10 ms·
Da Vinci robot surgeon removes inoperable tumor, saving patient’s life
- konschubert 3y agoThis is an ad with very little information.
- jaclaz 3y agoIt seems more a summary of this (linked to): https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/first-person-robot-surgeon-1.6946399 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/first-p...
- Ekaros 3y agoSo sounds like slow news-day. A columnist got surgery done for case with some complications. Next some other publication wrote article to generate articles. Essentially showing where we are. Mildly interesting things get circulated.
- RockRobotRock 3y agoWhy would da Vinci need to advertise?
- ftxbro 3y ago[flagged]
- chrisjj 3y agoLet's not forget "Swan and Morton scapel No. 3 removes inoperable tumor, saving patient’s life" ... 100,000 times.
- mrabcx 3y agoHow could it be inoperable if a human controlled robot managed to remove it?
- glimshe 3y agoInoperable without the robot, which can reach deeper where hand controlled instruments wouldn't be able to.
- prasadjoglekar 3y agoTL;DR: old human hand based surgery breaks the jaw to get to the area of the throat where the cancer was. Causes lots of complications after; or is simply deemed too hard. The robot is more dextrous and thinner and can do the surgery without breaking the jawbones.
- srean 3y agoIn a similar way that a scalpel helps execute a surgery that's inoperable without a scalpel. There's a lot of difference between a scalpel and a 'robot' but its a tool nonetheless. In other words, I agree with what you are saying.
- dv_dt 3y agoAs I understand the daVinci device is not really a robot in the sense that it works autonomously. It’s a precision waldo setup with a surgeon in control.
- idiot900 3y agoRobotic head and neck surgery is routine at major medical centers all over. Da Vinci has been around for many years and it is human controlled. I’m glad this patient was helped but there is absolutely nothing interesting otherwise about this.
- richk449 3y agoWhat an amazing world we live in. There is nothing interesting about a robotic assisted surgery able to perform more delicate and sophisticated operations than the best human surgeon in the world.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 3y ago>What an amazing world we live in. The kind of amazing where untold millions of people can't afford basic healthcare in the same country that we have a robot surgeon?
- richk449 3y agoYea, amazing, not perfect. If DaVinci hadn’t developed the robot, would more people be able to afford health care?
- coldtea 3y agoIf we were spending more on spreading the basics and less on 'nice to have' robots, yes.
- iancmceachern 3y agoYes. Da Vinci is famously not better. There isn't a single study showing its better. It's also not less expensive, and doesn't reduce staffing needs in the OR. What is it? A marketing tool. Surgery centers and hospitals can drive increases in patients and patient throughput, improving their bottom line. It's marketing and throughout. They have a classic razor razor blade model. The surgical instrument are proprietary and locked in with eeprom chips in the disposables. They only last a handful if cases and then must be replaces. Intuitive made something like 80 billion last year and has had no real competition in their market for decades. As a result they've been able to pretty much write their own checks, choosing how much stuff costs and achieving huge margins on lots of very expensive equipment and supplies. Source- I've worked on and lead the design teams for surgical robots for several companies in the field.
- MattGaiser 3y agoI have been hearing about Da Vinci for years and Wikipedia says it was being for 200,000 surgeries back in 2012. [0] The manufacturer claims there are about 7000 of the units. Is this remarkable? I would imagine that it saves thousands of lives a year. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Da_Vinci_Surgical_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Da_Vinci_Surgical_System
- coldtea 3y agoYes, but it's the most precious lives. The lives of those who can afford it.
- MattGaiser 3y agoThis surgery happened in Canada, where there is universal health care.
- coldtea 3y agoThe universal health care in Canada is a little overrated: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/may/11/canada-cases-right-to-die-laws https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/may/11/canada-cases-r...
- rurban 3y agoNot on civilised countries. There the robots do save everybodies lifes.
- bionhoward 3y agoOne time in med school we had a lecture by the da Vinci surgeon guy, and of course I had to stick my hand up. “Will there ever come a time when the human hand cannot keep up with the instrument?” The whole room (200 people) laughed out loud, and the surgeon said, “No.”
- jwilk 3y agoWhat do you mean by "cannot keep up with the instrument"?
- dredmorbius 3y agoJohn Henry: <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Henry_(folklore) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Henry_(folklore)>
- richk449 3y agoAnyone know more about robot assist systems in general? Are there similar systems for performing delicate assembly operations on a production line? (Non medical) The die binders that I used to use had physical motion reduction systems - are there more general versions of these available?
- arcticbull 3y agoThe whole sub specialty of design for manufacturing and assembly (DFMA) helps us avoid the need for humans in robot exoskeletons on the assembly line.
- rurban 3y agoI do work for the competition (medical). There should be, but no idea
- Ekaros 3y agoYou don't probably want delicate assembly operations on production lines. You do everything possible in designing what ever you are building to not do them. On other hand, multi-axial CNC machines and various welding robots are quite amazing.
- robotresearcher 3y ago“Surgeon removes tumor using current best practices” doesn’t sound so exciting, but is actually more amazing. These devices have made some hard surgeries much more doable.
- capableweb 3y agoIn this case, it's about a "inoperable tumor" so I'm guessing a human hand wouldn't be able to do it at all. That's what makes this particular case more amazing.
- vorticalbox 3y agoThe article states it would have required breaking the jaw in two. So it was doable but as the article states "no one was lining up"
- robotresearcher 3y agoBut they didn’t have to line up to do it that way, because the robot is widely available these days.
- vorticalbox 3y agoYeah in this case I think it's a bit of creative titling. It's "inoperable" in the sense "no one wanted to do it by hand"
- CuriousCosmic 3y agoWell only if you don't consider the surgeon who operated the davinci robot. Not to diminish this case at all but people kinda misinterpret how surgical robots operate. They are less like CNC robots where you program in a control path before hand and the robot follows it. Rather they are like a set of "prosthetic" tools that allow you to stabilize your movements and shrink them down to extremely small motions beyond the precision human hands are capable of. It still takes an extremely skilled human surgeon at the controls at all points of the surgery to make this possible, these are just tools that give those surgeons more fidelity and stability in their motions. No less amazing in the slightest but make no mistake that this surgery was performed by a human, just with a far more advanced kit of scalpels and forceps.
- iancmceachern 3y agoI really don't like these kinds of headlines. The medical professionals are the real heros here. If the da Vinci system had just come out and this was some new capability I would understand. In this case the headline should say "surgical staff saves life of inoperable patient using standard surgical quality of care and using device that has been available on the.market for 15 years". It's one thing to say "new Invention of the automobile saves life of first ambulance passenger" and another to say, today, the same thing.
- vasco 3y agoThe hero talk is really cringy. Other than that, it's not going to be long until we don't need anyone controlling it and for us to find it barbaric that we used to expose ourselves to factors like "trembling hands" or other such nonsense inside our guts.
- iancmceachern 3y agoI think someone going above and beyond to literally save another's life, despite incredible odds, is the definition of a hero. What's cringe about that? There are two sides to this coin. It's the classic do we want to keep a human in the loop, or not. By your same point we could argue that robots are more efficient killing machines, so let's make autonomous killing robots. Back to surgery, there are lots of reasons you want a surgeon in the loop. There are lots if things that robots can do better too (like your tremor example). The key, like many things, is in the shade of grey in between, not the extreme arguments on both sides. I stand by calling that surgical staff heros, and also think that the future of (good) surgery lies in the combination of skilled medical professional and machine, not the replacement of skilled professionals by machines. Disclaimer: I work in this space
- BrandoElFollito 3y ago> so let's make autonomous killing robots. I think that this is not ethics or something that stops us from doing that, but rather the poor state of robotics. The second we can, we will have autonomous killing robots à la Terminator (but better because they are not really optimal by looking like us)
- porkbeer 3y agoThe controls on the da vinci are absolute shite. Congrats to the very skilled surgeon, not this useless advert of an article.
- markwkw 3y agoI just had a thought. A thin robotic worm. Can squeeze through and around important organs/vassels. When its head reaches the tumor it gently chews and siphons the tumor. I’m imagining tiny mechanical jaws just for cool effect
- xwdv 3y agoI thought most tumors could be operable soon by destroying them with some kind of focused ultrasonic energy at a specific point?
- lr1970 3y agoRobotic laryngectomy has been around for several years already and is quite common in the US. Source: my wife participates in these surgeries.
- 1letterunixname 3y ago"It's the man, not the machine."* - Chuck Yeager * "Without me, my rifle is useless. Without my rifle, I am useless."** It's the man and the machine together as a super-organism. ** https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rifleman%27s_Creed https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rifleman%27s_Creed Disclaimer: I played with a Da Vinci prototype sewing grapes but I'm definitely no surgeon. My hands shake more than someone with Parkinson's. I cannot fathom subsequent generations of refinements in steadier hands with surgical experience. Clarke's third law applies here. Although, I wonder before how long AI and mechatronics will receive credit for simple veterinary surgeries as a testbed on the path to a truly miraculous, sci-fi "surgical chamber".