3 ms·
> A good example or problem with degrowth is proclamation that things like planes won’t be possible. Aviation is 2% of emissions. Aviation came with oil, it wi
by palata 3y ago
> A good example or problem with degrowth is proclamation that things like planes won’t be possible. Aviation is 2% of emissions.
Aviation came with oil, it will disappear with oil. It's not a problem of emissions per se, it's a problem of energy. Fossil fuels are not unlimited and we don't know how to completely replace them.
> The big ones are things like heating and cooling
We need to work hard on building isolation, obviously. And people need to live in smaller habitations.
> and transportation
We need more trains
> Hydrogen or liquid fuels should work, both produced from green energy.
Same thing: if you look at the numbers, we won't have enough green energy to produce enough hydrogen for aviation, even if technically we can make planes fly with hydrogen. We will have to choose where we use our hydrogen: for planes, or for steel and agriculture?
> But it won’t work if impose suffering on people.
Yep, we need to teach people and hope they accept to do what's needed to survive.
> Or do things that don’t work or don’t help.
Totally agreed here. Hoping for anything short of degrowth doesn't help. We need everything PLUS degrowth. And still, it will be hard because climate is already pretty messed up (with inertia) and biodiversity is looking bad.
- _hypx 3y ago[flagged]
- palata 3y agoAnd thinking that we will have inexhaustible amounts of green energy is not hyper-optimistic and hyper-arrogant? We don't currently have inexhaustible amounts of green energy, and we don't have any viable solution right now. If you think that because we can make 1 solar panel, we will be able to replace fossil fuels, then you have obviously never done any kind of engineering in your life. Problems come with scale. It's not being hyper-pessimistic to know that.
- _hypx 3y agoIt's immediately obvious from basic physics that the world is bathed in green energy. It's availability is thousands of times greater than fossil fuel energy: https://www.freeingenergy.com/the-earth-gets-more-solar-energy-in-one-hour-than-the-entire-world-uses-in-a-year/ https://www.freeingenergy.com/the-earth-gets-more-solar-ener... The problem with doomers and degrowthers is that they are pretty ignorant people. They just assume that there's no solution or that green energy is just too weak to solve problems. This is why they are arrogant and not just pessimistic. They believe they already know the answer despite never looking for possible answers in the first place.
- palata 3y agoI said you have no clue about engineering, not about basic physics. There is a big difference between saying "but Proxima Centauri is a nuclear fusion reactor producing a ton of energy" and actually leveraging it.
- _hypx 3y agoLast I checked, solar power is very cheap. Your problem is the same as with many degrowthers, you are basically stuck in the past and refuse to change your mind despite new information. It is the arrogance of "knowing everything" while not having any desire to learn.
- palata 3y agoYou completely miss my point. You are the arrogant want saying "don't worry, we can solve it, we know". I am the one with humility saying "guys, I have seen how engineering works, it's always harder than we think". Tell me: how do you make plastic with solar energy? Because last time I checked, plastic was made of oil. There are tons of engineering problems (from the fact that nobody has ever produced that much solar energy to the fact that you can't control solar energy - what do you do when there is no sun? Happens at least every night...). Plus, if your only reference is the price of solar power today, then you are highly uninformed on the subject at hand. Of course solar power is cheap: in many places it is subsidized, and it is built with cheap, abundant fossil fuels. But make no mistake: solar today is absolutely marginal. So you are extrapolating from the current marginal energy production of solar to 100% of the world, with the only argument that "last you checked, solar today is very cheap" and "those who believe they know slightly more than me are arrogant, I won't listen to them". > while not having any desire to learn. Let me take you on that. I will share with you my favorite introduction book on the subject (it is cheap, from a really respected french engineer, and it took me 5h to read). If you do have any desire to learn, read it seriously. Now in all fairness, if you share with me the title of a serious book that explains why degrowth is "arrogant and stupid", I commit to reading it. Do we have a deal? My choice is "World without end" (in French: "Le monde sans fin"): https://www.amazon.com/World-Without-End-Blain-Christophe-ebook/dp/B0C1KXNZ1W/ref=sr_1_2?qid=1693822647&refinements=p_27%3AJean-Marc+Jancovici&s=books&sr=1-2 https://www.amazon.com/World-Without-End-Blain-Christophe-eb...