5 ms·
Geezer* Perspective... [*If not in the USA, read "Old geezer". Credit: Aachen] Many varieties of "I really regret that I [did|didn't] do X when I was younger
by bell-cot 3y ago
Geezer* Perspective...
[*If not in the USA, read "Old geezer". Credit: Aachen]
Many varieties of "I really regret that I [did|didn't] do X when I was younger" occur in older humans.
The stereotype of young men wanting to avoid all the work and commitment of setting down, marrying, and raising children is older than the pyramids. It is obviously not true of all young men, but there's very seldom been a shortage. Sure, their feelings may change as they grow older - but a young man whose main motive for marriage is "so I don't regret not having kids when I'm old" strikes me as a young man who the young women should avoid.
In some cases, I get the sense that "I really regret not having children" is mostly a way of articulating "I am old and socially disconnected and feel lonely and depressed". In the modern world - where kids generally grow up and move far away for jobs - having had children would probably not help much with that.
- basisword 3y agoI feel like most young men have always wanted to extend their youth and avoid the responsibility that family life would bring. However, until recently (with easy access to birth control, abortion, and proper education) this wasn't really possible. You would accidentally have a child and be forced into the lifestyle you were trying to avoid. And most of the time things worked out and you were forced into a situation that's probably better for you rather than delaying it until it's too late. Now that we have 'choice' things are more difficult because you need to actually commit to something life changing. For most people it's impossible to know the 'right time' to do that or for them to have the courage necessary to take the change.
- ant_li0n 3y agoWow yeah you really hit the nail on the head for me. My wife and I weren't trying to have kids but we weren't trying not to have kids either, if you get my drift. Looking back on it, if we had been "smart" about deciding when the right time would happen, we might never have had kids. Having kids is hands-down the best thing I've ever done but also the hardest. Not because of the amount of work, because it's really not that much work. It's more of the dramatically uncomfortable shift in perspective: Realizing I'm not the main character in this story. It still hits me sometimes.
- mbg721 3y agoThe thing that struck me about having kids is that no individual task is all that hard, but there are a lot of them and you have to be available at all times. It can wear you down like any other on-call situation.
- anon291 3y agoThe entire phrase 'trying for kids' is a neologism only enabled by birth control For most of history, people just did what you did and had the results you did
- bryanlarsen 3y agoOn the contrary, "trying for kids" was accompanied by an elaborate ceremony to kick off the process. This big ceremony was often so successful that the kids would arrive 5 months after the ceremony!
- em-bee 3y agoone person can have a child in 9 months. so two people must be able to have a child in half that time. the math checks out.
- dagw 3y agoTrying for kids means making sure you have sex at the right times of the month, something humanity has known about for millennia. Equally people not 'trying for kids' made sure to only have sex at the 'wrong' time of the month, again something humans have been doing for millennia.
- cafard 3y agoHow many millennia? Mary Beard in SPQR writes that the Romans had the right time of the month as wrong as they could.
- anon291 3y agoUp until very recently, there was very little knowledge that pregnancy lasted nine months... even among the 'learned'. Old pregnancy manuals talk about pregnancies taking anywhere from a few months to many many months. Without ultrasound and HcG tests, there is very little indication a woman is pregant until she starts showing or feeling the baby (and even then, a new mother may not even notice until she's showing anyway). As for fertility awareness, I don't believe the methods used prior to the modern day were super effective. Regardless, the knowledge was not present. So I'll restate my claim. Up until the modern day, there was no such thing as trying for children. There were married couples engaging in socially sanctioned sex, which obviously leads to children. Or there were fornicators that we knew could have children, but was socially unacceptable, and few fornicators actually wanted children from their unions.
- beardedwizard 3y agoMy experience was that you will never feel "ready" to have kids, you just close your eyes and go for it. I think it is a good idea to look at finances and relationship health; but beyond that I'm not sure much else matters. It's almost the same as marriage - and your comment is insightful in that when given the choice humans will almost never choose to change, being "selfish" feels great while you are doing it.
- etrautmann 3y agoThat’s exactly my experience (typing with an eight week old sleeping on my chest. I can’t imagine feeling 100% ready before, but the 9 months leading up to the delivery is time to mentally shift and prepare for the enormous change.
- bevesce- 3y agoI don't understand why selfishness comes in this context. I'm considering if and when have children because not doing it would be reckless and egoistical playing with somebody else's life
- beardedwizard 3y agoSure, it's ok to feel that way too.
- em-bee 3y agoi think the smart thing to do is to have kids when you are 20 and then enjoy life when you are 40. at that time you are much better off financially (unless you live in a country where you have to pay for your kids education maybe) which gives you a lot more freedom to explore your interests.
- tonyedgecombe 3y agoLooking back I don't think I would have been ready at twenty. Also I couldn't afford a house at the time but could at thirty.
- em-bee 3y agothe expectation to need to be able to afford a house before you can have kids is something that is very wrong with society today. (but at the same time the difficulties today to afford a house is also something that has gone wrong. and i suppose the expectation to have a house made more sense when it was still possible to afford one. either way something here needs to change.)
- mofosyne 3y agoEh it's rational to expect stable housing before having kids. Even during medevial time, while you don't have much freedom, you have at least the certainty and stability of a place to live and a role to play. I don't think modern society does that anymore.
- em-bee 3y agowell, over here, renting is considered stable housing because we have sufficient protection for renters. i keep forgetting that this is not the case everywhere.
- poisonborz 3y agoThat's an opinion an algorithm could come up with based on raw data, but in real life you will not enjoy life the same way when you are 20, especially given at what life stage other 40s are at in most societies.
- rcme 3y agoWhy is wanting to do X now so you don’t regret not doing X later not a valid reason for wanting to do X? I want to eat lunch now so I’m not hungry later. I want to study hard now so I don’t regret not studying later. Aren’t most motivations essentially based on the possibility of future regret?
- permo-w 3y agodepends on your personality. for me, most of my motivations are based on what I feel like doing right now
- bell-cot 3y agoTHIS. People vary greatly in how strongly they weight the present vs. the future when they are making decisions. (And they're often darn inconsistent - being (say) very-long-term in planning their career, yet reckless about their health and safety.)
- JKCalhoun 3y ago> where kids generally grow up and move far away for jobs - having had children would probably not help much with that. Companionship was never a part of why I fathered children. And in hindsight, raising my daughters was the most meaningful thing I did in this life. I'm just suggesting that there may be other motives for parenting. Big Brothers and Sisters of America is an organization that pairs men up with boys who are in single-mother families (and I guess now women with single-father girls). (I was a "little brother" when I was young.) I am not sure about whether a single male is eligible (I don't see why not?) but AFS and other "foreign exchange student" organizations might be another avenue to "parenting" of a sort. I also found the 10 months or so I spent being a host parent to be very rewarding.
- jimmydddd 3y agoI was a big brother while single and in college. So it's likely still possible.
- hombre_fatal 3y ago> but a young man whose main motive for marriage is "so I don't regret not having kids when I'm old" I had a spit take here. When people say they regret not doing something, they are talking about regretting not everything that came along with doing that thing, not just avoiding the emotion of regret later in life. You could rephrase that into "a young man whose main motive for marriage is to have a loving, fulfilling family which they would prefer much more than staying single, esp later in life" and it's a pretty anodyne take on why anyone gets married and starts a family. When someone says they regret not quitting smoking 30 years ago or starting to exercise daily, are they just talking about avoiding the emotion of regret in 30 years?
- voisin 3y ago> When people say they regret not doing something, they are talking about regretting not everything that came along with doing that thing, not just avoiding the emotion of regret later in life. Perhaps I am misunderstanding but isn’t that what regret it? The not having everything (or most things) that come along with having done the thing? > When someone says they regret not quitting smoking 30 years ago or starting to exercise daily, are they just talking about avoiding the emotion of regret in 30 years? I think this is exactly right. They regret not having all the benefits of having made these choices thirty years prior, and so the feeling of regret is the umbrella term for what they are trying to avoid. In short I think you and OP are saying the same thing but you are arguing that the term regret is narrower. I don’t think that’s right.
- smugma 3y ago“It’s better to regret something you have done than to regret something you haven’t done.”
- thefz 3y ago> You could rephrase that into "a young man whose main motive for marriage is to have a loving, fulfilling family which they would prefer much more than staying single, esp later in life" There is zero guarantee that a family will turn out right, let alone "loving, fulfilling" so this is just a loaded perspective of an issue that has nothing to do with your own world view.
- Aachen 3y ago(For anyone else not in the know: Geezer being USA slang for an old man apparently, or in Brittain just any man... I assume it's supposed to be the former)
- mensetmanusman 3y agoPeople are actually moving less than years past. https://www.thirdway.org/report/stuck-in-place-what-lower-geographic-mobility-means-for-economic-opportunity https://www.thirdway.org/report/stuck-in-place-what-lower-ge... “In the 1950s, about 20% of the population moved every year. By 2017 that number had been cut virtually in half.”
- pertymcpert 3y agoI don't agree. You're making a big assumption that the person expressing regret actually wants something else, but that in my experience is not true.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoMixed feelings. On the one side, it feels like people stay "immature" for longer; instead of starting their careers in their teens and a family not long after, people stay in school until their mid-twenties. Then, what does it take to start a family? Stability. People need a stable income, a living wage, and a place they can call home. If people complain about birth rates, pay people a living wage when they enter the workforce, and make it so people can afford to own a house (that they can live in for the rest of their life if they want to) from their mid twenties onwards on a single income. People can't build a future now, because they worry about the next paycheck.
- mbg721 3y agoAnother side of that is not having such obnoxiously specialized careers that every job change means having to move to a different state.
- atlantic 3y agoNot really. Starting a family is a leap in the dark. Always was, always will be. The only difference today is that people (may) have a lower risk tolerance, and a tendency to plan everything in advance. I had my first son with no house and no income. I just did the best I could, and things fell into place as I needed them.
- legacynl 3y agoI'm not trying to diminish your hardships, but the fact that everything worked out for you in the end is either the result of luck or (mild) privilege. Imagine that everytime somebody helped you out, that didn't happen?. how much worse off would you be right now? There are loads of people who are in your situation who don't have any family, or have a mental or physical handicap, or who happened to get twins instead of just one kid? The start of a family will always be a leap of faith, but difference is if you start on solid ground or not.
- jimmydddd 3y agoAgreed. However, I also think that help does tend to "materialize" if you end up needing it. I've noticed that couples who make a lot of "wrong" decisions (e.g., financially, timing wise) end up getting help while couples who make the "right" decisions seem to get less help. And both types of couples end up with almost the same outcome.
- bombcar 3y agoThe elites don’t want you to know this but the regrets at old age are free you can take them home I have 458 regrets. Much of it can be "path not taken" but you have to work hard to distinguish actual real regret (which will involve understanding why the choices were made, and what about the choices was wrong (e.g., "I underestimated the work vs reward") vs the "nobody wants to talk to me now, if I had kids I could force them to."
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> a young man whose main motive for marriage is "so I don't regret not having kids when I'm old" I was having dinner with my wife's parents, along with some folks from our common church. A congregant asked how I came to join up. I nodded to my in-laws and said 'I knocked up their daughter'.* Which is how a lot of young men got into the parenting racket (and church). * to which my kids said 'Wow dad. Thanks.'
- dcolkitt 3y agoThe large majority of Americans live within 50 miles of where they grew up. And this number has been steadily ticking up. Geographic mobility is the lowest it’s ever been in the post war period.
- koonsolo 3y agoAs the title says, it's not about not wanting kids, it's about thinking it will happen automatically. Some guys think that relationships magically start in a romantic setting, like shown in Hollywood movies. Reality is: if you want something, you should actively purchase it. So if you don't want kids: fine, enjoy the freedoms it will offer. If you want a relationship and/or family, don't sit on your ass until it will magically appear to you. Go get it!
- antisthenes 3y agoThe reality is that for an average guy, earning a stable long-term relationship in the Tinder era is an enormous amount of work, to the point that many find this challenge insurmountable (at least 5% more men, than women, as we can see from the article). There are many men that I know that simply are consumed by the necessity to make ends meet that they barely have any time to go out and meet new people (women specifically). Also, on top of that, women are far less approachable these days, which increases the effort even further.
- xyzelement 3y ago// I get the sense that "I really regret not having children" is mostly a way of articulating "I am old and socially disconnected and feel lonely and depressed" This seems like a superficial take. Placating your sadness is a benefit, not the goal, of having kids. You can pop a Prozac and alleviate your sorrows, that's not the same as the deep satisfaction of looking back on a lifetime of meaningful time with your kids and hopefully seeing them grow into good adults and parents themselves.