6 ms·
The problem with this, or any other hypothetical "decoupled growth" argument is that, well, it's purely hypothetical. There's no evidence whatsoever that econo
by dredmorbius 3y ago
The problem with this, or any other hypothetical "decoupled growth" argument is that, well, it's purely hypothetical.
There's no evidence whatsoever that economic growth can be decoupled from resource, and most especially energy, usage. There are instances of increased efficiencies, which thanks to the Jevons Paradox increase overall resource utilisation (economically, efficiency is equivalent to a reduced price, and hence induces greater demand). And there are instances of outsourced resource utilisation (both in terms of inputs and of waste sinks), most notably that of China which has committed tremendous domestic resources and incurred immense environmental insult in providing "cheap goods" (that is: goods lacking fully-costed externality impacts) to developed countries.
But there's nary a trace of actual empirical evidence of substantive decoupling in the real world. Much handwaving and could-be's, however.
- XorNot 3y agoConversely the people who argue against growth never have any answers they want to elaborate on. They have "well we can't have endless growth" and that's where the conversation stops. They never want to examine the consequences of that thought (no growth means we're into a zero-sum game) or whether they think we're even plausibly close to the limit (instead they want to have a proxy argument about environmental damage or global warming, and are very uninterested in any specific solutions to their go to examples - i.e. "we can't possibly stop emitting CO2 from power generation, we must simply use less power!").
- dredmorbius 3y agoI'd really like to see you point to specific instances of this. I could point to any number of examples refuting this, but really prefer you lay your cards on the table first.
- XorNot 3y agoI mean you're doing that right now. You seem to believe we can't have infinite growth. Okay...and? Do you have anything more to add other then a mathematical reductio ad absurdum talking about 1000 year timespans? What tangible actions and economic model do you believe this should inform in the next 5 to 10 years, which you as a citizen of a democracy have some role in choosing and advocating for?
- dredmorbius 3y ago<https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37386474 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37386474> Again: I have sources. You? I'm reading this as you don't.
- dredmorbius 3y agoUpdate: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37399144 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37399144>
- XorNot 3y agoLinking to a half-dozen separate arguments, and presenting no original conclusion or summarizing thought on what you took from those works isn't an argument. In fact it's very much not an argument - it's you presuming that I haven't read those, because otherwise how could I disagree? My question was quite specific: what do you think we should do in the next 5 to 10 years? Apparently you've read widely on this topic! So widely that when asked this question, the only thing you did was throw book titles and author names around and talk about how great they are. Rather then anything about what they say. I mean presumably all these distinguished luminaries drew some actionable conclusions right? Because you are calling for actionable things to happen - such as?
- dredmorbius 3y agoYour specific assertion was "Conversely the people who argue against growth never have any answers they want to elaborate on." <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37386379 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37386379> I gave multiple specific authors who have proposed plans. Yes, it's a number of titles; I assure you that's only the thinnest scraping of the broader literature. Or to put it plainly: there are many people who've had "answers they want to elaborate on" ... and you're now complaining that there are too many of them? Tough to please. I've asked you now three times who it is you're claiming has no answers. I'm not exactly still waiting. But if you'd care to provide a response to that question I'd appreciate it. I'm not asking for a thesis. Just a listing of who or what references you're pointing at. Seems to be a considerable challenge for you to do so, just sayin'.
- kbenson 3y agoThe optimal strategy now for unlimited growth and some future limit on growth bei g hit when there are competitors are likely the same. Take advantage of it as much as possibly for as long as possibly. Given two countries where one lints it's economic growth and the other doesn't, if they're given another few hundred years before a limit is hit, which one is in a better place to respond when that limit is hit? Does the country that minutes itself even still exist as it did, or was it taken over by a stronger one (whether economically, militarily or culturally)?
- salawat 3y ago...No crap it's a zero-sum game! We've been screaming it from the bloody rooftops while economists and charlatans have gone on and on chasing alpha, instead of really focusing on breaching the most critical breakthroughs we need. Near limitless clean power, closed cycle industrial processes, and bloody innovations in either transport, agri-husbandry, or medicine. But no. War. War, real estate, and more pretend finance for finance sake. Either that or mass producing the tools of tyranny.
- XorNot 3y agoYou have just given a list of achievable technologies which would allow growth within the current resource constraints. What do you think "new energy sources" are if not economic growth?
- bliteben 3y agoAt some point unlimited growth would mean the heat death of earth. Remember all used energy no matter how green the source emits heat. Even stars have limits to their energy. If you don't believe in limits then you aren't accepting physical reality.
- dredmorbius 3y agoAgain, I'd really like to know who specifically you are referring to with "the people who argue against growth never have any answers they want to elaborate on". I've mentioned numerous specific examples refuting that here: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37399144 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37399144>
- snowwrestler 3y agoIt’s only hypothetical in that the future hasn’t arrived yet. Most predictions are hypothetical by that criteria. We know the economy is decoupled from physical limits because we have built it to be that way. If you go to my bank right now, they are not going to have a physical pile of valuable objects there which is my account balance. They have a computer that stores numbers, and obviously it needs energy to operate, but it doesn’t cost 10x energy to store 10,000 instead of 1,000 in the database entry for my account balance.
- dredmorbius 3y agoQing Dynasty China had "decoupled" its currency from specie by way of the first paper-based currency I'm aware of. See: Richard von Glahn, Fountain of Fortune: Money and Monetary Policy in China 1000-1700 (1996). But that has absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with decoupling the actual economy from its physical foundations. Long after Qing, China remained fundamentally dependent on rice and wheat harvests (and suffered tremendous population losses, as much as 8 million deaths) many centuries later. The wealth-tracking representation has been decoupled from any substance with intrinsic value, but the economy has not. Put another way: you could have a monetary system in which currency was entirely backed in precious gold and silver, and introduce huge quantities of same to your economy ... without increasing the actual wealth of the nation by Adam Smith's definition, "annual produce and labour of the nation". This was precisely the situation Spain found itself in following its conquest of the Americas and importation of vast quantities of South American gold and silver.
- snowwrestler 3y ago> The wealth-tracking representation has been decoupled from any substance with intrinsic value, but the economy has not. If you insist on measuring the economy solely in terms of "substances with intrinsic value," you will find the limit of economic growth at approximately the limit of those substances. However this is begging the question because it's not the only way (and not the currently accepted way) of measuring economies. Anyway, it's not just the representation, wealth itself is increasingly nonphysical and hypothetical. For example not only is my $1,000 bank account just a database entry, my database entry is most likely offset by about $900 in loans to other people. So my saved cash is actually about 90% claims on future payments by other people. Or look at stocks; at a P/E of around 20 currently, 95% of the value of my SP500 index fund is hypothetical. And of course the whole point of a bond is future payments. Market-winning behaviors are also becoming less physically correlated. Did Barbie take 5x as much energy as The Flash to make or present? Does a 3 bedroom row house in San Francisco use 5x as much energy as a similar house in Detroit? Does Apple use 3x as much energy as Amazon? Does it take twice as much energy to make a Mercedes C class as a Honda Accord? There are tons of examples like this. Rice and wheat harvests are a pretty small part of modern economies now. Look, I agree that a certain level of energy usage is required to enable economic activity. If we were to cut our energy use too much, we would limit or perhaps crash the economy. People need food, clothes, shelter, plumbing, communications, etc. I'm just saying: that is not equivalent to proving that future economic growth is bounded by energy usage. One does not logically follow from the other.