4 ms·
> Both of these no one has any plans yet which wouldn’t require major changes in the way people live Eh... I mean, nearly every country in the EU has seen redu
by rsynnott 3y ago
> Both of these no one has any plans yet which wouldn’t require major changes in the way people live
Eh... I mean, nearly every country in the EU has seen reducing greenhouse gas emissions for years (even _with_ replacement of some gas generation with higher-intensity coal generation due to the invasion of Ukraine), on the foot of building retrofitting, increased renewable generation, etc. The US and China have also been investing significantly in renewable generation (though, I believe, at least in the US's case, building retrofitting has yet to start on a large scale). US emissions are broadly declining and have been for a while, Chinese emissions have almost flatlined, though are still inching up. People are doing stuff.
> the way the US interacts with the world which would put them at a major disadvantage with everyone else
Huh? I would think that the US is actually in a rather good position here, certainly relative to Europe and probably to China. The US is very physically big, so lots of space for renewables, and is more self-sufficient on lower-carbon-intensity fossil fuel (ie gas, likely realistically essential as a transition fuel) than the others. It would also likely find lower-intensity agriculture easier to cope with, if it comes to that.
> And this isn’t a problem caused just by the US. So even if the US did this, the rest of the world would keep on trucking and making the issue worse.
China is if anything currently outpacing the US on renewable and other low-intensity (nuclear) generation capacity.
This feels like a comment written 30 years ago, back when no-one was doing anything much. Today, the big three are doing some stuff, with plans for more.
> Until the problem is causing real, unavoidable, unambiguous issues for everyone, of course it’s going to be denied.
The denial is interesting. In the developed world, it's only a significant factor in the US, Canada, and Australia, all of which have large fossil fuel industries, and in all of which it has been highly politicised. (Similar pattern in the developing world; the big denial cheerleader there being Indonesia). In most countries, it is fairly broadly accepted to be happening, and to be at least largely humanity's fault. Even in countries where denial is a significant political issue, it is generally on the decline (as you'd expect; the percentage of the electorate who'll die off anyway before we see really major impact is declining).
- lazide 3y agoHo man. To stop major, major climate impacts we long ago passed the point where reductions or caps would even make a dent. To even have a hope of not seeing major disruptive climate change we would have had to be at the point of net-negative fossil carbon releases years ago. And we’re nowhere near that. Those changes are something of course. and we’d be in a (marginally) worse situation without them. But they’re overall just minor impacts. The changes required to actually address the issue have barely been contemplated, and will be massively disruptive.
- pier25 3y agoI agree. Zero emissions is only the first step. It's like removing the foot from the gas pedal. But the car is still moving very fast and we need negative emissions to prevent crashing into a wall. Unfortunately even zero emissions seems like a miracle at this point.
- pauldenton 3y ago"Zero Emissions are just the first step". A lot of people's critique of environmentalism is that they are anti growth. Comments like this just seem to feed that skepticism
- taberiand 3y agoPerhaps, in about the same way that chemotherapy on a stage 4 cancer patient is anti-growth. And the patient is still chain-smoking. It seems as a society we have chosen palliative care; we would like to forgo the treatment and just be made as comfortable as possible before the damage is totally overwhelming and we reach organ failure and death
- pauldenton 3y agoDo you know how much of a settlement patients get for experiencing Chemotherapy when their cancer diagnosis was false and they went through the harrowing experience because an expert misdiagnosed the source of their problem? High 6 figures. low 7 figures.
- taberiand 3y agoAgain, the current stage of climate change we are in is analogous to stage 4 cancer. Don't pretend climate change isn't real. It is already impacting humanity today.
- pier25 3y agoWhat I'm arguing is that we need aggressive negative emissions. In case it's not obvious this means not only stop putting carbon in the atmosphere but also removing what's already there. I'm all for growth as long as we don't deplete the Earth and don't cook ourselves to death.
- robertlagrant 3y ago> The denial is interesting. In the developed world, it's only a significant factor in the US, Canada, and Australia It depends on where the denial is hitting. E.g. plastic straw bans are made fun of, probably legitimately. Anything that is something an individual can do and feel good about is often not something that will be effective compared to the massive amount of pollution and waste being generated through the general uplift of people out of poverty. In terms of the US: they're leading the way with Tesla on electrification of vehicles, which is a great, large-scale solution to a big source of pollution (or if not a solution, a key element in the larger solution). Canada and Australia I know less about.
- rsynnott 3y agoPlastic straw bans are nothing much to do with global warming; they're a general hand wave-y "good for the environment" thing (and, like, they are, but not in a particularly impactful way). > they're leading the way with Tesla on electrification of vehicles ... Eh? I'm not sure that's really particularly clear; Tesla is in global terms a fairly small part of the market, and the EU and China are both significantly outdoing the US on actual adoption of electric cars. That said, as above, the US is generally doing fairly well on emissions reduction, better than people often give it credit for (albeit partially accidentally due to cheap gas). However, my point was that the US (and the other two) are unusual in that significant numbers of people there, with a significant political voice, believe that anthropogenic climate change is _not a thing_ (or in extreme cases that climate change period is not a thing). This is unusual.
- robertlagrant 3y ago> Plastic straw bans are nothing much to do with global warming What I was saying was the "climate denialists", being a label applied by people who disagree with them, including on things like straws, is an extremely broad church, and not very useful for actually describing what people think. > Tesla is in global terms a fairly small part of the market Can you cite?