4 ms·
This is always where geeks run off the rails in discussions like this. We want to come up with rules for things: either this statement is "sexist" or it is not
by ajross 15y ago
This is always where geeks run off the rails in discussions like this. We want to come up with rules for things: either this statement is "sexist" or it is not, and here is the objective reason for that decision.
But it misses the point. Context matters. In a utopian environment where women felt equally respected, sure, a sideways/slightly-inappropriate comment would be fine. In some workplaces today that might even be true. But it's not the norm, and in the real world people feel disrespected by this kind of treatment. Not everyone (but some, sure, as I'm sure someone will point out needlessly) likes the fact that their perfectly "normal" clothing choice can make them "attractive" in one context but the butt of a joke in another. Men, on the whole, don't deal with that.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoWe want to come up with rules for things: either this statement is "sexist" or it is not, and here is the objective reason for that decision. Um, yes - geeks want objective rules which allow us to figure out that an activity is either legitimate or not. This principle is called the "rule of law". Are you advocating that we should abandon the rule of law in cases of sexism?
- apenwarr 15y agoLaws are the bare minimum set of rules for your moral behaviour - the stuff that's so bad we have to punish you if you do it. If you can't do better than the bare minimum, then you're doing very poorly at morality. Not all good behaviour can be written down as clear-cut rules. I sure wish you could, but you can't. It's a bit like the story of what happens if you try to measure programmer productivity: whatever measurement you use (eg. lines of code), someone will find a way to game the system. Yet people can still be "obviously" more productive even if we don't have a numerical way to prove it.
- jdp23 15y agoWhat apenwarr said. Also the "rule of law" is nowhere near as objective in the geek sense as you seem to think. It's filled with concepts like "the reasonable person" and "mens rea" which are heavily contextual and subjective.
- brown9-2 15y agoAttempting to find nature's law governing complex social interactions sounds like a fool's errand.
- chunkybacon 15y agoThe rule is: some girls like it, some girls don't. You have to know what they will like before you open your mouth.
- sophacles 15y agoOh bullshit. If I'm hanging out with my boss at a barbegue and does something stupid and I say "you're such a dumbass", it's a fun jab. If my boss says incorrect or misinformed in front of customers, and I say the exact same thing, in the exact same tones with the exact same stupid grin, it could be a lost sale, and a reprimand. Context does matter, and it's not some whimsical flight of fancy by fickle and capricious women.
- kamaal 15y agoMy rule is Simple, Girls or Boys. Black or white, no matter what race, religion, ethnicity or even personal preferences people have. Deal with them professionally. Judge them with only on performance, nothing else.
- rmc 15y ago"girls"?! Do you know many female children that wear low cut tops? Or do you mean adult women?
- Anderkent 15y agoVia google: Girl: A young or relatively young woman A young woman of a specified kind or having a specified job - a career girl Women who mix socially or belong to a particular group, team, or profession - I look forward to having lunch with the girls Perhaps this is a language issue, but it's just as common for me to call my male friends 'boys' as my female friends 'girls', even though all are adults. Not sure what the issue here is.
- rmc 15y agoThere can be a lot of hang overs in languages that aim to demean and diminish people. Calling a black man "boy", or a woman "girl" is a way to belittle them. "Boy" vs "Girl" is an interesting one. It's not uncommon, as you pointed out, to call adult women "girl". However you rarely in the straight male world do people refer to adult men as "boy". However in the gay male world, sometimes "boy" is used (e.g. this collection of gay short films 'Boys on Film': http://www.amazon.co.uk/Boys-Film-Hard-Love-DVD/dp/B001L5JMQ6/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1332419006&sr=8-1 http://www.amazon.co.uk/Boys-Film-Hard-Love-DVD/dp/B001L5JMQ... ). This shows that "boy" (and hence "girl") is a slightly sexualised way to talk about someone. Should you be using sexualised terms in a professional environment? No, so say "women". (BTW: Just because your google search found some results that back up what you say, but might be a bit misogynistic doesn't mean google is right. "Jew Watch" still shows up above the fold if I search for "Jew", but it would be wrong of me to excuse anti-Semitism based on that reasoning)