6 ms·
I wrote this after the 'PG has lost the plot' thread. I didn't like the title, but the content was fairly good. People really seem to have trouble visualizing
by davidw 15y ago
I wrote this after the 'PG has lost the plot' thread. I didn't like the title, but the content was fairly good. People really seem to have trouble visualizing "that which is not seen":-)
- eli_gottlieb 15y agoBravo and bingo. These are the exactly the frustrations I tend to feel as an unpaid, open-source coder. And the next level of the phenomenon is that the entire software industry has shifted its business model to avoid having to compete with piracy or open-source. There are now, to my knowledge, two major for-profit companies building their own PC operating systems: Microsoft and Apple. There are four or five building mobile operating systems: Apple, Microsoft, Blackberry, Google, (maybe) Symbian. The number of for-profit IDEs and programming platforms is still mostly healthy, but much, much smaller than it once was. "That which is not seen"? That is, the effect of this privative of profits on the real world? Almost whole fields have shifted over into the domain of unpaid, spare-time open source work. Thousands, millions of man-hours are expended for no salary and no equity. Think what would happen if all the open-source programmers (paid and unpaid) went on strike. Now you're realizing the economic value of open-source code that goes completely uncaptured by its producers. Yes, the result is that less gets done, because everyone has to find day-jobs, and that the software industry has changed almost entirely from product business models to service business models. Now, another scary thought: what if someone stole the code and databases to your web-service? You say that your contacts and relationships are what really makes your web-app worth something, but frankly, that's a load of crap. I'm sure there are some starving Chinese coders who would love to steal your code and your data, bring up their own web-service identical to yours (but in Chinese), get a few million users, and then translate theirs back into English for North American and European usage. The "relationships and business expertise" excuse sounds much like what everyone said when America sent its manufacturing overseas: "We'll do all the high-value services and design and development work here." Well, no, the manufacturing was itself high-value and the other high-value points in the supply chain eventually followed it, and we're China's bitch now. There is an imperative to enable value-creators to capture some portion of the value they create as cash. Otherwise the entire foundation of not only capitalism but all possible market economies breaks down into mush.
- bunderbunder 15y agoI think it might be instructive to think of what the world was like before the idea of letting people who create intellectual products maintain some ownership of (and therefore be more able to make a living from) their work: - Serfdom was still legal in most of Western Europe. - Professional artists occupied the same social rung as prostitutes. - An intellectual professional's primary option for making a living off his (that pronoun being sufficient for the era) work was patronage. - The vast bulk of intellectual output served the primary purpose of glorifying the political and religious Powers that Be. Of course that doesn't imply that the current copyright and patent law isn't enormously out of hand, or that it doesn't largely function to the detriment of creative professionals thanks to the grotesque ways in which it has been amended over the past three or so centuries. But the basic idea is admirable, and it can and should be salvaged.
- davidw 15y agoI think so many things have changed that looking at 'before copyright' is not likely to yield much, because it's "before" so much else as well. I very much agree with your conclusion though.
- npsimons 15y agoI can play this game too: you know what the software industry was like before Microsoft and Apple? EVERYTHING was open source. When you bought a program (if they didn't throw it in for free with the bloody expensive hardware) you ALWAYS got source code. People still sell open source software; I've never understood why people think that commercial software is incompatible with open source. It isn't.
- bunderbunder 15y agoI can play this game too: you know what the software industry was like before Microsoft and Apple? EVERYTHING was open source. And yet, computing professionals were much less free than they are now. Because programmers almost universally worked at the King's pleasure. The exception to that rule was small garage shops. Like Microsoft and Apple.