3 ms·
> Ask HN: Is there a “spend more money” problem in political discourse? Probably somewhere. There's more of a tax less, restrain spending problem in political
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> Ask HN: Is there a “spend more money” problem in political discourse?
Probably somewhere.
There's more of a tax less, restrain spending problem in political discourse in the US.
> One major problem we have here in the UK is that people will not accept any other solution to our healthcare problems other than spend more money on the NHS.
Clearly not really a problem with policy as much as it may or may not be with the discourse; UK share of GDP spent on the NHS was essentially flat for the decade pre-COVID, starting and ending at 10%, and varying between 9.6%-10% in between.
> The amount of government spends per capita far more a product of the country's GDP per capita than of relative tax rates and government deficits.
That thesis is essentially that government spending is a conatant share of GDP. Pre-COVID, whose effects on spending haven't completely passed, UK government spending as a share of GDP had declined for the preceding decade.
Not only is government spending not a constant function of GDP, there's little evidence that spending more than can be afforded, on the premise that affordability is a constant function of GDP, in the UK, but the opposite seems to be the general case.