4 ms·
Zzz. Expecting the delivery workers to eat the difference between "5-second hand-off to somebody who's waiting at the street entrance"* and "gotta secure their
by bell-cot 3y ago
Zzz. Expecting the delivery workers to eat the difference between "5-second hand-off to somebody who's waiting at the street entrance"* and "gotta secure their vehicle & stuff and get through your building security and figure our where your apartment is and trek up there and..." is an age-old "treat your servants like shit because you can" move.
*The article is very clear that the delivery app's Terms of Service specify "street-level entrance only". [Added footnote. Credit: ballenf.]
- arijun 3y agoComparing it with a 5-second hand off is like one of those bar graphs that cuts off the origin to make the difference in the bars look bigger. It’s more a difference between a 15 and 18 minute delivery. Not nothing, but I don’t see a huge difference between that and someone who lives 18 minutes away. I personally go down to meet them, but mostly because it’s faster for me to run down than wait for them to take my slow elevator.
- bell-cot 3y ago15 minutes vs. 18 minutes - that's roughly a 17% pay cut for the driver, plus assumption of liability (for theft). I'll guess that ~100% of folks here on HN would feel themselves blatantly screwed over if they were on the receiving end of that deal.
- dingnuts 3y agoIf I was a disabled person who would have immense difficulty getting to the street and back again, I sure would hope I could pay an extra 3% or have that cost built in, because going to the street would defeat the purpose of getting delivery.
- forgetfreeman 3y agoRight, but given population statistics it's a pretty safe bet that the majority of individuals involved here are not disabled in any meaningful way and are making life difficult for their delivery drivers for their own personal convenience. It's interesting to me how quick folks in the comment section are to try to take cover behind some dude in a wheelchair.
- iLoveOncall 3y agoActually it's a 0% pay cut because you pay for apartment door delivery. It's a 17% theft if the delivery driver doesn't come up.
- bell-cot 3y agoCite? The article seems to clearly state otherwise: > ...representatives from both companies told Rest of World, their rules already require delivery workers to only go as far as a street-level point of contact, from which customers are asked to collect their meals.
- jabradoodle 3y ago1. Read the article 2. Have some compassion, delivery drivers are not rolling in cash
- iLoveOncall 3y ago1. It doesn't matter what are the terms and conditions for this particular application, it's a topic that touches every delivery app and most give you the option to request delivery at your door and have drivers not respect it. 2. If they don't like the game they should stop playing it. If it's not worth it for them to do deliveries where they actually have to deliver, then they can look for a job that is more worth their time.
- jabradoodle 3y agoOf course it is relevant, it is what this thread is discussing. You could say the same about anyone being underpaid or treated poorly; this is what regulation is for. These people are trying to make a living and not everyone has good job opportunities available to them.
- saberience 3y agoWhere I live it's definitely NOT the difference between 15 and 18 mins. I'm on the 69th floor on a tower with fairly strict security and nowhere to really park outside, so it's really more of a 10 minute (minimum) process to find parking, go through security, find the right lift (there are 10 lifts going to different floor subsets), waiting for the lift (sometimes can be several minutes if they are in use). So basically it's a big pain in the ass for delivery people who are already not being paid a livable wage.
- wruza 3y agoThere’s no problem unless a service specifies entrance-only delivery. All parties agree to the same contract. But if you still prefer to eat that cost, the company they contract with will pocket it through market means. Not them. Same for tips, they pay those who are underpaid. Delivery drivers are unprotected, period. It’s an unregulated low-skill high-competition job, these suck systemically. You can’t unsuck it by personal means.
- kranke155 3y agoNot quite. The Brazilian elite (that’s middle class and above, considering 30-40 million Brazilians live with hunger or near hunger) live in a dystopia of their own making where both parties are at risk of violence here. Virtually all middle class and above housing is a tall tower with gates and security around it. Often double gate or triple gate. Just the time to get across that can be 5-10 min. If it’s your first time due to the need for ID. The driver who leaves his bike outside risks losing it, but the person who comes down to get their food risks the driver being armed and robbing them or kidnapping them. Thus you have a sort of a Prisoner’s Dillema where nobody wins and everyone loses (except the app). For the customer the safest thing is to get the driver through the triple lock, then have him drop off the food at your door inside the building and leave it there. For the driver the safest and most efficient is to drop it off at the security at the door, but these days the security sometimes is virtual only anyway, there is no one to drop it off to, just cameras and fingerprint sensors. So there is no way out of the game, except like many have said the apps should just charge for doorstep delivery. But this makes their lives more complicated, so they’d really like not to even if it results in death and robbery for both parties. Capitalism in Brasil hits different.
- avar 3y agoCan't those towers implement goods hand-off points in the longer term? I.e. bulletproof glass with a tray through which you can pass goods back and forth?
- kranke155 3y agoI believe some do. I was there for two months this year but can’t say I ordered delivery food. Some cities will have different systems and every tower is a bit different. I imagine it’s the same thing as any other solution - it will cost money and any opening in the tower security will be gamed and exploited by criminals. That’s likely why it’s not common. The level of criminality and insecurity in Brazil is unusual even for global standards I think. The level of gaming and exploration of any security system by criminals is surprising for people from the outside, and there’s a lot of externalities. Some stories I’ve heard (and was not surprised about): - during the pandemic criminal groups in Recife pretended to be City workers dealing with COVID to get inside the towers and assault apartment buildings - a person in Fortaleza (one of the least safe places) went to the bank to make a large withdrawal to help her father buy a 2nd hand car (I think). As soon as she drove away an armed possy stopped her car and told her to give them the money (which they knew she had). Someone at the bank tipped them off (After that she decided to move) Brazilians are a wildly creative culture. You see this in song and music and whenever you see a Brazilian running a business