3 ms·
> You are entering a legally binding contract with the seller. They must oblige or else refund you. Where does it say that? > Think of it like preordering fro
by jacquesm 3y ago
> You are entering a legally binding contract with the seller. They must oblige or else refund you.
Where does it say that?
> Think of it like preordering from a local store.
No, again: Kickstarter is not a store. How is it even possible to have this level of misunderstanding when it says exactly that on the linked page.
https://help.kickstarter.com/hc/en-us/articles/115005028834-What-is-a-creator-obligated-to-do-once-their-project-is-funded- https://help.kickstarter.com/hc/en-us/articles/115005028834-...
"At the same time, backers must understand that Kickstarter is not a store. When you back a project on Kickstarter, you’re helping create something new — not pre-ordering something that already exists. As Kickstarter does not offer refunds, we encourage backers to investigate the project idea first, to vet the creator thoroughly, and to assess the inherent risk of the project for themselves before making a pledge.
There’s always a chance something could happen that prevents the creator from being able to finish the project as promised. "
And that's from the current terms of service, the previous ones (which were in effect when this project launched) were even more lenient. And that's also why it is called a 'pledge' and not a 'sale'.
- verve_rat 3y agoI mean, they can say whatever they want on the site, but the real question is: what does the legislation, regulation, and common law say about this? Has anyone successfully sued a project? Is there case law?
- jacquesm 3y agoRegret isn't a reason for a restatement of the terms of agreement. If you think that you are going to need a lawyer or sue someone because you backed a Kickstarter short of being fraudulent I suggest you don't ever use Kickstarter at all. That's so against the spirit of what the whole thing is about.
- Guvante 3y agoMost Kickstarter backers out in $50 or less. The filing fee for small claims court is usually $20 and that assumes you live near each other. They are usually judgement proof but that isn't uncommon in other fields too.
- jacquesm 3y agoThe thing that allows Kickstarter to work in the first place is that it uses low risk on the one side (the backers) to enable the initiators to engage in much higher risk ventures than they would ever be able to do on their own. If the backers 'back out' because they see that risk as too high retrospectively they should not have engaged in the first place. Because you are out only $50 or less. But collectively you've enabled someone to take on a risk that they could not have carried by themselves, as a backer you underwrite that risk. This is such a fundamental component of crowdsourcing that I find it bizarre that it needs to be spelled out like this. Legal recourse should be reserved for outright fraud, no less.
- verve_rat 3y agoYes, that is the theory behind crowdsourcing, but what is the actual legal reality? We often don't know that until it has been tested in a court.
- jacquesm 3y agoYou normally speaking shouldn't care. But there have actually been Kickstarter cases brought to court that were resolved in the favor of the backers. Examples: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/06/feds-take-first-action-against-a-failed-kickstarter-with-112k-judgment/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/06/feds-take-first-... (most likely fraud) https://icv2.com/articles/news/view/32334/court-orders-fines-payments-kickstarter-case https://icv2.com/articles/news/view/32334/court-orders-fines... (seems to have been either bad timing or someone that needed the court to get off their ass) https://massivelyop.com/2022/10/12/chronicles-of-elyria-dev-celebrates-dismissal-of-backer-lawsuit-as-next-phase-of-heros-journey/ https://massivelyop.com/2022/10/12/chronicles-of-elyria-dev-... (many millions of $, case dismissed) So it's a bit of a toss-up. Especially the second is weird because the state is awarded $54K versus a pittance to the backers and apparently the backers did in fact receive their stuff. All in all, other than outright fraud I don't see much in terms of real world recourse here, and even then you have to wonder if you shouldn't just write it off. The last one is interesting: by handing a lot of $ to a project initiator you are also effectively funding them from defending from you suing them...
- jldugger 3y ago> Where does it say that? Well, the Terms of Use[1] in force at the time make it pretty clear: > By creating a fundraising campaign on Kickstarter, you as the Project Creator are offering the public the opportunity to enter into a contract with you. And later on, it suggests backers should expect rewards promised or their money back: > Project Creators are required to fulfill all rewards of their successful fundraising campaigns or refund any Backer whose reward they do not or cannot fulfill. Obviously you and I know better than to expect these to happen, but lets not pretend like everyone participating should have known they were bearing equity-like risk. [1]: https://www.kickstarter.com/terms-of-use/oct2012 https://www.kickstarter.com/terms-of-use/oct2012
- renewiltord 3y agoSure, but the same contract offers arbitrary delivery dates: > The Estimated Delivery Date listed on each reward is not a promise to fulfill by that date, but is merely an estimate of when the Project Creator hopes to fulfill by. Project Creators agree to make a good faith attempt to fulfill each reward by its Estimated Delivery Date The point of this site is to gather enough money to make a good faith attempt at something. That's pretty obvious. Even an LLM can figure that out.
- Guvante 3y agoHonestly to my understanding that is very common terms in contract law. Normally you have a right to a full refund if a date is specified and missed (specifically you can liquidate the contract for failure to fulfill which allows you to retrieve your consideration). But pretty much everybody ensures the contract avoids that by either specifying damages for a missed date (which avoids full liquidation) or specifies that no real date is for open ended projects. Note that with no end date you can still sue for failure to uphold if say updates stop.
- jacquesm 3y agoYes, you can sue. But that will likely put the initiator in the poor house, whether you win or lose doesn't even matter. Is that what you had in mind as one of the possible outcomes when backed a project? If so: then don't back that project. People do Kickstarters without vetting as to their business acumen, skills, planning capabilities, ability to source components, product safety knowledge and so on. This dramatically changes the situation from ordering a good from a store or company and you should adjust your expectation as to delivery, quality of workmanship, product safety and guarantees accordingly. It is precisely why I've never done a Kickstarter even if there have been multiple occasions where people indicated they would love it if I did that. But I could see the potential trouble down the line with some clarity: I could easily put in a ton of effort, ultimately fail through some unknown factor and still be morally (and in some jurisdictions even legally) on the hook for either the delivery or a refund. This has such a chilling effect that it never even was a consideration to try. And that's precisely what Kickstarter is: to give people a chance to try to achieve their goal. Best effort, at best, and success as a lucky nice-to-have. And that's why I'm more than happy to back some projects that have low chance of success but where I hope that the initiator will either learn something or in an odd case that it will result in something tangible. I'm pleasantly surprised when it works and I don't sweat it when it doesn't. And I think that's the best match attitude wise for what Kickstarter offers, higher expectations than that and you will be disappointed.