10 ms·
I'm not good enough to work on open source software
- davidw 15y agoI wrote this after the 'PG has lost the plot' thread. I didn't like the title, but the content was fairly good. People really seem to have trouble visualizing "that which is not seen":-)
- eli_gottlieb 15y agoBravo and bingo. These are the exactly the frustrations I tend to feel as an unpaid, open-source coder. And the next level of the phenomenon is that the entire software industry has shifted its business model to avoid having to compete with piracy or open-source. There are now, to my knowledge, two major for-profit companies building their own PC operating systems: Microsoft and Apple. There are four or five building mobile operating systems: Apple, Microsoft, Blackberry, Google, (maybe) Symbian. The number of for-profit IDEs and programming platforms is still mostly healthy, but much, much smaller than it once was. "That which is not seen"? That is, the effect of this privative of profits on the real world? Almost whole fields have shifted over into the domain of unpaid, spare-time open source work. Thousands, millions of man-hours are expended for no salary and no equity. Think what would happen if all the open-source programmers (paid and unpaid) went on strike. Now you're realizing the economic value of open-source code that goes completely uncaptured by its producers. Yes, the result is that less gets done, because everyone has to find day-jobs, and that the software industry has changed almost entirely from product business models to service business models. Now, another scary thought: what if someone stole the code and databases to your web-service? You say that your contacts and relationships are what really makes your web-app worth something, but frankly, that's a load of crap. I'm sure there are some starving Chinese coders who would love to steal your code and your data, bring up their own web-service identical to yours (but in Chinese), get a few million users, and then translate theirs back into English for North American and European usage. The "relationships and business expertise" excuse sounds much like what everyone said when America sent its manufacturing overseas: "We'll do all the high-value services and design and development work here." Well, no, the manufacturing was itself high-value and the other high-value points in the supply chain eventually followed it, and we're China's bitch now. There is an imperative to enable value-creators to capture some portion of the value they create as cash. Otherwise the entire foundation of not only capitalism but all possible market economies breaks down into mush.
- bunderbunder 15y agoI think it might be instructive to think of what the world was like before the idea of letting people who create intellectual products maintain some ownership of (and therefore be more able to make a living from) their work: - Serfdom was still legal in most of Western Europe. - Professional artists occupied the same social rung as prostitutes. - An intellectual professional's primary option for making a living off his (that pronoun being sufficient for the era) work was patronage. - The vast bulk of intellectual output served the primary purpose of glorifying the political and religious Powers that Be. Of course that doesn't imply that the current copyright and patent law isn't enormously out of hand, or that it doesn't largely function to the detriment of creative professionals thanks to the grotesque ways in which it has been amended over the past three or so centuries. But the basic idea is admirable, and it can and should be salvaged.
- davidw 15y agoI think so many things have changed that looking at 'before copyright' is not likely to yield much, because it's "before" so much else as well. I very much agree with your conclusion though.
- npsimons 15y agoI can play this game too: you know what the software industry was like before Microsoft and Apple? EVERYTHING was open source. When you bought a program (if they didn't throw it in for free with the bloody expensive hardware) you ALWAYS got source code. People still sell open source software; I've never understood why people think that commercial software is incompatible with open source. It isn't.
- bunderbunder 15y agoI can play this game too: you know what the software industry was like before Microsoft and Apple? EVERYTHING was open source. And yet, computing professionals were much less free than they are now. Because programmers almost universally worked at the King's pleasure. The exception to that rule was small garage shops. Like Microsoft and Apple.
- billswift 15y agoOf course, another factor is how ending copyright might redirect a lot more resources into open source. Without being able to benefit from rents that come from keeping proprietary code, how many companies would switch to using and improving open source alternatives?
- davidw 15y agoIt's very easy and simple to pay $100 to use some bit of software. It's way harder to actually contribute to it meaningfully. Software markets solve a coordination problem. Not perfectly, but reasonably well. Same thing goes for many other kinds of information goods. No way would I pay an author to sit around writing a book, but I'm happy to give them $5 for a copy.
- bunderbunder 15y agoMine certainly wouldn't, because we would likely go out of business if people stopped paying us for the software that we create.
- j_baker 15y agoAs someone who has been paid to work on OSS, let me say that it is absolutely not about skill. Most notably, Google and Mozilla pay plenty people to work on Firefox and Chromium. Even Apple has some OSS projects (Webkit and Darwin come to mind).
- davidw 15y agoIt was a bit tongue in cheek - I have actually had paying gigs working on open source in the past. But the point about where the money comes from stands - Google's money comes from their proprietary stuff. I actually think something like Google is a pretty good way to produce open source software, by the way, but it's made possible by the money made elsewhere.
- gcp 15y agoI'm not sure it was necessary to refer to the "I'm not good enough" thing. It really has little to nothing to do with your point. Because you've just undermined your own example (Guido Van Rossum / Python / Google) above, it weakens your position. If I get it correctly, your point is that one requires copyright for open source software to be viable, by opening up a revenue stream to support the (free) open source part. This is true. You can make money form open source on either: 1) Selling alternate, source closed licenses. (MySQL for example) 2) Selling support, consulting. (Red Hat, many others) (1) requires copyright. (2) maybe less so, but without the open source licenses, which require copyright law to work, the software wouldn't exist to begin with either. Red Hat uses trademarks (which really are similar to copyright) to reinforce their position. So does Mozilla.
- davidw 15y agoI know you can make money from open source. It's difficult though. The title was something of an attempt at linkbait (albeit not a very good one), but also a way to point out that effectively, it is harder to get paid to work on open source software.
- simonbrown 15y ago
- crcsmnky 15y agoInteresting perspective but I have to say there are quite a few companies working the whole "open source the code, charge for consulting, etc." thing. Just in data alone, Cloudera, Data Stax, Basho, 10gen and Hortonworks come to mind. My point is that thousands of people get paid to work on open source projects. The project might not be their original creation but they still get to give back by producing something that everyone can use. Isn't that really the point anyway? EDIT: added a missing 'not'
- thekungfuman 15y agoThis business model is fairly popular in education. We have tons of open source projects where we COULD run it for free, but sometime we pay for hosting, or consulting, or customization. It seems to work well too.
- falcolas 15y agoFIWI, I have personally not heard of a single one of those companies. To continue the OP's concept, these are likely companies with employee counts in the single or double digits, whereas closed source companies have employees in the 5-6 digit ranges, reinforcing the "I'm not smart enough to get paid writing open source" concept the OP presented.
- davidw 15y agoThe problem with consulting is that you first have to have a product. That can take a lot of time and money to produce. Then, if you start consulting, it's all about billable hours. Hours spent fooling around making the product better may not translate, at all, into more money for the company.
- antirez 15y agoI guess that in some way a lot of companies are taking from open source without giving enough back. Open source is much cheaper than proprietary software to produce, a team of a few guys do the work of what would be a much bigger team in a proprietary software, and there is no need to have a profit, paying the developers is enough, so... if companies using open source would give back even a small amount of money... But maybe some global "fund" should be used or something like that, I don't think that giving to the project you use is going to scale (we don't want a few guys rich, and nothing for all the rest, otherwise it's a company). But then bureaucracy starts to be an issue, who selects the right projects? And so forth. Not trivial. Or maybe the solution is that if you are an enough large company, hire N open source developers. Like charity there should be a non written rule that most tech corps should follow. Like the 1% rule: hire 1% of your work force to write open source (and probably this would end being a largere return about branding than many ADs large companies run for more money than that).
- JoeAltmaier 15y agoIF open source is The Way, it wouldn't need subsidizing. It sounds like all utopian arguments: If Only everybody came around to the right way of thinking, we'd all be better off. Sure its true, but it aint gonna happen.
- antirez 15y agoyep, but it's strange because it's hard to think at the whole IT economy of today without open source. The idea of startups itself was completely different. What Unix? buy a license, with proprietary hardware maybe, and then purchase the web server license, and the compiler... So soon or later it's gonna happen maybe as everything is posing on this base.
- ajross 15y agoI don't think resources are really the problem. There's a ton of money out there that pays for full-time open source developers. Basically all the core contributors of all the "serious" projects (i.e. things shipped in high-revenue-producing contexts) are already on staff somewhere. It's true that there's a much larger population of people (like me) who want to work full time on open source and would take a job if it was offered. But that just gets to what the linked article is talking about: companies don't generally "staff" free software projects with new hires. They hire the projects that already exist. So basically the solution, if you want one of these jobs, is to get off your butt and make something people want. Then give it away. :)
- jasonlotito 15y agoThe article is confusing. He talks about intellectual property, copyright, and open source. He seems to confuse intellectual property and copyright (or at least, use them interchangeably), and seems think that open source and copyright are at odds. That open source licenses rely on copyright indicate this isn't the case. Maybe I just misread the entire thing, but I honestly don't see the message he's trying to get across. It feels like their is a massive amount of context that is missing from this.
- kisielk 15y agoAn interesting perspective. I too would like to spend more time writing open source software. The main reason I do not, and something which I think holds true for a lot of people, is that even if our company wanted to open source some of our software it's fairly difficult to do so and of questionable value. Many of the components and practices in our software are quite specific to our business and environment. They'd just be useless or, worse, an impediment to other people wanting to reuse the software in a different context. Even if we were to refactor parts of our code base to produce some "clean" components that didn't rely on the specifics of our business or other processes, there are many cases where that would just add to the overhead of maintaining the software for us.
- riledhel 15y agoYou are understimating the value of your software. You never know who can find your work inspirational or educational, even entertaining.
- jdost 15y agoOddly, in the age of the internet, it is easier for someone to do open source at least part of the time for their employer. With the internet, a lot of the money for web based companies is not from the software itself, but the services the software provides. This allows for the company to open source a large chunk of the code base and still make money to pay the developers. (see things like 37signals/RoR)
- aliguori 15y agoI'm paid to work on Open Source full time and have been for the better part of a decade. I don't really agree with anything the article says. Open Source development is a segment of the industry. Getting a job in Open Source is really no different than getting a job in Game Development, Robotics, or any other niche market. You generally have to (1) be willing to accept less pay (2) be more flexible about relocating (3) have specialized skills and experience or just get really lucky.
- phrontist 15y agoThis throws the absurdity of capitalism in our faces: Guido, a guy who developed software that benefits hundreds of thousands even by conservative reckoning, can't work on it full time.
- SirDinosaur 15y agoFor those interested in sustaining themselves by making open / libre software, I plan on dedicating my next summer to starting a cooperative for hackers. The basic idea is that if we can create a decentralized ecosystem for exchanging currency, ideas, and goods in an open and cooperative manner, we can solve our needs as hackers without resorting to non-free alternatives. You can find my early planning here: https://github.com/SirDinosaur/hackercoop https://github.com/SirDinosaur/hackercoop, and I'd greatly appreciate any questions, comments, critiques on how to make my / our dream possible.
- DanBC 15y agoHow do you solve taxes?
- SirDinosaur 15y agoLet's rephrase the question: how do we solve taxes?
- DanBC 15y agoIn the UK: Taxes are complicated but mostly solved. Either your employers deduct taxes before you get your money or you are self-employed and pay an accountant to sort it out; and people you buy things from add taxes before you buy stuff. If you are rich you get an accountant and practice various forms of avoidance (legal, but those loopholes may close soon, and of dubious ethicality) to evasion (not legal). Missing from the above description are people involved in barter economies. There are several barter economy systems in the UK. The UK tax collectors (HM Revenue and Customs) are clear: barter trades can be taxable. Suggestion: Find an accountant that would like to work as part of a co-operative. The collective either has one big joint account (like a business) or lots of individual accounts - either way good accounting will legally minimise tax burden and help with other stuff.
- SirDinosaur 15y agoAwesome, thanks for the suggestion. Do you suppose the accounting could also be automated, with help from an accountant, as part of the system that facilitates exchanges? My current thinking is to create a system that can be used by anyone, not just those within a single collective.
- kungfooguru 15y agoWhy does this have a single up vote?