7 ms·
The shrinking number of primary care physicians is reaching a tipping point
- telotortium 3y agohttps://archive.ph/lzjyv https://archive.ph/lzjyv "Opinion" Seems like the primary issues are poor compensation and lack of respect.
- HDThoreaun 3y agoThe primary issue is that there aren't enough residencies so we don't train enough doctors. There are literally millions of competent Americans who would love to become primary care doctors but can't.
- gloryjulio 3y agoIt's just like the housing issue. It's not that we don't want to build more housing stock. The system is broken and artificially limited the supply
- deprecative 3y agoWe don't want to allow people to utilize the resources we have. There are more houses than housed and unhoused people but we keep building more and pricing out the poors. The poors grow in number every year. We just don't care. We like our society this way. This is what we want.
- fallingknife 3y agoThis is a ridiculous argument. There are 143 million housing units in the US and 600k homeless. That means that a vacancy rate of 0.4%, or 1.5 days per year is enough to make that true. Vacancy just due to people moving will greatly exceed that number.
- deprecative 3y agoYou're proving my point while disagreeing with me? I'd like for that to be a new one. We want this. This is us.
- analognoise 3y agoI don't know how accurate it was, but I read that 27% of Canadians were fine with MAID (medical assistance in dying - i.e. euthanasia) for those whose only affliction was "poverty". https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/canada-maid-assisted-suicide-homeless https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/canada-maid-assisted-su... I've been thinking about that a lot recently. You're right: this is who, at least a large group of us, are.
- defrost 3y agoThat's very much the worst possible spin on people's feelings with a framed poll and National Post reporting though. It could equally be argued that 27% of Canadians do not agree that MAID should be restricted, the poll question was preambled: At this point, only an adult with a grievous and irremediable medical condition can seek medical assistance in dying in Canada ... and went to list other conditions (povety, homelessness, disability, etc). One extreme interpretation is that all those replies indicate support for culling the weak. The other extreme interpretation is that all those replies support the self determined right to seek assisted suicide regardless of conditions.
- fallingknife 3y agoPeople love to take these statistics and make them something they are not and complain about how terrible our society is. It makes them feel morally superior.
- the_d3f4ult 3y agoThis isn't true for primary care. There are tons of open spots every year that are filled by International graduates or aren't filled at all. The problem is nobody wants to do this job.
- giantg2 3y ago"filled by International graduates or aren't filled at all." Do you have a source for that? The stuff I saw says that a certain number of slots are reserved for international students, which further constrains the supply.
- fhsm 3y agoThe following document seems to be the definitive source, supports the larger point of speciality dependent results, and was my first google result: https://www.nrmp.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/Advance-Data-Tables-2023_FINAL-2.pdf https://www.nrmp.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/Advance-Data...
- giantg2 3y agoThanks! Yeah, looks like there are some openings. Also looks like that is one specialty that has increased its slots by over 25% in the past 5 years. Progress
- the_d3f4ult 3y agoSure. Here you go: https://www.nrmp.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/Match-Rates-by-State-Specialty-and-Applicant-Type-2023.pdf https://www.nrmp.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/Match-Rates-...
- tacticalturtle 3y agoI think requiring 11 years of post high school education (undergrad + medical school + residency) is a pretty big reason why we don’t have enough primary care doctors. It’s such a huge investment of time and money, that it’s very hard to convince anyone to get into the field. We have this immutable education track, seemingly because that’s the way we’ve always done it in the US. But I’d be very curious if we actually achieve better outcomes than countries with shorter medical educations. The article mentions that NPs and PAs also favor higher lying specialties - but it seems much easier to solve that supply and demand problem than paying the cost for more MDs
- HDThoreaun 3y agoThere are far more med school applicants than spots every year. They can't expand because of residency constraints, sure all that stuff would lead to more people wanting to become doctors, but the people who want to be doctors now largely can't. That problem would only be worse with less education.
- okaram 3y agoActually the issue is not residency; basically everyone who graduates med school gets a residency. The filter is on entering med school.
- HDThoreaun 3y agoNo. Med schools desperately want to expand because they make a ton of money, there are not enough residency slots for them to expand without competent graduates going unmatched.
- naveen99 3y agoWhile there are more residency spots that graduating medical students in the us every year, they do have to compete with foreign grads, of which there are more than enough. So the us grads can’t be completely and openly incompetent. So some of them do fail to even graduate, and obviously not get residency spots.
- breadwinner 3y agoThis is intentional, to keep salaries high. Only in USA do you have to get a random degree before you can go to a medical school. The only purpose served here is to reduce the number of doctors.
- candiodari 3y agoNote: lack of respect for primary care physicians by government and insurance companies. Not by patients or the general public. Of course, the end result of all the short-term cost saving, is that care is switching to emergency only, which is a lot more expensive for everyone.
- telotortium 3y agoAlso lack of respect from the medical profession. Hanging out with pre-meds at elite universities, it was considered a bit of a disappointment to only get a GP or internal medicine residency - good students try to get speciality residency. This is of course downstream of the lack of compensation from government or insurers - specialties earn more, unless you're willing to become a physician in a rural hospital.
- jwestbury 3y agoThe lack of respect by insurance companies is startling. Insurance companies effectively govern what care people receive, rather than doctors. I paid almost $1000 last year for a sleep study to diagnose sleep apnea, because my insurance company wouldn't cover it -- I wasn't high-enough risk. Turns out, I have severe obstructive sleep apnea. I'm just glad I was in a financial position to pay for the study myself.
- bell-cot 3y agoA complex system ruthlessly optimizes for profits...and is anyone surprised that other metrics grow worse?
- ramesh31 3y agoSpecialists aren't much better. Try getting a dermatologist appointment. It's almost comical now. The whole system is collapsing under load.
- arbitrage 3y agoA dermatologist has been consistently difficult to get an appointment with for twenty years in some places.
- fhsm 3y agoDermatology is playing on a different level now: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6659155/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6659155/
- Spooky23 3y agoThat will get worse. They are consolidating with private equity money and pushing quasi-medical skin products. If you have a mole or something that needs to get checked out, try a plastic surgeon.
- darth_avocado 3y agoAnecdotally, I have been using one medical since 2015. Initially it was the best service ever, you could find a ton of Physicians and Family doctors. But it started getting worse every year. Now, there are 0 doctors in my area, only nurse practitioners. As much as I buy the argument that not everyone needs an MD for primary care, I do absolutely think NP are just not sufficient. Too many times have I gone with an ailment that was met with “let it run the course” or “try this OTC medicine”, that eventually escalates into a more serious problem that put me out of commission for weeks. Thank god I have a job that didn’t fire me. And the other times it is met with “let’s just order a bunch of tests or see a specialist to be safe”, which would have been handled very differently by an MD.
- bboygravity 3y agoThis sounds like every MD in The Netherlands is equal to NS in the USA :p
- ofjcihen 3y agoAlso an anecdote but I’ve had the same experiences. The one that sticks out to me was a few years ago. I’m prone to sinus infections and this one just wouldn’t go away. I booked an appointment with an NP. She took a brief look at me and then advised that I go to the hospital because “you might have a brain tumor”. I told her I get sinus issues all the time. She responded that her sister died of a brain tumor. So off to the ER I went and 2k later I had an ER doc look at me like I was an idiot and diagnose me with a sinus infection.
- darth_avocado 3y agoFunny, I wasnt specific in my example, but my bad experience that I had in mind was also about a sinus infection. I had the flu symptoms and I booked the first appointment after the usual “let it run it course” period and specifically said that this feels different. Got the “let it run…”, waited another week, booked another appointment, got a bunch of otcs and finally when another week passed, I went to urgent care and the doctor there immediately diagnosed it as sinus infection and prescribed be antibiotics. Was feeling better after that in 3 days.
- treis 3y agoUrgent care is one of those scams so brazen that they can do it out in the open and get away with it. They bounce almost everything to the ER and essentially charge twice for the same work. Once at the Urgent Care and once at the ER. It's such a fantastic business model and essentially is doubling their profits. It's not just private equity pulling these shenanigans. Our local Children's chain is a non-profit and they pull some real shady shit.
- giantg2 3y agoI wouldn't doubt that some urgent cares do shady stuff. The ones I've dealt with were great. Knowledgeable doctors (not just NPs or PAs), decent facilities, variety of common services like x-ray, blood draws, etc. One upfront fee for the visit and additional services are cheap ($30 xray, $10 blood tests). Really not bad.
- tptacek 3y agoLike a lot of people, I exclusively go to urgent care for routine stuff, and for the first line of care for anything more serious, and I have never once had the experience of being bounced to an ER. They share records with my PCP but can see me at the drop of a hat on no notice. People overuse doctors. Most of what younger people (under, say, 50) go to the doctor for, a good NP can do just as well or better. One of my weird hobbyhorses is how dumb the name "nurse practitioner" is; they should just call them "associate physicians". (Note here that we're talking about "urgent care", which are clinics run by health chains, staffed with a doctor or two, a couple NPs, and a bunch of nurses; "urgent care" is not the ER, which is a thing people gotten hung up on HN about before, because I guess every country calls their ER something different. Going to the ER for routine care is insane.)
- TylerE 3y agoI've been "bounced to the ER" once, but that's because the x-rays showed pneumonia, and my vitals were... not in a great spot. Even then it was phrased as more "If it were me, and I had similar comorbidities, I'd get that looked at ASAP" Ended up hospitalized for 4 days.
- 3y ago
- bachmeier 3y agoMy primary care doctor informed me a few days ago that he's shutting down his current practice. Appears to be driven by his desire to get away from the insurance companies. He's part of a new practice where you pay a monthly fee and everything's included. You can text and email with questions, stop by for an appointment and get right in, and so on. The advantage for him is that he never deals with insurance companies again. The disadvantage for me is that, since I have few health issues, and they're minor when I do, it would cost a lot more per year.
- alexpotato 3y agoThe crazy part is this is how it used to work. One of the older models for a physician went like this: - you opened a practice - you charged a "subscription" to be a part of your practice - people could come as much as they wanted What's crazy to me is that MORE doctors don't do this since I'm 100% sure there is a demand for a service like this.
- QuarterReptile 3y agoWhen you have a market as distorted as medicine in the US, it's not just that crazy things happen, but also that normal, functioning versions of the thing are crowded out by the inescapable pull of the distortion.
- Spooky23 3y agoMakes sense. Primary care would be better like dentists. The monopolies formed for these health networks are bad for everyone. The staff are miserable, patients don’t heal, and half the time the companies are losing money. My primary care was bought by a hospital network, which was bought by some multi-state network that is under financial stress yet just boight another regional network to ruin.
- hcurtiss 3y agoThe two shops around here charge about $175/month for a family ($80/month single adult). That's a difficult price to swallow when you have insurance through work, which almost everyone able to pay $175/month does. There's probably some value, but I need a doctor so little, I just can't see paying for it. It's competing with services like Zoomcare, which is basically an on-call online-scheduled prescription service which works very well for my purposes. I struggle to see these Direct Primary Care services getting off the ground unless they're in a very affluent neighborhood where price doesn't really matter anyway.
- diogenescynic 3y agoIt's weird how there's a scarcity of all the important things--physicians and medical specialists, houses, cars, etc. Why can't is supply not increasing to meet demand? It seems like our modern economy has lost focus on the basics. It seems like a scam more than anything.
- polygamous_bat 3y agoThe age of value creation has passed us by, now is the age of value capturing. If you're creating value, you're a loser to those who specialized in capturing the value you produce.
- hardtke 3y agoThe supply of doctors in the US is primarily limited by the number of residency slots. Unlike many countries, foreign medical graduates can't practice here without doing a residency. I think the number of residency slots is kept low by the federal government (which funds them) and also by physician organization lobbying.
- maxerickson 3y agoThere aren't rules against entities other than the federal government funding a slot.
- fallingknife 3y agoWhy does the federal government need to fund residency slots? They generate tons of billings and get paid next to nothing. Should be very profitable.
- HDThoreaun 3y agothey're not. As far as I understand every single one loses money before accounting for federal subsidies. Many are actually closing.
- diogenescynic 3y agoExactly, just like the number of homes is artificially limited by zoning, permitting, etc. It's all artificial scarcity and it's for life's essentially--which is why I said it's a scam because it seems intentional.
- jncfhnb 3y ago> And fewer medical students are choosing a field that once attracted some of the best and brightest because of its diagnostic challenges and the emotional gratification of deep relationships with patients. Is this true?
- the_d3f4ult 3y agoYes. https://www.nrmp.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/Match-Rates-by-State-Specialty-and-Applicant-Type-2023.pdf https://www.nrmp.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/Match-Rates-...
- jncfhnb 3y agoI meant the qualitative reasoning behind it
- neuronerdgirl 3y agoThat's not the reasoning, its a continued descriptor of "that once attracted the best and brightest"
- jncfhnb 3y ago> because of its diagnostic challenges and the emotional gratification of deep relationships with patients.
- scioto 3y agoI've already outlived my ancestors, and the world's a pretty dismal place, or at least the US is, so why not let an otherwise preventable disease take me 20 years earlier?
- leoqa 3y agoI’d like to get a few more rounds of counter strike in if I can
- candiddevmike 3y agoYou sound depressed, everything OK?
- scioto 3y agoOh yeah. Just a little bit of snark-slash-commentary since humans are being treated as profit centers. My FP of 20+ years also retired after selling his practice, as per the article. I do think it's sad (no, I'm not depressed!) that the race to the bottom, with a dash of enshittification, now encompasses health care, which we all need.
- okaram 3y agoBecause I want to see my kids become full adults? I want to meet my grandkids? There's still a lot of things I want to see and do.
- costco 3y agoI had a sort of similar view and then I heard about a boy attending kindergarten in my area with Sanfillipo syndrome. There are different types of it but basically their bodies can't break down certain kinds of carbohydrates which means that they accumulate in their cells and eventually cause havoc. As a result, they continuously lose motor and brain functions until they die at about 20. There are no cures. Him (well, I don't know how much he knows given his age) and his parents would probably kill for more days. It also made me realize that my day to day problems were utterly trivial and that I should be grateful for even having day to day problems.
- mannyv 3y agoMedicine in the US has become a game of billing for the most number of procedures possible. For those doctors that don't want to play, well, they go concierge. In primary care especially the fees are low, and to be any good you need to explain things to the patients - which takes time. In the current medical billing culture it's about throughput, so taking time to explain falls by the wayside. This is industrial medicine.
- tptacek 3y agoPrimary care makes up a relatively small percentage of all medical spending, especially considering how important its role is in our system.
- mannyv 3y agoThe problem is prevention is worth less than the cure. Attia talks about it in his book - the heroes of medicine are the ones that operate and save people, not the ones that ensure that people never get to that poont/
- ryandrake 3y agoI moved a year ago and still have not found a new primary care doctor. The search is almost comical: Take a search space of all doctors within 50 mile radius. Now start applying filters: Must be "in network" with my insurance (-A%), must be of specialty "primary care physician" (-B%), must be accepting new patients (-C%), actually picks up the phone when called or returns your call (-D%). A%xB%xC%xD% leaves me with about 3 candidate doctors. New patient appointments are out 3 months for Doctor X, 5 months for Doctor Y and 9 months for Doctor Z. Doctor X So I set up an appointment for Doctor X. 3 months later, the front desk receptionist calls and informs me that Doctor X is unavailable on the day of my appointment, so I need to make a new appointment--a wait of another 2 months. So I make that appointment. 2 months later, front desk receptionist calls and says Doctor X is retiring and no longer taking patients. Doctor Y Next I set up an appointment for Doctor Y. 4 months later, I get a call from Doctor Y who informs me he is also no longer taking new patients. Doctor Z Finally, I now have an appointment with Doctor Z for some time in 2024. Fingers crossed... It seems a better strategy would have been to just set up appointments with all of them in parallel and just go with the first one to actually want to take my money. When people try to argue against socialized medicine they like to point out how the American system doesn't have wait times, and systems like Canada and U.K. make you wait many months for a doctor. Obviously they haven't tried finding a USA doctor recently.
- tptacek 3y agoIf you had an actual problem that needed a specialist, and you had a PPO plan (most people do), you'd pick a regional provider chain and find their urgent care, walk in, and get an initial consultation done the same day. Stipulating you need a specialist, they'd make a referral, which you could either use directly or use to book with another specialist. Last time, I was 6 weeks out for my referred specialist from my PCP, and 3 days out from the one I called. It is annoying to book an annual physical, and to establish a long term PCP relationship. It takes forever to book my PCP; months. But I've learned simply never to go to my PCP directly for stuff.
- wintermutestwin 3y agoI have a PPO, but each specialist I contact still wants a referral from my PCP. I suspect that it is the insurance companies that create this and every other distortion of our ridiculous HC situation in the US
- the_d3f4ult 3y agoI'm a medical sub-specialist. When I trained, my primary care mentors were simultaneously some of the smartest and most poorly compensated physicians in the system. I have to master a very narrow body of knowledge to function well. To make a good differential, a family medicine physician has to know a lot about everything. This skill saves the medical system tons of money by preventing unnecessary testing, lab work and specialist referrals. It also saves lives and dramatically increases patient quality of life. I can't emphasize enough how hard this is to do since, in the American system, you can be held liable for any missed diagnosis. You have to be sure that you're correct and it's much easier to just order everything and discharge the liability to a specialist. Practicing primary care in this era is a nightmare. Like the article says - most clinics are run by PE or hospitals that push 'providers' to see a complex patient every 10 minutes while absorbing none of the liability for rushed, low-quality care. The compensation for these positions is now significantly less than most of the salaries that you see in the "Who's hiring?" threads on HN except with a tremendous amount of liability attached, a ton of customer service and a guarantee that your salary will go down relative to inflation. The idea that NPs or PAs could just fill in the holes in our primary care system was always laughable to anyone who understands how medicine is actually practiced - to do the job well you need well trained, highly intelligent people. The punchline of the joke is that very few PAs/NPs ever intended to go into primary care and now the market is flooded with "Psych NPs" and "Derm NPs" pedaling Ritalin and botox. Nothing will fix this problem short of a complete, ground-up rebuild of our healthcare system.
- wrs 3y agoThe fundamental problem with US health care is that the incentives are exactly backwards. With “fee for service” the prevailing system, of course we get the maximum number of “services”, with providers being driven to provide the most specialized and rare “services”. All while the primary care doctors, who are the ones avoiding the need for services, also known as keeping people healthy, and thus are the most valuable from the point of view of actual societal good, are being driven away. The system literally generates more revenue the sicker people are. So it’s no wonder it optimizes itself away from keeping people from getting sick. It worked for a while, perhaps because most doctors have morals, but now it seems the shareholders are in charge rather than the doctors. There is an alternative (“value-based care”) that is slowly catching on, as the governments and companies paying for all these unnecessary services are starting to wonder if there’s a better way. Essentially, you pay a fixed amount per person, so the system is incented to keep people healthier, not sicker. But lord, there are so many entrenched interests fighting against improvement. And even that system can of course be gamed at the expense of society.
- philwelch 3y ago> There is an alternative (“value-based care”) that is slowly catching on, as the governments and companies paying for all these unnecessary services are starting to wonder if there’s a better way. Essentially, you pay a fixed amount per person, so the system is incented to keep people healthier, not sicker. This sounds like rationing. Sorry buddy, they only pay a fixed amount per person so we can’t actually afford that expensive surgery or MRI or whatever else you need, go home and walk it off.
- viraptor 3y agoThe costs per person are pooled in those cases, similar to insurance, so it's expected that some people will "use what others paid in". That's ok. And sure, you can call it rationing, but whatever model of funding you're thinking of, at some point you'll get to make a decision like "do we spend 5M to save those 6 people or that 1 person?" - it's not a few layers detached.
- wrs 3y ago
- ProllyInfamous 3y agoYou cannot pay a physician enough for the sacrifices they have made — just to an ugrateful diagnose You. To any pre-medical students, please seriously consider a better pathway forwards. There are literally SO MANY BETTER METHODS "to help people" and "to make money." If these are two of your primary reasons for joining medicine, please spend the time thinking about how you want a well-lived life. src: dropped out of medical school, after ER rotation, prior to ACA. Hadn't thought enough about a livable professional experience. I became an electrician.
- WirelessGigabit 3y agoFinding a doctor in general is becoming harder. When you check the insurance site all you see is NPs and PAs. I just moved to the area, I don't need an NP. An NP can't even prescribe me my meds. And that hip surgery I had? Yea, I need to see a doctor, not a PA who just sends me for an MRI and then refers me to a doctor. And then there are DOs. Also something I avoid. Insurance is really trying to pay less for a visit... They can start by not re-imbursing homeopathic stuff & chiropractors.
- tacticalturtle 3y agoIf you’re purposefully avoiding DOs, then yes, it’s going to be hard to find a doctor. They take the same licensing exams, and the same residencies.
- droidist2 3y agoWe paid for this. In the late 90s we purposely reduced the number of doctors graduating from medical school. U.S. WILL PAY TO REDUCE DOCTOR GLUT Washington Post, August 24, 1997 https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1997/08/24/us-will-pay-to-reduce-doctor-glut/c0092e65-84af-4225-a9d8-abc5a8213e96/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1997/08/24/u...
- philwelch 3y agoI have a primary care doctor now for the first time in many years. I don’t know how essential it is to keep his practice running, but he also does cash-only appointments for weight loss prescriptions. Insurance is probably a bad model for primary care compared to fee-for-service, and one way around it is to do a separate fee-for-service practice that lots of people will want or need.
- rabbits_2002 3y agoWhat are primary care doctors for? They either just prescribe OTC drugs or refer you to a specialist that you can just schedule yourself. Primary Care usually has a >month waiting list so its not for emergencies. No doctor I have had takes questions without an appointment or even picks up their phone. I just skip them entirely now and go to a specialist if I have a health problem.
- DontchaKnowit 3y agoIn my experience specialists will not take patients without a referal. So that is the express purpose of a primary care. Referalls. That and vaccines/physicals