5 ms·
So exactly how would you “break Apple up”?
by scarface_74 3y ago
So exactly how would you “break Apple up”?
- EGreg 3y agoOnce they get bigger than the US government (not the country, the government) they wouldn’t be able to do anything to Apple. And even now, Apple can just relocate, as Microsoft threatened to do.
- ThunderSizzle 3y agoThen just tax them to hell (aka tariff Apple imports if they move out of the country significantly) if that's the game these companies want to play. They need the US customer base and investment base more than the US needs Apple.
- scarface_74 3y agoYes and raise prices on everyone? How do you just “tax Apple” and not everyone else?
- paulryanrogers 3y agoBased on share of profits for any given market, like smartphones or laptops.
- scarface_74 3y agoYou realize Apple has less than 20% of the PC market? Every company already pays taxes on profits
- paulryanrogers 3y agoI said "share of profits". Though perhaps I should have said revenue. Regardless Apple has 85% of smartphone profit. And its share of services on mobile and laptops is growing.
- scarface_74 3y agoAnd I fail to see the difference. If Apple has 85% of the profits in cell phones, it’s already paying 85% of the taxes in the cell phone market.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoThis isn't about the taxes (which they mostly dodge or pass on to consumers). It's about choice. With a chokehold on market revenue they crowd out competitors which reduces consumer choice over time.
- scarface_74 3y agoWhose fault is it that Amazon, Facebook and Google - all trillion dollar market cap companies are not able to compete? Amazon and Facebook both tried creating their own phone. Consumers have choice. They can buy from Apple or any number of much cheaper Android devices. They made a choice to pay Apple more. It’s consumers making a choice that led to Apple’s revenue. Both Google and Microsoft have better services than Apple and they still can’t compete. Google is worth a trillion dollars plus, have their own operating system and has the most visited page on the internet and still is estimated to sell as many phones in a year that Apple sells in less than a month. It’s not Apple being anti-competitive. It’s the competitors - all large companies - being incompetent. In the computer space, Apple was a nobody and almost bankrupt compared to Dell and HP in 1997 when Jobs came back. Why were they so incompetently run? Why couldn’t Microsoft make a competitive ARM chip?
- paulryanrogers 3y agoAs more government and banking requires iOS or Android people are forced into a duopoly. If not for regulated standards like SQL or laws protecting clean room reverse engineering would we still be locked into IBM today? Apple lucked into a chockpoint. They had plenty of opportunities, even if less than other giants. Now giants sit like bridge trolls demanding a tax to cross. The market is not healthy when so few players have so much control.
- thenewwazoo 3y agoExactly how they break themselves up: iPhone, Mac, wearables, services, and so on.
- brokencode 3y agoI don’t think so. Apple is not a monopoly in any of those spaces, and has plenty of competition on all fronts. One of the big things that makes Apple products so compelling is the integration and shared engineering between them. For instance, Apple made some of the best processor cores over the course of a decade for the iPhone. Now, variants of those cores are used in everything from the Apple Watch to the Mac. Also, when you buy an iPhone app, it will often also work on the iPad and Apple Watch with tight integration and syncing. To break the company up on product lines would significantly worsen the products. It would make the products less competitive worldwide and likely hurt the US economy. I think this would be a nonstarter for regulators. If regulators want to go after anticompetitive practices, they would more likely force Apple to make changes to App Store policies, which are in many cases incredibly unfair.
- mschuster91 3y ago> For instance, Apple made some of the best processor cores over the course of a decade for the iPhone. Now, variants of those cores are used in everything from the Apple Watch to the Mac. Regulators could force Apple to sell their CPUs (if as hardware or as IP license) under fair conditions to willing buyers, or to open up macOS, iMessage, Facetime and Find My iDevice to competitors' products. That way Apple could still enjoy the benefits of having tightly integrated hardware and software, but the rest of the world could enjoy high performance ARM systems as well, thus finally providing some actual competition to Intel and AMD.
- scarface_74 3y agoWhy should Apple be forced to sell their IP? The Mac has less than 15% market share? Should Google, Microsoft, Qualcomm and Amazon also be forced to sell their IP? Intel has 80%+ of the computer market. Should they be forced to license their IP? Should Google be forced to license their search algorithms?