3 ms·
Given the legacy of white privilege in American society, why do white people have lower life expectancy than their counterparts in Canada and Western Europe, as
by onetimeusename 3y ago
Given the legacy of white privilege in American society, why do white people have lower life expectancy than their counterparts in Canada and Western Europe, as well as per capita suicide and psychiatric disorder rates far higher than their Black, Asian or Latino peers? Their conclusion: “Whiteness encourages whites to reject policies designed to help the poor and reduce inequality because of animosity toward people of color as well as being unaware that the poor include a great many white people.”
This isn't supported by the data though is it?
That said, African Americans actually fare a bit better, relatively speaking, in Greater Appalachia (where their life expectancy is 74.2) than in many other regions, including the Deep South (where it’s 73.6) and even the Far West (74.1) and Yankeedom (73.6).
Hispanics actually have much higher life expectancy than whites in the U.S. Researchers call this the “Hispanic Paradox” because it confounds the usual associations between socioeconomic status and life expectancy
Which both contradict an earlier quote:
This is logical considering the overall values and variation in health and opportunity of Yankeedom are more favorable than the Deep South or Greater Appalachia,” she said. “There are regions of the country with structural barriers to health, where types of long-standing discrimination and disinvestment have occurred through policies and practices applied and reinforced by people with more power.
The author's claims about regions and about health disparities caused by different views of healthcare policy doesn't seem supported by the data. The racist South, built by feudal slave lords, is equal to Yankeedom in terms of lifespan for Black people and worse for white people. That doesn't fit the narrative that whites in the South choose policies that limit Blacks. The "Hispanic Paradox" also calls into question whether the regions, which seem made up, even matter.