3 ms·
Ho man. To stop major, major climate impacts we long ago passed the point where reductions or caps would even make a dent. To even have a hope of not seeing ma
by lazide 3y ago
Ho man. To stop major, major climate impacts we long ago passed the point where reductions or caps would even make a dent.
To even have a hope of not seeing major disruptive climate change we would have had to be at the point of net-negative fossil carbon releases years ago. And we’re nowhere near that.
Those changes are something of course. and we’d be in a (marginally) worse situation without them. But they’re overall just minor impacts.
The changes required to actually address the issue have barely been contemplated, and will be massively disruptive.
- pier25 3y agoI agree. Zero emissions is only the first step. It's like removing the foot from the gas pedal. But the car is still moving very fast and we need negative emissions to prevent crashing into a wall. Unfortunately even zero emissions seems like a miracle at this point.
- pauldenton 3y ago"Zero Emissions are just the first step". A lot of people's critique of environmentalism is that they are anti growth. Comments like this just seem to feed that skepticism
- taberiand 3y agoPerhaps, in about the same way that chemotherapy on a stage 4 cancer patient is anti-growth. And the patient is still chain-smoking. It seems as a society we have chosen palliative care; we would like to forgo the treatment and just be made as comfortable as possible before the damage is totally overwhelming and we reach organ failure and death
- pauldenton 3y agoDo you know how much of a settlement patients get for experiencing Chemotherapy when their cancer diagnosis was false and they went through the harrowing experience because an expert misdiagnosed the source of their problem? High 6 figures. low 7 figures.
- taberiand 3y agoAgain, the current stage of climate change we are in is analogous to stage 4 cancer. Don't pretend climate change isn't real. It is already impacting humanity today.
- pier25 3y agoWhat I'm arguing is that we need aggressive negative emissions. In case it's not obvious this means not only stop putting carbon in the atmosphere but also removing what's already there. I'm all for growth as long as we don't deplete the Earth and don't cook ourselves to death.
- rsynnott 3y agoReaching net-negative, or even net-zero, won't be happening anytime soon, obviously, but it's far from true to think that no-one's doing anything. > To stop major, major climate impacts Yeah, no, that ship has sailed.
- lazide 3y agoI never said no one was doing anything. I said no one is doing enough to make any significant difference in the outcome. Maybe it is enough to shift things around a couple years! That isn’t nothing. But even if 100% of the population stopped driving cars and ordering on Amazon or whatever, that isn’t going to stop it either.
- pier25 3y agoWell yeah because cars are at the most like 10% of global emissions. And because of climate lag, we're still only experiencing the effect of emissions from a couple of decades ago. Plus there are climatic feedbacks to take into consideration which nobody really knows with certainty how these will react in the coming decades.