3 ms·
> Remote update mechanisms can themselves present security problems in some domains. I've proposed many times that the device have a physical write-enable swit
by WalterBright 3y ago
> Remote update mechanisms can themselves present security problems in some domains.
I've proposed many times that the device have a physical write-enable switch on it, not a software switch. That way, a malware infestation won't survive a reboot, and your backup hard drives won't get compromised.
I'm amazed that nobody does this. (Hard drives used to have a write-enable switch on them.)
- landemva 3y agoWhy doesn't MS do similar on all of their OS code by placing it on a read-only filesystem? Only allow updates when reboot into an update mode.
- WalterBright 3y agoI have zero faith in software read-only modes.
- Too 3y agoAndroid does this. OS is read only. Updates happen on second partition and takes effect by swapping partition on reboot. Integrity is verified by secure boot.
- landemva 3y agoInteresting. How is it verified? Maybe keep Merkle tree hash of eveything in TPM?
- structural 3y agoMany flash chips have write enable pins at the hardware level. So this support really does still exist in theory! However, these pins mostly aren't used for any kind of switch in basically every PCB design I've seen. Either it's "always enabled" so the storage can always be written, or it's a chip that's programmed from the factory and always disabled to prevent any kind of user update.
- WalterBright 3y agoI'd sure hate to have my system ransomware compromised, and when I try to restore from a backup drive, the ransomware encrypts it, too, as soon as I plug it in. I also have, on occasion, flipped the from and to parts of the command to restore from a backup. I'd really like to have a hardware switch to make the drive read-only.
- fragmede 3y agoThey exist, but only as very expensive specialty gear for digital forensic investigators. https://digitalintelligence.com/store https://digitalintelligence.com/store
- WalterBright 3y ago> very expensive Indeed, for a 2 cent switch.
- structural 3y agoThese also exist for removable drives (not really any different price compared to normal drives, in wide use) in the govt/defense market, where using a hardware write switch when moving data between airgapped systems in a controlled way is common.