3 ms·
The thing about voting machines is that they can work, as long as they also provide a paper trail that determines the actual result of an election or referendum
by jeroenhd 3y ago
The thing about voting machines is that they can work, as long as they also provide a paper trail that determines the actual result of an election or referendum.
This means initial results will be available quickly, followed by actual results a day or two later. This takes the pressure off the counting process which should help prevent miscounts. They solve the real problem of unintentionally spoiled ballots. However, I don't think the concept of voting machines is entirely incompatible as long as we keep the paper trail authoritative.
I have had to explain the obvious flaws in electronic voting to various family members ("why can't we just vote online with our government login" being the most common one). When blockchain bullshit started appearing in public media, people started pretending like they finally found a problem that blockchains solve, only to quickly be shut down again soon after.
I don't think people are aware of how many layers of protections the voting system has and how well thought-out it is. Every year naive politicians try to call for modernisation, and every year they find out that paper voting is actually the best option we have been able to come up with.
- abacadaba 3y agoBlockchains with zk proofs fix this tho.
- philjohn 3y agoThat's literally how Dominion voting machines work. And hand recounts are only for verification, you shouldn't rely on them because they're far less accurate.
- jeroenhd 3y ago> And hand recounts are only for verification, you shouldn't rely on them because they're far less accurate. Voting machines can be altered. Go to any big hacker conference and you can learn how to hack the common models in thirty seconds. Humans may be fallible, but I'll always trust those fallible humans over anything automated.
- philjohn 3y agoAnd hence - use random hand counted samples for verification. But nobody has proven that the dominion machines changed a single thing, in fact, the hand recount in Georgia showed as much. Which is why the "election fraud" claims then moved on to more outrageous claims.
- Kinrany 3y agoThe errors in hand recounts are rare because there are lots of mutually suspicious people looking at each ballot. And when they do happen, they are uncorrelated. A single software error can easily change the result of the election; a thousand human errors cannot.
- thatfrenchguy 3y ago> This means initial results will be available quickly, followed by actual results a day or two later Actual results from paper ballots in French elections are in around an hour or two after voting closes. Yes, it relies on volunteers counting and on people watching but it’s much more effective than anything that would involve machine. You can literally watch your ballot box all day if you’re suspicious.
- pyrale 3y agoFrance's voting system is bulletproof when it comes to vote integrity. However, it has one significant drawback: it is hard to ask more complex questions than voting for x/y/z or yes/no questions. One could say that it is a good thing (since it is hard to have a good public debate on many topics at once, voting on many topics at once means you collect people's preconceived opinions rather than people's informed judgement), but many US states ask many questions at once when people vote, so they would have to significantly reduce the share of direct democracy in their system.
- pyrale 3y ago> However, I don't think the concept of voting machines is entirely incompatible as long as we keep the paper trail authoritative. The problem is impossible to solve if you want to respect the following requirements: - No one can know who you voted for - Anyone can oversee the process and understand why fraud can't happen There simply is no way to prove voter anonymity with an electronic machine without enough technical knowledge to audit the system.
- Tyr42 3y agoThe ones I saw seemed fine? You fill out a paper ballot, and you submit it to the worker at the end who scans it and drops the ballot in the box in one motion. You have a paper trail, it anonymous, and it's pretty easy to understand. I guess if you modified the firmware on the scanner to disclose the vote counters continuously, and the worker at the end knew me by sight (the worker I showed my I'd to is on the other end of the room) you could find my vote. But you could also hide a camera in the booth, which is easier.
- pyrale 3y ago> But you could also hide a camera in the booth, which is easier. It is also easier to check whether there is a camera in the booth.
- Kinrany 3y agoIs it? Cameras can be really small.
- pyrale 3y agoYou can see it this way: if you can time people voting, you can hide the camera anywhere in the voting room. Checking the booth is always going to be easier than checking the room. There is also the issue of voters selling their vote. It's pretty easy for them to wear a tracker that tells you when they were in the booth. On the other hand, with paper ballots, the buyer has no way to check the vote, since market ballots are null.