5 ms·
> The Stallman movement failed The stuff you read on hn... Seriously, you think it failed? I think it succeeded wildly beyond anything anybody imagined at the
by jacquesm 3y ago
> The Stallman movement failed
The stuff you read on hn...
Seriously, you think it failed? I think it succeeded wildly beyond anything anybody imagined at the time, to the point that very large entities threw everything and the kitchensink at it to try to make it fail. Which exposed them for the criminals they were.
We don't need anything that is more compatible with 'business owners' than what we've got. What we need is education, so that people stop telling each other that the free software movement failed, but instead point out that without that free software movement the operating system, the browser and the applications on the computer that I'm writing this on would not exist.
- rapnie 3y agoGiven your last paragraph, what is the net trend in society of that happening with enough speed to outpace other negative developments? Would it be more accurate to say that the Free Software movement is in need for an update, or making next steps, to provide a better outlook in this regard? Edit: Changed "Stallman movement" to "Free Software movement". I am a FOSS advocate myself, but not interested in deeply engrained notions around Stallman himself.
- jacquesm 3y agoI think it's doing fine as it is within the limits of the law. If you want more you're going to have to either operate outside of the law or you're going to have to have the laws changed. But within the law the Free Software Movement used all of the available space, to the point that almost every other license out there is less strict than theirs. What needs to be updated is the the knowledge of the users and of the programmers. But we've been co-opted as an industry for the most part by very large bags of money and a service oriented eco-system is the capitalist response to the free software movement. Doing an end run around that is hard to enforce (see the various licenses that address this loophole directly) without having the backing of a regulator. I see this as a simple swing of the pendulum, which it has done several times in the past regarding centralization and decentralization of computers: single machines -> single machines with terminals and time sharing -> mini computers with terminals -> microcomputers -> networked micro computers -> networked micro computers using peer-to-peer services -> networked micro computers with access to services -> special purpose computers (terminals!) with access to services. So if we want to do away with these we'd need to focus on the technical implementation of federated services that do not require central services at all. One thing you could advocate for is to restore peer-to-peer capabilities of residential internet but the fear of the hacker card will be played to counter that one. But there is also still pressure to push the pendulum one more step to the right: identified access to the internet and without that no service. This may well happen, I would expect a country like the UK or Australia to be first to implement this. Also note that there is no actual technical driving force behind the pendulum, it doesn't have to swing at all, it could just as easily get stuck. The important common factor between all of the above was that someone (or lots of someones) made a lot of money by driving the swing.
- louthy 3y agoBusinesses don't do free. It is not what they exist for: The 'Stallman movement' isn't compatible with the the tech-company, the employed software-engineer, etc. I think what the OP is getting at is that the for-profit tech industry needs something akin to the Hippocratic Oath [1]. As software engineers swearing to a set of 'do no harm' ethical codes could well be a first step to becoming a recognised professional. I can certainly see a future with a framework like that. If a doctor does something unethical it could affect the life of a few people. If a programmer does it, it could affect the lives of billions - it's not a hard sell that something like an ethical code is probably well overdue. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hippocratic_Oath https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hippocratic_Oath
- jacquesm 3y agoThe for profit industry has been very happy to integrate the fruits of the FOSS labor. And yes, we need an ethics framework for the IT industry, but we need liability more than that and I don't think either is going to happen in the next 10 years. Maybe if there is a mass death (> 10K people at once or so, a few 100 doesn't seem to have made a difference so far) on account of a software issue we will finally wake up.
- louthy 3y ago> The for profit industry has been very happy to integrate the fruits of the FOSS labor. Of course they are. They get free labour and their profits are therefore higher. which is the entire purpose of any corporation, to maximise profits. Being upset about this is futile, it's the artefact of living in a capitalist world. The free-software movement just isn't going to move the needle on that. They can either come up with a licensing model that pays, or get over it. But really, this isn't about FOSS, it's about engineers everywhere (whether in FOSS or working 9-5 in a software company) making ethical decisions and understanding the impact of their work, on potentially billions of people. Critically, I think having something to point at, "this is the oath I swore to", when talking to a boss, could be just the thing we need.
- dinkleberg 3y agoI think this is one of the areas where software being treated as "not real engineering" caused some trouble. I went to school for electrical engineering and in my senior year they really pushed the idea of engineering ethics [1] and the personal responsibilities we had to whistle-blow. There is this Order of the Engineer [2] that has their own oath akin to the Hippocratic Oath. I went down the software path so I never really looked into it, but my professors were very in favor of it. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Engineering_ethics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Engineering_ethics [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Order_of_the_Engineer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Order_of_the_Engineer
- dennis_jeeves1 3y ago[flagged]
- dang 3y agoWe've banned this account for repeatedly breaking the site guidelines. Please don't create accounts to break HN's rules with. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- ThrowawayR2 3y ago> "I think it succeeded wildly beyond anything anybody imagined at the time..." Somebody needs their memory refreshed. What was imagined at the time is that nearly all proprietary software companies, particularly Microsoft, would have gone bankrupt or bowed to the inevitable necessity to release all their source code to the community under capital-F Free licenses and nearly all businesses that use software would be voluntarily contributing any code developed for their own use to the community also under Free licenses so that their code would help others and others' code would help them. Needless to say, this has not happened. Instead, FOSS turned out to be an enormous free handout to businesses with very little contribution back to the community compared to the value received. (Yes, even the Linux kernel. If there were contributions to Linux by all businesses that use it that were even a tenth of what Microsoft charges for Windows, there would be a thousand full time kernel developers.) That is failure and developers are recognizing that by turning away from Free licenses to fake FOSS licenses like open core or shared source.