3 ms·
Hi: Since I wrote this I just want to clarify that I did not say that newspapers were the only ones in the accountability business; I intentionally said news m
by barthjg 15y ago
Hi:
Since I wrote this I just want to clarify that I did not say that newspapers were the only ones in the accountability business; I intentionally said news media, which is a wide swath that also is meant to include certain bloggers and others. Newspapers do NOT have a monopoly on that.
Also, I intentionally did not include 'government related funding' in my mention of what's worth learning from public media's business model. I stressed the role of listeners and the value that public media has been able to gain from developing a reliable and meaningful RELATIONSHIP with listeners. That has taken 40 years to build.
I agree that investigative reporting is a high point and necessary one for journalism, but let's not discount the importance of day in, day out reporting that informs and accurately reflects the life, doings, role, malfeasance of institutions and people of a community. There are some impressive local blogs and sites that do an ambitious job of capturing a pretty full picture of what is going on. My hat's off to them. They need support. Reporting on scandals and forcing out the scoundrels is only one measure of the value of a good news outfit.
Newspaper ownership is a mixed bag; some owners would not know the First Amendment if it bit them. But then there is the McClatchy chain whose DC bureau did some of the most outstanding and aggressive reporting on the lead up to the Iraq War. No one paper or news organization performs well or poorly all the time. But I take the point of one poster here, I think, that a newspaper is only as good as its owners' and leaderships' commitment to independence and the role of an aggressive press.
What is killing a lot of papers -- and my op ed only touches on the mix of factors -- is high production costs, debt and relevance of these brands and forms to audiences with many other choices. The NYTimes HAS an audience, so does the WSJournal. But so does Google and Slashdot and Mashable and Gawker. The news space is crowded with a lot of value for new audiences hungry for the right mix. If you find your news sites valuable to you, then support their business model. What we need are credible, accurate and competitive news businesses.
Thank you all for the thoughtful feedback. This is the sort of debate and discussion I was hoping the oped would generate.
Finally, this crazy notion that journalism is not that hard. It is. Good journalism is very hard, demanding, damning and public. Go to a crime scene at 2AM, or into a courtroom, or try an election night and let's see how good you are at getting the story of what is going on. Only an uninformed cynic would think that ANY profession done well is 'easy.'Take a look at the LV Sun link I included - that investigation into patient deaths and suffering at local hospitals was groundbreaking work. Not at all 'easy.'
-John