5 ms·
At least you're in the car. I'm not, and I'm also at risk, and so is my family. Proximity to Tesla is fortunately higher for Tesla owners so they are probably a
by jacquesm 3y ago
At least you're in the car. I'm not, and I'm also at risk, and so is my family. Proximity to Tesla is fortunately higher for Tesla owners so they are probably at higher risk from FSD than the rest of us but you really should not give control of your car to anything that says 'beta' on the tin and that regulators haven't stepped in yet is a complete mystery to me. Given the amount of requirements a vehicle (and a driver!) has to go through to be allowed into traffic in the first place you'd expect that any kind of mission critical software would be required to be put through its paces in a very stringent test environment as well but that seems to be asking too much.
Besides the fact that the next OTA update may well give you a completely different batch of problems.
- Waterluvian 3y agoI’m all for the personal responsibility thing. In Canada if you do 50km/h over the limit they seize your car roadside, fine you $10k, suspend your license, and likely charge you criminally for dangerous driving. We also have private race tracks where you can take your Civic and put yourself into a wall at 170km/h if you so choose. I don’t care for arguments about safety statistics or the ends justifying the means. My kids are on these streets. It’s not your autonomy test track.
- sebzim4500 3y agoFor the most part I agree with you, but >I don’t care for arguments about safety statistics is insane. If it's safer it's safer, and the only way to know is statistics. The fact that (seemingly) no government department is collecting and publishing safety statistics on every self driving car manufacturer defies belief.
- Waterluvian 3y agoThey’re my kids so I just don’t care if using them as a test subject results in longer term safer roads for everyone. But I think what you’re talking about is if autonomy makes my kids safer in the immediate, and not as an end result of public testing. Yes, I support that. I don’t think this is that yet. The word beta is right there.
- theptip 3y agoStrongly agree with the sentiment. Note NHSTA in the US recently started publishing incident counts for self-driving vehicles, but its total counts by company, not per-mile, and therefore mostly meaningless
- 6D794163636F756 3y agoThey specifically said test track. Once it's proven then put it on the roads. But in it's current state it should be severely restricted. They may need training data but then they can pay for it or pay to construct suitable tests
- sebzim4500 3y agoIt's already on the road driving millions of miles. Someone should just count how many accidents it has had, and compare to how many are expected given the number of miles driven under each driving condition. If FSD has more accidents then ban it.
- Waterluvian 3y agoI love this “logic.” You can do something wrong but if it works out, hey, it’s fine right? This also creates a wonderfully sloppy veil. Hey it’s proven safe. So we’re going to go ahead and fuck with the settings more.”
- sebzim4500 3y agoIf it improves safety then it isn't wrong
- Tempest1981 3y agoI think the point is that if it's "proven" safer today, the manufacturer can then make changes and test publicly, and be absolved of responsibility if there are regressions.
- TheCleric 3y agoSure this will go fine since it's not like we have a track record of people dying in Teslas, with Tesla taking zero accountability, and withholding the crash data from open scrutiny. This experiment is sure to be unbiased.
- dzhiurgis 3y agoDo you treat all traffic participants with same scrutiny? I’d rather have distracted driver on autopilot over distracted driver in a car with crude ADAS.
- jacquesm 3y agoIt's not a binary choice: there are also simply normal, non-intoxicated, non smartphone distracted drivers.
- wilg 3y agoThat's not the point. The point is there are many less safe drivers on the roads than people in Teslas supervising FSD. As far as anyone knows there's been like, maybe one crash on FSD and no deaths. (There are Autopilot/ADAS related deaths, though not a shocking number relatively, but that is not the same type of system and is also deployed on many other vehicles.)
- dzhiurgis 3y agoWhere are they? Taking a driving exam?
- jacquesm 3y agoNo, they're just your everyday normal drivers. Tens of millions of them. Most people - surprise - actually just follow the rules. That there are also many that do not means you're looking at a venn diagram where only the fraction 'drives a Tesla' and 'would be an unsafe driver' that overlaps is affected positively whereas those that 'drives a Tesla' and 'would be a responsible driver' may well be the larger fragment. And it says nothing at all about the population at large given that a Tesla is an expensive piece of kit.
- xboxnolifes 3y agoAre you really trying to suggest that every driver is intoxicated or on their phone? Do you drive?