2 ms·
Funny, my reaction is the total opposite. Generally speaking, democratizing access is about removing monopoly power that extracts illegitimate rents -- and tha
by crazygringo 3y ago
Funny, my reaction is the total opposite.
Generally speaking, democratizing access is about removing monopoly power that extracts illegitimate rents -- and that tingles in a good way.
Libraries have always been at the forefront of democratizing access, and hasn't that been an unadulterated good? Or whether it's community colleges that democratized access to higher ed, or the deregulation of air travel that democratized air travel through cheaper prices that made it more available to the masses, instead of artificially restricting routes.
I can't think of a single example of "democratizing access" that is "sketchy at best" or "outright evil". They all seem pretty great to me!
But I guess I'm also firmly on the side of AI training here -- I see no reason for additional compensation to authors/artists for training on their data, when anyone can go to a library or museum and then go and create their own works influenced by what they've seen. Who cares if I hire an expensive consultant who's read a lot of books at the library, or a cheap AI who's read a lot of books from Books3? Why would authors/artists deserve extra compensation for the latter but not the former? There's just no clear legal principle behind that.
- itsokimbatman 3y agoI mean that's part of the conversation that needs to be had. I would argue libraries are an unadulterated good, but it is generally considered at best unethical and at worst illegal to re-use content that isn't your own, at least without a proper citation. Then there's also the issue with things like art, music, and code. Where does the line fall with scraping Github, Soundcloud, DeviantArt, or Instagram and using things like that without permission? Most of the code on Github is open source, but there's a lot of difference between the GPL and BSD licenses.
- crazygringo 3y ago> but it is generally considered at best unethical and at worst illegal to re-use content that isn't your own, at least without a proper citation. No it's not at all, except in extremely limited circumstances. When George Lucas made Star Wars, did he cite all the Westerns and space opera serials and movies that influenced him? When you give a presentation at work on why you should move to a sharded database, do you cite the history of academic work on sharded databases? When you use Times New Roman in a document, do you cite the British newspaper The Times, or Robert Granjon's prior serif designs from the 1500's? Of course not. Legally, you can do whatever you want with ideas and styles and whatnot, which is what AI is about. Legally, you only run into problems when you reproduce sections of copyrighted works verbatim, without a license, in a manner that's not considered fair use. Your answer to "where does the line fall" is quite clear legally -- it's the line demarcated by fair use, which has nothing to do with licenses. AI doesn't change that.
- jamilton 3y agoBut there is no bright line test for what is and isn't fair use.
- kybernetikos 3y agoI am not a lawyer, but it seems right to me to say that the weights are a derivative work of the training set. > A “derivative work” is a work based upon one or more preexisting works, such as a translation, musical arrangement, dramatization, fictionalization, motion picture version, sound recording, art reproduction, abridgment, condensation, or any other form in which a work may be recast, transformed, or adapted. A work consisting of editorial revisions, annotations, elaborations, or other modifications, which, as a whole, represent an original work of authorship, is a “derivative work”. As I understand it, derivative works must be created with the legal use of the original work, or be fair use, otherwise they are infringing.
- crazygringo 3y agoNo, as you can see from your very definition. But here's a good example: If you take a book and turn it into a movie, that's a derivative work. Anyone can see the direct resemblance -- the transformation or adaptation. But if you take a book, convert each letter to a number, add up the numbers that make each sentence, and then sell that as a list of "random" numbers, that's not a derivative work. The end result is sufficiently transformed that copyright no longer applies. Ownership of the original work has no relevance. And AI weights are like that. They're a complete transformation. They're not a derivate work. The only thing you have to make sure of is that they haven't been overtrained to the extent that they can regurgitate whole chapters of the texts they were trained on, for example. But that's not something they're currently able to do, and obviously copyright law will force companies to ensure it stays that way. (Not to mention that companies would do it anyways, due to the economic motivation of reducing model sizes to cut costs.)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 3y ago