28 ms·
The whole description is pretty confusing, I hope video is shared at some point so we can understand it a little better. I’m sure they (Cruise as well as the ci
by bee_rider 3y ago
The whole description is pretty confusing, I hope video is shared at some point so we can understand it a little better. I’m sure they (Cruise as well as the city) don’t want to dump it on the general public immediately for good reasons, but hopefully we’ll see it eventually.
> A stalled Cruise robotaxi blocked a San Francisco ambulance from getting a pedestrian hit by a vehicle to the hospital in an Aug. 14 incident, according to first responder accounts.
> “The patient was packaged for transport with life-threatening injuries, but we were unable to leave the scene initially due to the Cruise vehicles not moving,” the San Francisco Fire Department report, first reported by Forbes, reads.
> Video and other surveillance data gathered by Cruise and reviewed by The Standard showed three Cruise vehicles were present at the scene. Two left the scene but one remained stopped as an ambulance arrived behind it. Cars continued to pass in the lane to the right of the stopped Cruise car.
I’m wondering if The Standard just got a little video of the end of the interaction? The Fire Department seems to be complaining about a general issue with multiple Cruise vehicles slowing things down, while the paper is talking about one car that seems to have “stalled.” (is that a mechanical failure?)
> "Throughout the entire duration the AV is stopped, traffic remains unblocked and flowing to the right of the AV," a Cruise spokesperson said in a statement.
> The video captured by Cruise showed that the ambulance parked behind the Cruise and did not attempt to pass the robotaxi in the rightmost unblocked lane.
This seems a little weird, the ambulance is apparently in a rush but there’s also normal traffic flowing to the right of it? Why weren’t those people pulling over, like you are supposed to when you encounter an ambulance in a rush (presumably with sirens on)?
I’m not going to defend autonomous driving here, I think it is awful that these things have been allowed on our roads before they are 100% ironed out. But it would be nice to see the video before coming to too many conclusions.
- shepardrtc 3y ago> Why weren’t those people pulling over, like you are supposed to when you encounter an ambulance in a rush (presumably with sirens on)? Because they didn't care about the person in the ambulance.
- sergers 3y agoYea seems a little weird. Here if a ambulance has lights and sirens on, it has right away in every direction (including going opposite of traffic), where everyone pulls over to the shoulder. https://www2.gov.bc.ca/gov/content/transportation/driving-and-cycling/road-safety-rules-and-consequences/slow-down-move-over https://www2.gov.bc.ca/gov/content/transportation/driving-an... And if there are other first responders, which sounds like firefighters? They usually section off the area with either their vehicle. Sounds like this was multilane both directions, and noone cared there was a ambulance... Oh right it's san fran
- bee_rider 3y agoIf it really is a case of “autonomous vehicle can’t pull to the right to get out of the way of the emergency vehicle because there’s traffic flowing there,” then it was just a bad move to roll out autonomous cars in an area with so many malfunctioning human drivers.