3 ms·
> I dislike how much for Tolkien being good means the same thing as obeying the right authority. Yes and no. At least in LoTR, Tolkien's various Team Evil gro
by bell-cot 3y ago
> I dislike how much for Tolkien being good means the same thing as obeying the right authority.
Yes and no. At least in LoTR, Tolkien's various Team Evil groups are pretty authoritarian. Often with the under-baddies ready to disobey or rebel the moment they think that they can get away with it. Under threat of war or violence, the various Team Good groups also tend to military-flavored authoritarianism.
But consider the start-of-story societies of the hobbits and the ents. Both have enjoyed centuries of fairly idyllic peace. The hobbits' authority figures - King, Thain, and Mayor - have faded to mythical and ceremonial offices. And their law enforcement officers seem to have been nothing but the Sherriffs - a dozen hobbits, armed only with walking sticks, with a feather in their caps as their "uniform". When the ent leader (Fangorn) is finally roused to action, he has to think long and hard to recall what other able-bodied ents there even are.
Having two such societies prominent of LoTR suggest to me that Tolkien had some quite un-authoritarian ideals.
(Yes, I'm omitting the Bounders, and Buckland's High Hay hedge, and ...)
- watwut 3y ago> Tolkien's various Team Evil groups are pretty authoritarian. Often with the under-baddies ready to disobey or rebel the moment they think that they can get away with it. It is always framed as a result of their badness. They do not rebel because they would plan to do something good - they rebel because they are selfish.