4 ms·
The article implied a causal relationship (blue partisanship causes higher life expectancy) but overlooks relevant changes in partisan alignment. For example th
by rayiner 3y ago
The article implied a causal relationship (blue partisanship causes higher life expectancy) but overlooks relevant changes in partisan alignment. For example the article shows that life expectancy in the tidewater region is higher than yankeedom. But Virginia was solidly red from 1950 until 2008. By contrast, Appalachia was mostly blue from the FDR era until 2000. Look at the counties that voted for Carter twice and then for Clinton.
Meanwhile, most of these life expectancy patterns existed before these political realignments. For example, West Virginia had low life expectancy in 1990 as well, despite voting for Dukakis by almost the same margin as his home state of Massachusetts.
Even just looking at the current statistics it doesn’t map cleanly to partisanship: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/pressroom/sosmap/life_expectancy/life_expectancy.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/pressroom/sosmap/life_expectancy/li.... Idaho is about as deep red as it gets. It voted for Trump 2:1 and hasn’t voted democrat since LBJ. So is Utah. But both have high life expectancy, similar to Oregon or Vermont.
Also, the whole exercise is meaningless without adjusting for race. Race gaps are bigger than state gaps. California does artificially well because Hispanics and Asians live longer than whites. Using 2012 data, whites in California have a lower life expectancy than whites in Idaho or Iowa: https://www.livescience.com/18835-race-lifespan-states.html https://www.livescience.com/18835-race-lifespan-states.html
- solarmist 3y agoDid you read the article? He goes back and talks about the founding cultures of these regions. The partisan nature of it is also a consequence of that rather than politics causing the divides. The author brings up racial divides several times and show variance graphs based on several races, but is obviously not comprehensively in this short article.
- rayiner 3y agoThe sub caption refers to “Centuries-old settlement patterns — and the attitudes they spawned about government.” The implication is that more government would increase life expectancy. The founding cultures are a real thing, but they don’t map in a stable way to partisanship. The south and Appalachia were core parts of the FDR coalition. I suspect what you’re actually seeing is differences in food and lifestyle traditions.
- pyuser583 3y agoMormon Utah and Idaho are outliers on lots of things. For example, teenage pregnancy tends to correlate with overall fertility rate - except in Utah and Idaho.