13 ms·
The lesson that constant percentage (that is, exponential) growth cannot continue endlessly is the fundamental message behind the concept of Limits to Growth.
by dredmorbius 3y ago
The lesson that constant percentage (that is, exponential) growth cannot continue endlessly is the fundamental message behind the concept of Limits to Growth. That is, there exist intractable limits to growth, and that no matter how convenient it may be to pretend otherwise, humans ignore this fact at their extreme peril.
Long-term ongoing economic growth, expressed as a constant percentage, is baked in to most current orthodox economics and economic policy. Even apparent mavericks such as Thomas Piketty assume that growth will continue interminably (noted in Capital in the Twenty-First Century).
Rather than being a critique of Liu, you've actually written a criticism of those he himself is generally addressing.
- xg15 3y agoI think there is one escape from this, basically confining more and more "growth" to artificial numbers on paper (or in a DB). Cryptocurrencies are kind of going in that direction, where the "value" that is reported as economic growth doesn't correspond to any kind of real-world matter or activity, but is simply assigned to some specific group of bits. I can kind of believe that this virtual kind of growth could continue a long time without boiling the planet, but of course that doesn't make things less absurd, as the "value" would represent nothing objectively useful and would have to be maintained artificially - either through scarcity mechanisms like PoW etc, or through locked-down devices and ecosystems. So that kind of "growth" could go on forever without burning the planet but would probably be a step back for civilization.
- dredmorbius 3y agoThe problem with this, or any other hypothetical "decoupled growth" argument is that, well, it's purely hypothetical. There's no evidence whatsoever that economic growth can be decoupled from resource, and most especially energy, usage. There are instances of increased efficiencies, which thanks to the Jevons Paradox increase overall resource utilisation (economically, efficiency is equivalent to a reduced price, and hence induces greater demand). And there are instances of outsourced resource utilisation (both in terms of inputs and of waste sinks), most notably that of China which has committed tremendous domestic resources and incurred immense environmental insult in providing "cheap goods" (that is: goods lacking fully-costed externality impacts) to developed countries. But there's nary a trace of actual empirical evidence of substantive decoupling in the real world. Much handwaving and could-be's, however.
- XorNot 3y agoConversely the people who argue against growth never have any answers they want to elaborate on. They have "well we can't have endless growth" and that's where the conversation stops. They never want to examine the consequences of that thought (no growth means we're into a zero-sum game) or whether they think we're even plausibly close to the limit (instead they want to have a proxy argument about environmental damage or global warming, and are very uninterested in any specific solutions to their go to examples - i.e. "we can't possibly stop emitting CO2 from power generation, we must simply use less power!").
- dredmorbius 3y agoI'd really like to see you point to specific instances of this. I could point to any number of examples refuting this, but really prefer you lay your cards on the table first.
- XorNot 3y agoI mean you're doing that right now. You seem to believe we can't have infinite growth. Okay...and? Do you have anything more to add other then a mathematical reductio ad absurdum talking about 1000 year timespans? What tangible actions and economic model do you believe this should inform in the next 5 to 10 years, which you as a citizen of a democracy have some role in choosing and advocating for?
- dredmorbius 3y ago<https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37386474 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37386474> Again: I have sources. You? I'm reading this as you don't.
- dredmorbius 3y agoUpdate: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37399144 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37399144>
- kbenson 3y ago> Long-term ongoing economic growth, expressed as a constant percentage, is baked in to most current orthodox economics and economic policy. Whether it is or isn't, the optimal strategy for a nation is likely exponential growth until it can't, and then switch as quickly as can be done with the least problems. Since nations are competing, and we're talking about exponentials here, the cost for cutting off exponential economic growth too soon is likely to become irrelevant to the future, which every nation is going to strive to avoid.
- 2358452 3y ago> Since nations are competing, and we're talking about exponentials here, the cost for cutting off exponential economic growth too soon is likely to become irrelevant to the future, which every nation is going to strive to avoid. I question this definition of relevance. To me, relevance is having a healthy, happy, sustainable society and culture. It's not accumulating goods and energy consumption in a self-destructive and planet-destroying way. The sooner nations realize this, the better.
- kbenson 3y agoIt's entirely relevant when your country can't control is own future, as that will extend to its citizens. Just because we're in a relatively stable period of history with regards to one nation seeking to conquer another (somewhat bucked by Russia) doesn't mean that will necessarily persist. A well regulated and lawful country where your rights are respected both internally and internationally is a luxury of a powerful nation and a stable system of narions. The former is what I'm saying is is important with regard to growth, because the latter can't be assumed to always exist in the future.
- dredmorbius 3y agoThe question of stability is an interesting one. There's a long-standing observation that countries in which stable political, economic, and technological cultures have emerged have tended to have natural defences. The British Isles and Japanese archipelago in particular both avoided successful foreign invasion or even significant attack for nearly 1,000 years, until the 20th century. Contemporary stability has more to do with Superpower alliances than geography, though geography still matters. The grand central-European plain had been the parade ground of invading armies since before the Mongol invaders, but today is largely peaceful, so long as one looks underneath the NATO umbrella. Ukraine suffers not only flat geography, ready river and sea access, railway infrastructure, and a long and unrespected border with Russia, but status as an unalligned state, whose prior security treaties with Russia have been abrogated. The first four factors are common to numerous other states, it's the last which has proved critical to its history since 2014. And such alliances don't require especially robust economic capability. Among the 31 members of Nato are wealthy states in absolute (Germany) and per-capita (Liechtenstein) terms, but also some of the poorest, notably Montenegro at 75th worldwide per capita and ranked 46 of 50 among European states in overall GDP (2023). Albania, Croatia, Estonia, Iceland, Latvia, Romania, and Slovakia are other states with low overall or per-capita GDP: State GDP EU rank GDP/capita (WW) ----- ----------- --------------- Albania: 40 101 Belgium: 12 18 Bulgaria: 26 73 Canada: n/a n/a Croatia: 29 54 Czechia: 19 37 Denmark: 16 9 Estonia: 35 38 Finland: 18 15 France: 3 21 Germany: 1 16 Greece: 22 39 Hungary: 24 51 Iceland: 37 6 Italy: 4 25 Latvia: 34 50 Lithuania: 30 44 Luxembourg: 27 1 Montenegro: 46 75 the Netherlands: 7 12 North Macedonia: 42 92 Norway: 13 3 Poland: 10 49 Romania: 17 55 Slovakia: 25 45 Slovenia: 31 34 Spain: 6 29 Turkey: 8 53 United Kingdom: 2 22 United States: n/a n/a Notes: - I've listed the North American members, but omitted their GDP as these are not European states.) - EU rank is 1--50 inclusive. - GDP/capita rank is 1--134 within Europe, based on global IMF rankings of 192 states worldwide. Sources: - GDP overall: <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_in_Europe_by_GDP_(nominal) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_in_Eu...> - GDP/capita: <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_in_Europe_by_GDP_(nominal)_per_capita https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_in_Eu...> Takeaway: Alliances trump GDP or per-capita income.
- felipeerias 3y ago> Long-term ongoing economic growth, expressed as a constant percentage, is baked in to most current orthodox economics and economic policy. As a forecast which may or may not happen? Yes. As an actual outcome that has been decided a priori? No, not at all. Only planned economies tried to do that.
- snowwrestler 3y agoConstant percentage economic growth is possible indefinitely because the economy is made up. It’s like saying “you can’t imagine a bigger number than I can.” A person can always imagine a bigger number, and the marginal cost of doing so is merely what is necessary to store the larger number in a ledger.
- dredmorbius 3y ago<https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37386222 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37386222>
- Turskarama 3y agoIf you want to define growth as cash, then sure. If you want to define it by tangible output, then not so much.
- snowwrestler 3y agoThe economy is measured in money.
- Turskarama 3y ago"Real GDP", which is the one usually reported on, is already adjusted for inflation and is usually reported as a percentage (i.e. it is unitless). What this means is that if 100% of growth comes just from inflation then "GDP" will have increased but "Real GDP" wouldn't have.
- snowwrestler 3y agoGrowth rates are expressed as percentages. The underlying value, GDP, is measured in money.
- Turskarama 3y agoYes, but I'm trying to tell you that doesn't matter. GDP is measured in money, but growth is measured as a percentage so it's unitless.
- slt2021 3y agoit is possible to have exponential growth with a brief period of financial crash/recession, when prices reset to previous bottoms and exponential growth continues (boom&bust cycle). so far it has been the case with human economics across all countries/economies. yes some shareholders will be zeroed out during recession, but others will continue on the growth journey
- dredmorbius 3y agoThat's known as a boom-bust cycle. It's common in finance and population ecology. See, e.g., lynx-hare population dynamics.