6 ms·
Negative impact of vegetarian and vegan labels
- hirundo 3y agoTl;dr: To trick people into eating less meat, withhold the information about whether their meal options contain meat.
- jowea 3y agoSince the vegetarians and vegans can still figure out the meat options contain meat I think it's more of a do not emphasize rather than withhold the information.
- DangitBobby 3y agoThe reason those labels are there is to facilitate us being able to find what we can eat. I don't want to look over 30 menu items before I can find the 3 things I can eat. Same reason they mark "gluten free", "nut free", "low carb", etc.
- petepete 3y agoPlus there are plenty of things that contain meat products without it being obvious, rennet in pesto for example.
- DangitBobby 3y agoYes, I have on occasion accidentally received meat in a dish that wasn't explicitly listed. Sometimes it's a result of me not being familiar enough with the food and sometimes they just don't bother to mention e.g. the salad comes with chicken on top.
- jagged-chisel 3y agoMany years ago I was surprised at “vegetarian” refried beans sitting beside “traditional” on the grocery. Turns out, traditionally, they contain pork fat. Not immediately obvious unless you’re raised making them yourself.
- dghughes 3y agoBut then it gets into the ridiculous where white sugar is used. It's white by filtering it with bone char. At that point it's a religion more than a diet.
- DangitBobby 3y agoIt definitely sounds more like "doing what the diet is" than a religion to me.
- jowea 3y agoMe neither but if no labels means more consumption and more options, might be worth it.
- delecti 3y agoOr less judgementally, people think they dislike vegetarian/vegan options more than they actually do.
- layer8 3y agoThe study didn’t survey how much the participants ended up liking the food they chose.
- wiseowise 3y ago> people think they dislike vegetarian/vegan options more than they actually do. No.
- BillyTheMage 3y agoPeople avoid it just because of the name. So, yes.
- wiseowise 3y agoPeople avoid it because it is made of crap, tastes like crap and has a texture of crap.
- delecti 3y agoOreos are vegan, and are the best selling cookies in the US. Thin Mints are vegan too, and as I understand it, they're pretty popular. Graham crackers are often vegan, and those are the base for basically every homemade cheesecake. Obviously the rest of the cheesecake isn't likely to be vegan, but it seems the crackers aren't enough to ruin it with their crappy taste or texture.
- adifogniobio 3y ago[flagged]
- failbuffer 3y agoThe menu descriptions in the study were quite thorough/complete. No trickery involved.
- theogravity 3y ago"The results suggest removing vegetarian and vegan labels from menus could help guide US consumers towards reduced consumption of animal products." The menu items would need to be descriptive about the ingredients used for someone who is actually vegetarian or vegan to know if the ingredients used truly is or not then. I also get that these kinds of meals are generally cooked alongside or on cooking materials that may have come into contact with meat, but I haven't found a vegan/vegetarian friend that has been sensitive to that detail (unless it explicitly states it's cooked on grills and pans that had meat on them).
- itronitron 3y agoIt would be nice if they had letter codes for meats like they do for allergens. I generally avoid red meat, but not for any ideological reasons.
- layer8 3y ago> The menu items would need to be descriptive about the ingredients used for someone who is actually vegetarian or vegan to know if the ingredients used truly is or not then. “this study did not find that vegetarians and vegans were more likely to choose items with meat when the labels were removed, indicating that removing labels did not negatively impact them.” Of course, the quote doesn’t address the stricter requirements of vegans vs. vegetarians.
- DangitBobby 3y agoJust because vegans and vegetarians were able to find the food eventually doesn't mean they weren't negatively impacted. It's a huge pain in the ass to find the 2 items I can eat on your 30 item menu without labels. Maybe a separate menu would be appropriate if we want to move away from labeling.
- froddd 3y agoIt also doesn’t address the fact that vegetarians and vegans will spend more time making sure they don’t accidentally eat something that doesn’t fit with their dietary choice, but that trawling through every ingredient for every menu item is a huge faff that’s avoided by simply labelling vegetarians and vegan items clearly. It feels like the argument of “removing labelling will result in more consumers choosing vegetarian and vegan options” relies on, ultimately, tricking the consumer. That can’t be a good proposition to start from.
- itronitron 3y agoBlatantly labeling a food item with anything other than flavor and nutritional value probably causes it to be seen by people as not being competitive on flavor or nutritional value.
- alphanullmeric 3y agoAnd with vegan food that generally is the case, hence the amount of processing, added sugars, seed oils, etc.
- at_compile_time 3y agoPerhaps the lesson is to be careful of vegan foods that require labels in the first place. Most of the healthiest food are so obviously vegan that it would be absurd to label them, as is the case with legumes, fruits, vegetables, and whole grains. It isn't until you move up the processing ladder that these labels become necessary. Once you've entered the realm of food that's been engineered to imitate animal products, that vegan label is doing a lot of work to make people think of the food as healthy.
- caf 3y agoI would hypothesise that a nutritional label like "high fibre" or "low salt" might well have the same dissuading effect. A follow-up study is called for! Other labels that might have a similar effect are religious ones like kosher or halal.
- ivan_gammel 3y agoI recently discovered a lactose-free sort of cheese in Germany that had only a small label on the rear side of the package (other brands in this segment usually make it very clear to simplify the discovery by lactose-intolerant people). My guess is their marketing team already knew the effect and wanted to sell it to broader audience. I won’t be surprised if „Eco“ and „Bio“ labels have „overpriced“ or similar negative perception for the audience not too concerned with their original meaning, but the discoverability for the target audience matters more for most of the products.
- brigadier132 3y agoIf I see something labelled vegan I immediately think it's going to taste worse. I don't think that about vegetarian food necessarily. But when I see it labelled that way on a menu it does go through my head that this food is on the menu for reasons other than its flavor.
- telesilla 3y ago>this food is on the menu for reasons other than its flavor. Sure and this is ok. The same with the salad, right? And the mineral water on the drinks list. Like you, I support the genuinely necessary efforts for providing good access to alternatives to animal protein. Edit : I think the replies are misunderstanding. I'm saying, the vegan food is not for you. It's for vegans, like the salad is for those eating light. Like the mineral water is for those who don't want an alcoholic drink. Why do you care how it tastes? Please, can we keep it on the menu. I've been 3 decades advocating and celebrating more diversity in menus and it would be devastating to see losses from what has been achieved. Next step what so many are asking here: make it taste good
- Aaargh20318 3y agoBut the mineral water and the salad don’t necessarily need to be labeled as vegetarian. I think the issue is that people don’t interpret the ‘vegetarian’ label on the menu as “this is OK for vegetarians to eat”, they interpret it as “we altered this dish to make it suitable for vegetarians”, and usually the latter means it’s not very good.
- zeroCalories 3y agoI don't think he implied otherwise. It was an opinion in reference to the study, which I agree with. If I'm at the store and grab a random snack off the shelf to try, I'll pretty much always put it back if the label says vegan because I've been burned by overpriced vegan snacks that taste like garbage so many times.
- the_af 3y agoI don't follow. Salad is on the menu because salad tastes good and some customers like the taste. Salad is not at all like an animal-based meal having its animal component replaced with something else. Likewise, mineral water is there because some people like drinking water and not alcohol or soda.
- CameronNemo 3y agoDid they literally write Vegan or Vegetarian, perhaps as the first word on the menu item? Or did they put a little green V or VG at the end of the item? I can't tell based on the abstract. Edit: looked into it further. It appears they did write "vegan" in parentheses at the end. I wonder if they had been more subtle about it if the results would be as pronounced.
- sombragris 3y ago> Reducing consumption of animal products is a critically important challenge in efforts to mitigate the climate crisis. Despite this, meals containing animal products are often presented as the default versus more environmentally sustainable vegetarian or vegan options. This told me everything I needed to know about the authors' beliefs. While I don't appreciate this position, I do appreciate their honesty. Kudos to them for that.
- froddd 3y agoWhat do you mean? I don’t see anything to do with opinion or personal preference of the author in the quoted statement, hence my question.
- BillyTheMage 3y agoI think it's the fact that they're only vegan because of consequences, not because they have a moral opposition to harming animals, which is what veganism is supposed to be about.
- DangitBobby 3y agoThat's funny, I assumed it was someone bristling at the thought of veggie-isms being the way of the future.
- mcdonje 3y agoI assume by that you mean it told you their beliefs are in-line with scientific consensus. Because the quote is in-line with scientific consensus.
- belorn 3y agoThe global scientific consensus is that climate change is primarily caused by humans burning fossil fuels. Fossil fuel use is what put more green house gases into the atmosphere, which in turn is heating the earth beyond what the environment can handle. How critical different strategies are to combating climate change has a significant weaker consensus. Energy productions and energy usage is usually the most critical in mitigating climate change. Diet is fairly debated subject, with some researchers listing it higher on the list while others listing it much lower. Agriculture is often combined with land use, but the deeper one go into this subject the more difficult things get. A "wet" forest is several times better than a dry forest, so in terms of combating climate change, removing water draining can be more effective than increasing the amount of land dedicated to forestation. There are many factors for policy makers and a lot of low hanging fruit that is more critical to target first.
- chefandy 3y agoI used to be a chef. It's really easy to level a bunch of value judgements at people on topics like this, but the truth is, food marketing is complicated, and none of us is as rational about our choices as we might imagine. Putting aside the appeal of the terms vegetarian and vegan, which is what most comments here seem to focus on, there are other factors. I reckon the most important one is in-groups and out-groups. As soon as you label something as being "for someone," it subtly implies that it not for someone else. The small Boston-area fast casual chain Clover did a really good job of side-stepping that. Their menu was ovo-lacto vegetarian with lots of vegan options, but they simply didn't market themselves as such. In turn, they were generally seen as a restaurant for everybody that served plant-based foods rather than a restaurant for people who eat plant-based diets. There are things that kind of annoy me about Clover that I won't get into here, and I'm not a vegetarian, but I do really admire what they did there.
- colanderman 3y agoI agree with you, but nitpick/warning about Clover specifically: I would not say they have "lots of" vegan options; last time I went they had two vegan sandwiches, one of which is on the "secret menu" -- except for the time when they swapped out the vegan mayo on it for a dairy mayo without telling anyone because of supply issues. They've also been actively hostile toward vegans on social media and even in-store media (they briefly had a "vegan wall of shame" at their DTX location) -- their owner is petty as they come. If you are looking for vegan food in Boston there are so many better options -- I would recommend literally anywhere else. My preferred example of non-exclusive labeling in the Boston area is Red White Boneless Ramen in Back Bay. Their store and menu are devoid of any mention of "vegan", "vegetarian", or "plant-based" (beside the recent addition of "Boneless" to their branding) but they are 100% vegan (and crazy delicious).
- r0b1n 3y agoWtf, dairy mayo? Is this an american thing? Mayonaise is oil, egg yolk and optionally mustard/garlic/spices/flavourings.
- 3y ago
- yousif_123123 3y agoI think a solution that I would prefer as a vegan and that wouldn't impact others is for the main menu to say at the bottom "ask for our vegan/vegetarian menu" so that for me it's easier to pick things, and no one else needs to see the labels. It also might invite the restaurants to provide more vegan options and potentially include some (without labeling) in the main menu.
- imjonse 3y agolooked for this in the article, since it seemed such an obvious thing to test for but they haven't (yet). Vegan and vegetarian can mean both the menu and the people following that diet, "plant based" is clearly only about the menu, may suggest "healthy", and may not evoke negative sentiments. """ Also, while the present work studies the impact of "vegetarian" and "vegan" labels, other terms used to indicate that foods lack animal products, such as "plant-based", have become increasingly common. Do "plant-based" labels also have a negative impact on consumers' choices? How does their effect compare to "vegetarian" and "vegan" labels? The present work could be extended to help answer these questions, as well as study how different labels positively or negatively impact the choices of different consumer groups. """
- bryanmgreen 3y ago"The results suggest removing vegetarian and vegan labels from menus could help guide US consumers towards reduced consumption of animal products." In Europe it is very common to see menus with iconography for fish, plants, grains, and cheese to quickly identify diet friendly items. To me, as a meat eater with a pescatarian girlfriend, it makes the menu seem much more friendly and inclusive. And from my anecdotal experience as a US citizen in Los Angeles who spends a lot of time in Europe, they are much more vegetarian friendly over there. Maybe removing labels isn't the answer, maybe adding more is.
- UncleOxidant 3y agoAs a vegan I depend on these labels on the menu to know what I can order.
- Mordisquitos 3y agoI'm proud to see a study supporting the hypothesis that I have long been proposing when going out for a meal with friends! In fact I explained it not long ago on HN [0]. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37094223 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37094223
- olig15 3y agoI received some cheese in a food kit that was labelled as Vegetarian, but I misread it as Vegan so I didn’t bother eating it (I’ve had bad experiences with vegan cheese in the past). I’d not seen cheese labelled vegetarian before which is probably what threw me off, but I didn’t even think that the rennet in cheese comes from cow stomachs, so having a vegetarian alternative to the rennet makes sense. After realising my mistake I tried the vegetarian cheese the next time it showed up, and it tasted indistinguishable from other ‘normal’ cheese I’d had in the past. My misreading and prejudice against what I thought was vegan cheese would have stopped me buying something that I liked. If it wasn’t marked as vegetarian I wouldn’t have even thought twice about eating it.
- 1024core 3y agoInstead of labeling "vegan" or "vegetarian", maybe label them as "contains no meat or dairy" and "contains no meat" respectively...? I dunno, as a vegetarian, I would love to be able to tell at glance if something is vegetarian or not. Anecdote: traveling in eastern California (near Sonora), I went into a store where they had these ginormous home-made Mexican cookies. Me gusta!! I asked for one, and was interrupted by the wife: she asked the owner (of the store) if she could confirm that they were vegetarian. The owner went to the back room, found the packing slip and whoops! One of the ingredients was manteca (or lard, or beef tallow). Apparently it's common to use it in Mexican food, so she wanted to confirm. Had the cookies had standard indicator of vegetarianism (a green circle in a green square, like this: https://images.app.goo.gl/ggPD5vEgFzwXjP2o7 https://images.app.goo.gl/ggPD5vEgFzwXjP2o7) I wouldn't have wasted their time.
- p1mrx 3y ago> a large field experiment in a chain of UK cafes found that modifying dish names away from names that highlighted that they were meat-free had a significant positive effect on sales (Bacon et al., 2018) I wonder if they listed Linda Bacon first for comedic value: https://www.wri.org/research/language-sustainable-diets-field-study-exploring-impact-renaming-vegetarian-dishes-uk-cafe https://www.wri.org/research/language-sustainable-diets-fiel...
- mcdonje 3y agoThey did a questionnaire based on a hypothetical menu. There can be bias based on the types of restaurants people tend to go to. If a restaurant primarily has meat dishes but they have one or two vegan options so token vegans can eat there, it's probably an afterthought. Some of the worst vegan food I've ever had was at steakhouses. Thay should surprise nobody. If someone who took the questionnaire primarily eats at places that primarily serve meat-focused dishes, they probably have a view of vegan food that's very different from the reality of what most vegans actually eat on a regular basis.
- delta_p_delta_x 3y agoThe experience in India is markedly different, given just how many people are vegetarian there (for a ballpark figure: at any mealtime, about 1/3 the Indian population, or about 500 million people, eats a fully-vegetarian meal). Restaurants and chains proudly advertise that they only serve 'pure vegetarian' food, and people—even not-vegetarian people—flock to them in droves anyway. Western veg(etari)an labelling has motifs of leaves, or plants, etc. Indian labels are a lot more subtle and abstract: a green dot in a green square for lacto-vegetarian, and a red/brown triangle in a red/brown square for non-lacto-vegetarian (ergo, egg products are in this group)[1]. The Indian labelling is also mandatory, so all food packaging and every menu item in Indian restaurants has to be accompanied by a green or red icon (this however leads to some mildly funny things like 'chicken tikka masala powder' being itself vegetarian, but the dish that it is used in being non-vegetarian). I think this whole disdain for vegetarian labelling is entirely because vegetarian food has got a terrible rep in the West. This is likely due to poor experience in cooking vegetables (no one likes steamed broccoli), to narrow restaurant options, to simply not being exposed to other cuisines besides American, French, and English. I've already given Indian cuisine as the gold standard for delicious vegetarian food; other alternatives (that may not necessarily be traditionally entirely vegetarian) include Indonesian, Tibetan, Chinese, Vietnamese, Thai, Mexican, and Italian. Final addendum: every study on vegan/vegetarian food should include a subsection or two containing a case study on India. [1]: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/d5/FSSAI_new_labels_for_veg_and_non-veg.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/d5/FSSAI_ne...
- GuB-42 3y agoWhat about reversing the label? Treat animal products like you treat allergens. Many restaurants have a table of allergens, they usually include things like "eggs", "milk" and "fish", just add an "animal products" line, maybe also more specifically "meat" (for vegetarians) and "pork" (for religious reasons).
- BillyTheMage 3y agoI can't stand people who conflate veganism with vegetarianism. Veganism is about morals and values and being a good person. Has nothing to do with diet or health.
- DangitBobby 3y agoThey are both worth mentioning in the this context in the way they are both relevant: reduced environmental impact and menu labeling. Also, vegetarianism is also commonly a moral choice.
- krannaut 3y agoI think India does a pretty good job on it. There's not a huge vegan market in India but vegetarianism is a huge thing. To differentiate between vegetarian and non vegetarian food there are different colored symbols [0] that explain whether food is vegetarian or not. Avoids the big label but anyone who wants to know can easily identify it. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:FSSAI_new_labels_for_veg_and_non-veg.png https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:FSSAI_new_labels_for_ve...
- mcdonje 3y agoFirst time I've seen that. It's good they updated the reddish-brown circle to a triangle. A colorblind person would have trouble distinguishing.