5 ms·
Public perception (as judged by art, which usually represents a slightly caricatured version of reality) seems to imply that your attractiveness and the appropr
by Swizec 15y ago
Public perception (as judged by art, which usually represents a slightly caricatured version of reality) seems to imply that your attractiveness and the appropriateness of your comments are inversely correlated.
That is to say, if you tell a woman she looks good, it will be a compliment if she likes you, a sexist remark if she doesn't.
- jiggy2011 15y agoThere's some truth in this, I have observed women who will happily let some strange guy basically feel them up in a club if he is good looking and call him "cheeky". Whereas an ugly looking guy who makes eye contact or smiles at them is regarded as a creep or potential rapist. In fact I remember reading somewhere that a persons physical attractiveness had a fairly significant affect on the likely verdict where they to be the defendant in a trial.
- dlitz 15y agoThey're all creeps. Some just get away with it.
- ryanwaggoner 15y agoThere's a running joke on Reddit that the best way to avoid being labeled creepy when hitting on a woman is to: 1. Be attractive. 2. Don't be unattractive. And there is definitely truth to this.
- scott_s 15y agoThen it's a good thing this isn't Reddit.
- freshhawk 15y agoYeah, the conversation here has been so much more enlightened.
- mkramlich 15y agoI've generally found that when it comes to matters of gender and sexuality, the more "enlightened" one claims to be, the far less actual experience in life, with real people, one actually has. The college/twenty-something years in particular are wonderful for many things, and universities are wonderful for many things, but one thing they're bad at is giving you a realistic view of the world as it actually is, and people as they actually are, rather than as how one ideally might like them to be. A view less based on reality than based on theory or political agenda.
- scott_s 15y agoThe next time I have to sit through an HR-and-Legal mandated harassment course for work, and I catch myself thinking "Is anyone actually this clueless to think saying such things is okay?" I'll make sure to remind myself, yes, some people are.
- freshhawk 15y agoYeah, the number of "this is how things should be" type comments here is silly. As if we can wish away the neurological aspects of human beings we don't like or that don't fit with whatever utopian ideology they espouse. It's naive but I did expect at least a little pragmatism from this group.
- gojomo 15y ago...which is lifted from an SNL skit, with Tom Brady: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gBVuAGFcGKY http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gBVuAGFcGKY
- jschmitz28 15y agoDo you mean directly correlated? If you are more attractive, your comments will be more appropriate. If you are less attractive, your comments will be less appropriate.
- BenOfTomorrow 15y agoIf it's in an wildly inappropriate context, her perception of you can switch from "like" to "dislike" quickly. It's a factor, but lots of women have stories about attractive creeps.
- tomp 15y agoThere's much more to this... A totally attractive guy (model-like) that emanates low self-confidence (shyness, bad posture, ...) could still have his comments perceived in a negative way (i.e. as being sexist, not compliments). So, I believe that we tend to judge this from the perspective of the perceived intent of the person making the comments. A self confident gut -> he's probably just being sincere -> cure. A not-self-confident guy -> he's trying to get something from her -> looser. (Probably applies with the sex roles reversed, but I have no actual experience to lean on). At the workplace, the label looser is just switched for the label creepy/sexist.
- jiggy2011 15y agoPerhaps but attractive looking people rarely emenate low confidence if at all, confident but ugly guys are more common but still relatively rare. I guess because of a positive or negative feedback cycle.
- knightenvy 15y agoI have always believed that confidence has a huge effect on what a person looks like. The most beautiful person can look like a mess if they do not believe in themselves.
- MPSimmons 15y ago...because there are no examples of overconfident sexist assholes?
- sherlocked 15y agoThere's a world of difference between a compliment (such as "nice dress!" and "Katie's got the low cut dress on today! I know where I'm sitting!" You could look like a literal Ryan Gosling clone and I'd still be offended if you told me the second statement at work.
- mkramlich 15y ago> That is to say, if you tell a woman she looks good, it will be a compliment if she likes you, a sexist remark if she doesn't. this. nailed it. it depends way more on how she feels and what she thinks of you, than on whether the words/act itself is somehow inherently wrong or sexist. that doesn't mean it's wise to say things or do things like that in the workplace: it isn't. but based on decades of actual experience on this planet this, your observation, rings true to me.