3 ms·
>You can't form a governmental system based on altruism. It has to be based on people acting in their own interests Nobody has ever proposed pure altruism. We
by eli_gottlieb 15y ago
>You can't form a governmental system based on altruism. It has to be based on people acting in their own interests
Nobody has ever proposed pure altruism. We've often proposed a system based on mutual/collective self-interest pursued cooperatively instead of individual/corporate self-interest pursued competitively.
Example: the NHS or Canadian health system versus the American health system. I chose this answer because the answer is really bloody obvious. You would never think that many small risk-pools competing against each other will somehow yield a better ability to spread out risk than a handful of pools, or even a single large pool containing everyone. The interest of the individual taking out insurance is clearly to place themselves in as large a risk-pool as they can in order to defray their own costs.
So what leaves us with insurance companies and HMOs in the States? Capitalist dogma that pronounces that Many Competing For-Profit Entities Beat a Single Central Non-Profit Entity Every Time. But what functions are we envisioning these entities performing? Those for a capitalist health system are, in fact, envisioning HMOs and insurance companies as businesses first and actual risk-pools second, whereas those for a single-payer system are envisioning insurance as fundamentally being about risk-pools and discarding the goal of profit-seeking entirely in favor of mere cost-recovery where possible.
Not surprisingly, each system results in exactly the thing it optimized for! The American system puts out gigantic profits for insurers/HMOs at the expense of both the collective public (through Medicare/Medicaid) and the individual public (through premiums, deductibles, high prices for medical procedures). The Canadian and British systems successfully spread out the risk of requiring treatment for sickness over the entire population.
Like freaking magic. And you can design other things this way.
- fidotron 15y agoI think I agree with you, although I certainly don't think either the Canadian or British systems are perfect. The Canadian ban on private health care has its own serious problems, and the PFIs in the UK are a mess. Those systems have resulted in their own (possibly) unintentional but utterly predictable side effects. The other classic that Friedman and co used to point out is the minimum wage. That said, I support the NHS etc. for entirely selfish reasons. I don't want to get sick, and more importantly I don't want other people making me sick. (Also not needing medical cover for employees is great for small companies). If there's an easy way to balance this I don't think it's been found yet.
- eli_gottlieb 15y agoNothing is perfect, but there are very different conceptions of citizenship at work. The proposed one, to which I object, is the capitalist/neoliberal conception of a citizen: a pseudo-"rational" actor in a political and economic war of all against all for the sake of individual and incorporated self-interest in the form of money and property, restrained only by statutory and Constitutional law from attacking their competitors. I counterpropose the traditional social-democratic vision of citizenship: a partly-emotional actor who participates in collective decision-making to pursue their values and their collective interests, thus enhancing their private life by placing it in a more secure public matrix. >The other classic that Friedman and co used to point out is the minimum wage. Funny how everyone listens to Friedman et al when they propose eliminating the minimum wage, collective ownership of commons property, or most social services, but not when they suggested a citizen's income or a negative income tax.
- moldbug 15y agoHow do you feel about the East German medical system? Could you design other things that way? The current American system is not an example of free-market medicine, it's a strawman of free-market medicine. It's pretty hard to have a free-market system with a central price-fixing committee. Does the term "RVU" mean anything to you? See under: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Specialty_Society_Relative_Value_Scale_Update_Committee http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Specialty_Society_Relative_Valu... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gosplan http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gosplan For a non-strawman, you'd need a system in which fee for service, catastrophic insurance (ie, actual insurance - the correct solution to your "risk pools"), and charity care were all separated. Look at any Anglosphere country before 1940, and add modern technology. The separation of charity and paid care (universal before 1940) is the absolutely essential reform, and it's so politically incorrect that no one on either side can even mention it. (Even the word "charity" is almost illegal.) For instance, the Canadian system is a reasonably good charity health system extended to the entire population. But Canada has to make private medicine illegal, to prevent the middle class from inventing it. As it is they just resort to the United States. And I haven't even mentioned medical innovation, which has ground to a giant flaming fscked-up halt. No, if you were designing something that you didn't want to suck, you wouldn't start with any of the existing solutions.
- praxeologist 15y agoYou are so right. Look at the continually improving capabilities and continually decreasing prices of computer chips and notice that this results from market processes. The same can be seen in health care where government is rarely not involved (Lasik). The only fundamental difference between health care and any other good or service is that it is "really, really important" and people are more apt to fall for "We're with the government and we're here to help."