4 ms·
I’ve been using UPI since its very early days when it used to fail quite often. UPI is still one of the best things to happen in the financial scene in India. H
by Brajeshwar 3y ago
I’ve been using UPI since its very early days when it used to fail quite often. UPI is still one of the best things to happen in the financial scene in India. However, these days, personally, I’m trying to reduce it to either known people, or established institutions. I wish there is another layer of tokenization when one pays via UPI, like how Apple Pay does. I wish that the transaction is obfuscated and the phone numbers and/or UPI ID are hidden.
You pay for a nice hot cup of ₹10 Chai on the streets but then you got a phone call later on - naively to upsell something, or the next step up, trying to scam you. Unlike me, my wife continues to pick up every incoming phone calls. We have had enough calls from people whom she paid via UPI trying to sell or this/that and what not.
There is a scam going on in India. Random females, who are either naked or scantily clothed, will call up on WhatsApp Video. If you pick up the call, say while in the bathroom and not fully clothed, they will take screenshots and threaten you that they will make that picture “viral” to extort money. I won't be surprised if there is an under-belly of phone numbers and other data being sold that were collected via UPI payment transactions.
Cash is still OK at the tea-stalls, the random shop, etc. Well, when I just wanted to have a simple Bombay’s cutting-chai but the chai-guy wants my phone number, and everything else -- I'm not comfortable with that.
- crop_rotation 3y agoUsing ICICI bank iMobile you can create a random UPI id totally unrelated to your phone number I agree with the problems you mention, and in general there is an increasing trend of taking phone numbers of customers in India, e.g. once at a Nike store, I was told the purchase couldn't be complete without the phone number.
- vinay_ys 3y agoI refuse to give phone numbers and usually the cashier will enter their own fake phone number to let the system proceed further. Some shops like decathlon tried to force us to install their app, create an account and then scan and pay through that – at the cashier counter. I just left the entire shopping cart there and walked out without purchasing. Such crazy things do happen but those companies will learn the lesson quickly as Indians are quite savvy about these things.
- crop_rotation 3y agoI do the same but in this case I had already made the payment and they refused to give me an invoice without a contact number, and I didn't have any interest in a confrontation. If I had not made a payment I would have simply walked out.
- wtmt 3y agoNext time, tell them that the Union Minister of State for Electronics and IT has said that people shouldn’t give their phone numbers at retailers if there’s no justifiable reason. [1] If they refuse to give an invoice, tell them you’ll report them for GST evasion. [2] [1]: https://www.onmanorama.com/news/india/2023/02/13/rajeev-chandrasekhar-mobile-number-retailers.html https://www.onmanorama.com/news/india/2023/02/13/rajeev-chan... [2]: https://theprint.in/economy/govt-launches-gst-reward-scheme-in-6-states-uts-rs-30-crore-corpus-for-prize-money/1742070/ https://theprint.in/economy/govt-launches-gst-reward-scheme-...
- sudshekhar 3y agoYou can create an alphanumeric UPI handle on most UPI applications. This will hide your phone number. Eg: My UPI id is sudshekhar.cheq@trans. Most other UPI apps allow you to create such handles AFAIK. Nowadays, you can also keep your bank details private by using UPI with a wallet instead of savings account.
- captn3m0 3y agoThe UPI protocol lets the acquirer lookup this to get additional information, and this is being used by several acquirers, notably Smartbuy@HDFC to provide phone numbers to merchants.
- sudshekhar 3y agoI think most data selling happens via branch employees / telecom operators instead of "at the top" Banks / UPI vendors have to comply with very strict data regulations and the confirmation of a "data leak" is enough to attract heavy penalties from the NPCI and RBI. Most banks and UPI service providers will never risk it, specially post the DEPA guidelines which have recently been adopted.
- captn3m0 3y agoSee this thread on twitter for reports: https://nitter.net/jackerhack/status/1632029845642412033 https://nitter.net/jackerhack/status/1632029845642412033, https://nitter.net/jackerhack/status/1630636510994378752 https://nitter.net/jackerhack/status/1630636510994378752
- sudshekhar 3y agoBoth these tweets can be addressed by adopting a UPI enabled wallet. Using Cheq, you can keep your bank account plus mobile number secret. Everyday small value transactions can also be consolidated separately from your main bank account. I don't think anyone is selling data in the UPI ecosystem but if they are, that's a very short-sighted strategy to make money for sure.
- gruez 3y ago>There is a scam going on in India. Random females, who are either naked or scantily clothed, will call up on WhatsApp Video. If you pick up the call, say while in the bathroom and not fully clothed, they will take screenshots and threaten you that they will make that picture “viral” to extort money. This is baffling. First, how much % of the day do you spend naked? 1-2%? So the success rate of any given call is going to be 1-2% at most, given that otherwise theres nothing scandalous to post. Second, do people just instinctively accept video calls, while they're naked? That seems very unlikely to me.
- Brajeshwar 3y agoThe receiver don't have to be naked. So, here is the story that got me to look into this a bit to learn what was happening. Father-in-law don't keep all the phone numbers updated, so, he picks up all calls -- mostly video calls from his kids and grandkids. One day, he picked up a WhatsApp Video, where the woman on the other end was pretty much naked. Father-in-law was in the couch and gave the phone to my wife, asking who is on the other end. After some verbal exchanges to stop calling us; a barrage of WhatsApp message began -- screenshots of a semi naked women and father-in-law on a video chat. I ignored the first time wife complained. By the 3rd, or so message, I called up a friend to give them a casual call and let them know who he was. Yeah! This whole scamming to get people's picture in phone screenshots getting "viral" seems to be a common scam in India.
- vinay_ys 3y agoIf all it takes is a screenshot, why not just photoshop it? Why do you need to call at all? I know there are a lot of scam calls trying to get payment credentials or get people to make payments but this MO sounds quite implausible.
- Brajeshwar 3y agoThe screenshot is likely the precursor the the video they record since the call got established. For most non-tech, and generations prior to us, would be startled, and likely to act in a haste to avoid further embarrassment. Let's say they have a success rate of less than 10% (1 in 10 calls), it is worth their time sitting in cabin somewhere in a town in India earning ₹25,000 a month working for an "Support Call Center" helping them setup this scam patterns. You wanna try a sure-shot scam/Spam game right now? 1. Register a domain in India or via an Indian registrar, I will guarantee you that in the next few days to weeks, you will get all the needed spam in your inbox associated with that domain registration. If you have given your phone number, then they will call up there too. 2. Register a company. Baam! Phone calls, emails, and the very famous Book Parcel scam via the post office to the registered address, and what not. Have fun. India is definitely not for beginners. /wink
- achow 3y ago> You pay for a nice hot cup of ₹10 Chai on the streets but then you got a phone call later on - naively to upsell something.. Not sure what is this about. Everyone pays using QR Code. No personal information like phone numbers are passed on to the merchant.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- crop_rotation 3y agoPaying via QR code is irrelevant, the receiver will see the UPI id you paid via, and 99.9% UPI ids are phone@<some_alias>. The QR code just is a shortcut to typing the UPI id.
- tecoholic 3y agoI withheld using UPI through the pandemic and a long while after that because of the no. of fraud cases I kept reading about and my reservations about UPI’s origins. But gave in and got in after moving to a new city and getting stuck in multiple places for the want of 5/10 rupees in change that somehow nobody seemed to had. I mostly just use it my grocery store and vegetable store or in those no-change situations. Yet, in the last week alone I have blocked at least 3 WhatsApp chats from unknown numbers about offers, business deals, one even very friendly female hi. Now I know from where
- achow 3y agoIf you have 'custom' UPI ID (and not <phone number>@bank) then UPI payment is not an issue
- wtmt 3y agoNo, a custom UPI ID won’t save you from your phone number being shared with merchants. [1] UPI payments also leak the person’s full legal name on transactions. Whether this is useful in merchant payments (not personal payments to known people) is highly doubtful. [1]: https://scroll.in/article/1045536/are-your-upi-payments-farming-your-personal-data-without-your-consent https://scroll.in/article/1045536/are-your-upi-payments-farm...
- tecoholic 3y agoI wanted even things like my bank name or UPI app itself to be private. So I discovered that we can creat a 9 digit UPI number/ID and use that. But doesn’t seem to help. Support for that seems to be non-existent. I have tried entering it places that ask for UPI id like online portals, but no. Only the @ format seems to be supported everywhere
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoDamn. UPI shares your phone number? Instant PLONK. But I have been hearing raves about how great it is, from my Indian friends.
- sameerds 3y agoNot the protocol itself. Your ID is an arbitrary alphanumeric string that you register with a provider. But most people just use their phone number.
- wtmt 3y agoSee https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37371646 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37371646
- wtmt 3y agoI’ll avoid repeating my previous comment [1], which has details on this. Unlike the mistaken belief of several people on this post, UPI does share the phone number even if a person uses an alphanumeric UPI ID instead of the initial or common phonenumber@provider address. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37371646 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37371646
- davchana 3y agoNo, you can make any upi id, like emails. Apps, being lazy, start giving phonenumber@app id to its new users. I always have used custom@app upi ID.
- jimkleiber 3y agoI'm not sure if it's possible with UPI but I know in Kenya many people will get a second, cheaper phone to use for m-pesa (mobile money), I think partially so the battery doesn't die on it but it could also reduce the types of calls you're talking about, or at least make it obvious that someone is calling your mobile money number. Is that possible with UPI? Or even a dual sim? I'm not sure if the account is tied to the person or the number.
- bitwidget 3y agoI think the issue is that Bank Accounts also need phone numbers linked to them and it seemed like only one phone number could be tied to an account. Having a secondary phone number used to combat spam also being the sole number tied to a Bank account could be bad. I could be wrong about the single phone number for an account, but that was what I experienced recently.
- davchana 3y agoAccount is tied to person's account number. Apps usually need current crop of phones, 5-7 years old phones not supported by app store are also not supported by apps.
- dmix 3y ago> but then you got a phone call later on - naively to upsell something, or the next step up, trying to scam you This should have been obvious in retrospect. Call spam is India's biggest export.
- fmobus 3y agoAnyone doing video calls sorta deserves it, especially if they are accepting video calls from people they don't know. EDIT: we kind of solved this problem in Brazil (PIX is similar do UPI, predates it in fact), as the user can opt to user other identifiers, or even generate a random GUID-like identifier.
- unmole 3y ago> PIX is similar do UPI, predates it in fact PIX was announced in 2019, UPI was launched in 2016.
- abkolan 3y ago>I wish that the transaction is obfuscated and the phone numbers and/or UPI ID are hidden. You can create a Private UPI ID it's supported on PayTM. Your phone number is not revealed when you send / receive payments.
- sanroot99 3y agoYou can create a virtual Id to protect phone number