3 ms·
Ugh. Science by press-release. This may all sound nice, but modern farms already deal with pollination by just bringing in bees. The same applies to birds, jus
by cyberax 3y ago
Ugh. Science by press-release.
This may all sound nice, but modern farms already deal with pollination by just bringing in bees. The same applies to birds, just a few species can control pests. "Nature" has an article about that: https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms8414 https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms8414 There are certainly arguments for increased biodiversity, but food security doesn't appear to be one of them.
- Cthulhu_ 3y ago"Food security" is only one aspect though, that sounds like min/maxing things - and that has brought us excess nitrogen (fertilizer), mass extinctions and health problems (pesticides), food poverty (quantity over quality), and ecosystem decimation. It's great for short-term profit, not long-term sustainability. I don't see life or nature when I see miles and miles of corn or wheat, I see a factory.
- cyberax 3y ago> "Food security" is only one aspect though, that sounds like min/maxing things - and that has brought us excess nitrogen (fertilizer), mass extinctions and health problems (pesticides), food poverty (quantity over quality) JFYI, pesticides in food are not linked with health problems. It's a more complicated story for people who apply pesticides, as they are exposed to 100-1000x greater amounts. Fertilizer runoff is a problem. And it's being solved, modern fertilizer application practices (e.g. direct ammonia injection) try to minimize it. > and ecosystem decimation. Wait until you hear about what Native Americans did with the ecosystems on the American continent. The current agriculture is long-term sustainable in most places. It's unsustainable only when there's not enough water available (e.g.: California).
- rocqua 3y agoModern farms don't handle water infiltration, and soil degradation very well. It takes more than one plant to hold water in the soil rather than letting the water (and soil) run off immediately once it rains. Similarly to keep soil in a state where it supports plant life, you need more than one kind of plant that is maximized for extraction.
- fransje26 3y ago> Similarly to keep soil in a state where it supports plant life, you need more than one kind of plant that is maximized for extraction. Ugg. You've got science for that. Just use more chemicals. /s
- cyberax 3y agoI really hate when people think that everyone else is a moron. Do you really think that nobody else thought about using "science" for agriculture?
- hutzlibu 3y ago"There are certainly arguments for increased biodiversity, but food security doesn't appear to be one of them. " Monocultures are not stable ecosystems and can only maintain their state of fertility through lots of chemicals which degrade the soil, which is not just material, but usually very much alive with all kinds of microorganism. So with more chemicals and newer, stronger herbicides and pesticides, the game can surely go on for quite a bit longer, but likely not in the long run.
- cyberax 3y agoThat's why modern agriculture is reactive. Instead of relying on "stable" conditions, you adapt them as needed.