4 ms·
Which is similar to T-Money in South Korea, Octopus in Hong Kong, and later Suica in Japan. All of which if I remember correctly came before 2000. They are sti
by ksec 3y ago
Which is similar to T-Money in South Korea, Octopus in Hong Kong, and later Suica in Japan. All of which if I remember correctly came before 2000.
They are still extremely popular in those region. One of the thing I dont understand is why these type of payment never took off in the West. Even things like Oyster card in the UK is only for transport but not for any other sort of payment.
Another point worth pointing out, Offline payment are much faster, with Sucia based on FeliCa capable of doing the transaction in less than 100ms. This is important in a transport system as heavily used as the Japanese transport. For people who are used to these type of payment, everything else just felt so slow.
With every iPhone now getting a Felica Chip built in, I was hoping this type of payment could take off. And yet nothing happened.
- toast0 3y agoI don't know about Europe, but in the US, offline payments with regular credit cards are/were a thing. In the old days, you could use an imprint machine to run the card, and mail in the charge slip. Raised numbers and imprint machines are uncool now, but they lasted a long time as backup in case the terminal wasn't working or the power was out. As far as I know, most US cards include the metadata for offline charges, where the terminal processes transactions in bulk, but there's more risk for merchants than doing an online transaction. Stored value cards are popular in transportation, where speed is important, fault tolerance is required, and connectivity is intermittent. But even for gift cards, it's more common to use the card as an identity token, and get the value from an online ledger; it makes alternate uses much simpler.
- zdragnar 3y agoI'm always extremely leery any time those come out because the network is down. A furniture / appliance store in my hometown had an employee use the imprint machine to steal a bunch of credit card numbers, including my parents' card. They only found out because the police had been tipped off and found a bunch of carbon copy slips in the employee's apartment.
- autoexec 3y agoJust about any time an employee handles a card there's a risk of that. Waitstaff who pick your card up off the table and disappear with it for several minutes, the employee you hand the card to at a drive thru window, even employees who swipe it right in front of you could probably pass the numbers in front of a camera long enough to go back through the footage later and read off what they need. The card readers we're supposed to navigate ourselves aren't perfect either, but it's much better when the card never leaves your hand. Honestly though I pretty much expect my card number will get stolen at some point. As long as I can keep an eye on my statements and my bank doesn't give me much hassle about reversing fraudulent charges when I see them it's not a huge deal.
- pohuing 3y ago> Waitstaff who pick your card up off the table and disappear with it for several minutes, the employee you hand the card to at a drive thru window Is this a real thing? Germany is horribly behind on payment options, but even we have mobile terminals that you yourself handle.
- solidsnack9000 3y agoIn the US, we almost always hand the card to stuff and they almost always run it for us. It is only with the widespread adoption of technology like Apple Pay that this is changing in the US. No one is going to hand their phone to the wait staff, so the staff bring a terminal to the table.
- zdragnar 3y agoMobile terminals are starting to become a thing, but at least where I live it is very much the exception. Either you pay at the reception desk or hand your card to the staff at the table, depending on where you eat.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hakfoo 3y agoWe sort of have two forces pushing in opposite directions: * Many transport cards were NFC or RFID or otherwise "you don't have to take the card out of your wallet" years before general-purpose cards were. Now, many transit systems just promote "tap-on and off with your Visa and don't bother loading money into our closed-loop network." (Interestingly, I will note that Toronto's system at least is cheaper to ride if you do use the closed-loop card) * Conversely, merchants-- especially large merchants-- have desperate desire to get away from the general purpose card networks due to high fees and sometimes clunky chargeback rules. Notice the handful of "Walmart Pay"/"Kroger Pay" apps that they'll support rather than enabling Apple or Google Pay at the till, or even things like Target and some petrol stations offering propriatery cards that connect to debit for settlement. Transport cards could be appealing for the merchant audience-- they're likely cheaper to process and represent funds already confirmed by the transport operator. But they're not federated, so it would turn into a nightmare of a thousand individual integrations and a UX like the early days of (pre-Visa/MC branded) debit where you'd have to check if the merchant supported the specific network your card was on.
- Fatnino 3y agoClosed loop card on transit is a free loan to the transit agency. Seems logical that they would prefer people use that.
- loyukfai 3y agoThe Octopus is the de facto transport pass in Hong Kong (well, it's started by the major transport companies) and commonly used in many shops, it's also used by some for building access. Octopus takes an 1.5% cut, I'm not sure if it applies to the founding transport companies but I assume the money will flow back to them anyway. Recently, some transport services started incorporating Chinese e-wallets like Alipay and WeChat Pay which utilizes QR codes, and the agony of seeing people (mainly Chinese tourists) repeatedly scan and fail at the gates blocking the whole queue during rush hours is quite depressing after years of smooth access. Cheers.
- ksec 3y agoThere should be a Hong Kong HN meet up
- lmm 3y ago> They are still extremely popular in those region. One of the thing I dont understand is why these type of payment never took off in the West. Even things like Oyster card in the UK is only for transport but not for any other sort of payment. From my memory, some newsagents etc. did allow payment by Oyster. But there just wasn't demand for it. In Japan at least, many people don't have credit cards and are scared of any kind of debt (perhaps because debts are more enforceable here). So that might be a factor.
- ksec 3y agoInteresting. Thank you I will look it up.
- Tijdreiziger 3y agoWe used to have a popular system like that in the Netherlands (which I totally forgot about until reading GP) called Chipknip ('knip' being Dutch for 'wallet'). The system was eventually discontinued in favor of contactless debit cards, though.