3 ms·
Implicit in the whole Kickstarter experience from day #1 is that projects may fail. The thing that I think Kickstarter could/should do is put this in large and
by jacquesm 3y ago
Implicit in the whole Kickstarter experience from day #1 is that projects may fail. The thing that I think Kickstarter could/should do is put this in large and prominent text on each and every project page rather than to bury it and to make it implicit. But since Kickstarter profits from the projects they do not do this, because if they would do it likely less projects would get funded.
So they push the responsibility back for to the project creators rather than that they, as middle-men properly inform the counterparty. In that sense they are clearly and unambiguously on the side of the creators and not on the side of the backers. This is smart from their perspective in a monetary sense, but ethically it leaves something to be desired: they could easily do a better job here and they have more than enough data to support the thesis that Kickstarter projects can and do fail. Note that Kickstarter defines 'success' as 'got funded', not as 'delivered on the pledges'. As far as Kickstarter is concerned, when you're funded they're done.
https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Delivery-rate-for-Kickstarter-projects-Approx-30-of-projects-are-delivered-without-or_fig4_366714553 https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Delivery-rate-for-Kickst...
A good 40% of all Kickstarters does not deliver anything, ever. And the remaining 60% is split 50/50 between those that delivered on time and those that delivered at all. And that split can differ substantially between one kind of Kickstarter and another, hardware in particular is difficult and has a high failure rate, even for projects with massive backing.
So, I'm not blaming the project initiators as much as I do Kickstarter, they clearly can do much better at informing potential backers of what they are getting into and the failure rate of projects (do deliver) within that particular segment, independent of the particular initiator (though their reputation could change that) should be prominently displayed on the pledge page. I won't hold my breath for that to happen though. Never trust a man etc...
- Guvante 3y ago"Not all projects fail" is not the same thing as "creators don't have to fulfill". Again this is why you run the Kickstarter through a bespoke LLC as that shields you from liability if you can't deliver. Having a bankrupt LLC makes you judgement proof and thus un-sueable unless they can pierce through the corporate veil because you committed fraud or something similarly terrible. Again it can both be true that they legally must deliver but there is nothing you can do if they don't.
- jacquesm 3y ago> Again this is why you run the Kickstarter through a bespoke LLC as that shields you from liability if you can't deliver. There is fairly high correlation between Kickstarters that are run through a bespoke LLC and Kickstarters that fail to deliver, for me that would be a reason not to back a certain Kickstarter. I see Kickstarters mostly as a way to spend a tiny bit of money to enable particular artists and hackers to pursue their dreams, a subsidy of sorts. And if it ever does result in a thing delivered to my door I'll be pleasantly surprised but my expectations are low and the stats to date mirror the larger stats available about campaigns fairly closely. Approaching Kickstarter in any other way will surely lead to disappointment. Suing someone because they failed on a project would radically change the nature of Kickstarter and even though it has happened I would like to see these reserved for those cases where the initiator clearly never planned to deliver anything in the first place. These happen often enough that it is a real problem.
- jldugger 3y agoYour position is that Kickstarter was 'an obligation-free playground for tinkerers' remains in contradiction of their stated terms of use (now clarified). Kickstarter differentiated itself from gofundme by introducing backer rewards and pretty quickly it looked exactly like the thing you say it wasn't: a place to preorder products. > I'm not blaming the project initiators as much as I do Kickstarter You entered this thread blaming _backers_, caveat emptor style. All the stuff you mentioned upthread was added / changed post 'day #1'. You can even read the discussion on HN from the time https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4551245 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4551245. In 2023 "don't kickstart with money you can't afford to lose" is reasonable but in 2012 the terrain was much foggier.
- jacquesm 3y agoI have presented evidence and have argued from the position of a backer, a project initiator and Kickstarter itself. Each of those have different goals and expectations and each of those try to ensure that their goals and expectations are satisfied even if they are not perfectly aligned. The reality is: 40% of Kickstarters never deliver. And only a very small fraction of those results in refunds. An even smaller fraction results in legal action and only a small fraction of those results in payouts to the original backers in excess of their legal costs. So even if you are right in the narrowest possible sense the fact remains that if a Kickstarter does not deliver you are likely going to lose your money. Backers should be aware of this, should never back a project with money they can't afford to lose and should assume that there is a 40% or so chance that their money will be gone. In 2012 there were enough people saying the same thing. This all started with arguments that Kickstarter is pre-ordering and that it functions as a store. Neither of these are true. The simple reality is that you are giving a bunch of money to a bunch of strangers who will possibly try to deliver on that which they have pinky promised to do. And that there is a very good chance that they will not. And that there is a very good chance that you will not be able - legally or otherwise - to recover your funds. The 40% can be divided into a couple of fractions: projects that failed but where the initiator tried their hardest, projects that failed where the initiator did not try their hardest but they did make some token effort and they delivered something (broken, useless, incomplete, swag only but not the main product that was the goal of the Kickstarter in the first place) and Kickstarters where the initiators never had a chance to deliver because they underestimated the complexity or were underfunded from day 1 and finally those that are simply fraudulent where the Kickstarter itself was the goal, and not the thing the Kickstarter was about. In all of these you probably will not see your money again and this has been the case since the earliest days of Kickstarter. Kickstarter could - and should - do more to inform users of these stats. Kickstarter could - and should - do more to keep the backers safe from fly by night operators, but this would require Kickstarter to do more in terms of due diligence on the initiators, and that in turn could increase their liability. They have always tried to make it seem like they don't have anything to do with the actual interaction even though they are to all intents and purposes the advertisers, middle men, and merchant of record. There are a few cases - that made the news, anyway - where backers have managed to retrieve some of the funds of the Kickstarter project initiators, usually using consumer protection laws. But this is not a structural thing and is more the exception that proves the rule: if the Kickstarter doesn't deliver your money is gone. So: Kickstarter is 'an obligation-free playground for tinkerers' far more than it is a store, and far more than a place where you should have high expectations of seeing your money or a product in return for your money. Backing a project is not the same as buying a product. Fraud and failure happen, you likely will have little or no recourse.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Implicit in the whole Kickstarter experience from day #1 is that projects may fail. To the extent that is the case, rewards shouldn't be dependent on success (or the project should be an independent business such that bankruptcy contains liability in the case of failure.) Also, some Kickstarters are fully developed products from established firms for which the project goal and stretch goals are set around well-researched production costs.
- jacquesm 3y ago~40% doesn't result in deliveries, something Kickstarter could easily advertise on their pages. This stat has held true over a long period of time The second I think is mostly abuse of the Kickstarter mechanism to push it more towards pre-ordering and marketing. It would be better if Kickstarter would not engage in these even if they improve the stats because it raises expectations for the kind of projects that Kickstarter was created for to begin with to unrealistic levels.