefficiency because sometimes I drop coins on the ground and don't bother going after them, but if you start reaching into my pockets for my pennies, you and I are gonna have words, followed by fists. It's not that they/I worry about watts/pennies, or even that they/I worry that you'll damage the powerlines/pockets, but that it's outright theft.
- weavejester 15y agoHuman beings have the luxury of being irrational about their finances, whilst publicly traded corporations are supposed to be able to justify their financial decisions. If a CEO says, "I hate stealing, so I'm going to spend 10 million dollars year of the company's money to stop 10 thousand dollars in power theft." then I don't think that's going to impress the company's shareholders.