3 ms·
> Non-App Store Version > A special version for users that cannot access the App Store. It won’t receive automatic updates. I will update it here once a year.
by satvikpendem 3y ago
> Non-App Store Version
> A special version for users that cannot access the App Store. It won’t receive automatic updates. I will update it here once a year.
Looks nice but not sure why you don't just put it on Homebrew instead of updating the non-app store version once a year.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- joshmanders 3y agoYou're welcome to submit a PR to Homebrew if you want it there. Why is it his job to put it there for you?
- satvikpendem 3y agoThey don't have to submit it to Homebrew. Similarly I don't have to use it. If I have to submit a PR to Homebrew when an app's creator can (and usually does) do it themselves, it's likely I will just use something on Homebrew already, like Itsycal, which I have just started using as a result of someone else mentioning it. It's just a difference of opinion, nothing more.
- ghotli 3y agoI maintain something like this. You're talking about maybe ten lines of ruby to accomplish getting this into Homebrew. It would just download this url and perform a checksum.
- satvikpendem 3y agoSounds good, sounds like the creator will have an easy time of adding it to Homebrew then. Until then I will continue using other apps that are already on there.
- joshmanders 3y agoIf it's so simple, why don't you do it since YOU'RE the one who wants it there so badly? You claim it's so easy, just a few minutes, yet you spent more time telling everyone how easy it is for him to do, than just doing it yourself. Can we stop expecting developers to jump to every little request given for a free app?
- satvikpendem 3y agoLike threeseed said in sibling comments, it seems strange to make users do this, all the while trying to use it as a free product to drive traffic to the paid one, which is equivalent to itsycal which is entirely free and open source? Why should the users perform free labor for the creator, while the creator gets to keep all of their paid version's revenue? It is not on the user to add it to Homebrew, it is on the creator. I am not sure why this is contentious at all, except for the sake of arguing. Homebrew packages are usually maintained by the creator, not the user.
- joshmanders 3y ago> which is equivalent to itsycal which is entirely free and open source? > Why should the users perform free labor for the creator, while the creator gets to keep all of their paid version's revenue? It's clear you have no desire to use this at all, you've mentioned many times in this whole parent thread that you would rather use ItsyCal even over this because it has more features... So what exactly is your goal with these demands? Just to make Sindre do something you want? > It is not on the user to add it to Homebrew, it is on the creator. No it's not. The creator has no obligation to do anything for anyone, paid or free. Stop being entitled.
- satvikpendem 3y agoI don't wish to make the creator do anything, all I asked was why it was not on Homebrew rather than having a non app store version be updated only once a year. Then you asked why I don't do it myself. I don't believe the user should be doing stuff like this that is the creator's job. As I said earlier, they don't have to do anything, but at the same time I don't have to use it either. I have no "demands," I don't "demand" that they add it. All I said was that if they do, I'll use it. Again, you haven't answered why users should do it for free while it's a traffic funnel for a paid app. Seems you know this creator personally and support them, but I don't, and most users don't either, and many users use Homebrew so if they don't see it on there, they likely won't use it either. It's not entitlement, it's simply how it works. You wouldn't go into a store who said their inventory is only updated once a year while a store right next to it is updated regularly. Nothing to do with the quality of products in said store, but they're just not the target customer. All this to again say why it's a point of contention to ask, not even why it's not on Homebrew, which wasn't even my point, but why they're expending extra effort to update it once a year when they could make their lives a lot easier by adding it to Homebrew and having it be done automatically.
- threeseed 3y agoAnd then what if the URL changes or the creator completely changes how it is hosted. It seems odd to place the onus on users to help drive traffic for a paid product.
- mofle 3y agoThere is simply not enough demand to justify spending double the time on publishing every update (one build for App Store and one build for Homebrew). There are very few people that use Homebrew and cannot use the App Store. The non-App Store version is intended for users on locked down corporate computers.
- threeseed 3y agoWhy would it be double the time ? At this point I would assume there is a proper CI/CD process and this should just be another target. And when you look at Homebrew users versus App Store users they are like separate circles on a Venn diagram. I am also building a Mac app and will definitely make sure it's on Homebrew. Crazy not to.
- satvikpendem 3y agoAgreed, it really is strange how this is a point of contention for so many people in this thread. Like you, I also think Homebrew packages should be maintained by the creator, not some random user. It's weird that people are pushing a user specifically to put it on Homebrew, that's simply not the user's responsibility.
- joshmanders 3y ago> I also think Homebrew packages should be maintained by the creator, not some random user. Oh boy, I have some unfortunate news for you. The whole ethos of Homebrew is exactly that, userland maintaining formula for software they want... I promise you Microsoft is not maintaining the casks for their stuff. 99% of all formula in the Homebrew repo is maintained solely by volunteers unaffiliated with all of the software. My question for you is why are you replying to everyone insistent on demanding that Sindre do all this for you, someone who will not be using the software anyways? What is your angle here? You're coming off super entitled.
- satvikpendem 3y agoLike I said in my other comment, I'm not "demanding" anything, my initial point wasn't even about Homebrew specifically but about why they're not automating their builds. I don't care whether the creator adds it or not, so it's not a demand from me at all, but it seems like you are the one who's annoyed that I'm just asking about Homebrew in the first place, calling me "entitled" for something I don't even care about.