3 ms·
> > They seem quite impossible to solve until you try a bunch of things, sometimes for years/decades, throwing stuff at the wall > Do you see what you did ther
by crazygringo 3y ago
> > They seem quite impossible to solve until you try a bunch of things, sometimes for years/decades, throwing stuff at the wall
> Do you see what you did there? That's breaking things down and trying lots of small things.
No it's not, that's my whole point.
If you're trying to find a filament that will work for a commercial light bulb, then testing out 1,000 materials is not breaking anything down to solve the problem. Instead, it's trial and error. They're literally the opposite approaches.
Some problems are solvable through fragmentation. Many others are just fundamentally not, and these obviously tend to be the more difficult ones.
> If anything, LLMs can help make non-linear thinking more efficient by getting you out of small areas of focus
That's literally the opposite of breaking things down into small steps. So now I don't even know what you're arguing anymore. But also, I don't see how LLM's help that in the least. I have not seen any examples of LLM's demonstrating "non-linear thinking". They literally work, well, with linear token prediction -- one token at a time.
- PaulRobinson 3y agoPerhaps you could provide an example of a hard problem that was solved that wasn't done so through breaking a problem down into small pieces. No academic paper ever written, invention ever created or piece of art I can think of or heard of (including general relativity, which was referenced earlier in thread), was solved by just sitting there and thinking about the big hard problem and solving the big hard problem in one go. The closest I can think of what you're referring to is an accidental discovery, so I think that's where our lines are crossed. At its core I still don't buy that LLMs are useless in the context of solving hard problems. You disagree. Time and experience will tell, but it seems more likely that successes will be attributed to them than not.