4 ms·
If the government of Canadia wants to transfer wealth from Facebook and Google to Canadian news companies, why not institute a tax on advertising revenue, and a
by toast0 3y ago
If the government of Canadia wants to transfer wealth from Facebook and Google to Canadian news companies, why not institute a tax on advertising revenue, and a subsidy to newspapers.
A tax on linking to news is clearly just asking for news to not be linked.
- gmerc 3y agoThis indeed is the better approach, and unfortunately the answer is that the motives, just like in Australia, are muddled by media ownership
- tonyarkles 3y agoAustralia is very interesting, because Canada’s plan here is somewhat derived from what Australia did (and Meta and Alphabet did get onboard there). Here’s the slightly different timelines that make all the difference. Australia: - parliament drafts this legislation and starts debating it (public record) - Meta blocks Aus news for 4 days and says “we have some changes we’d like to see if we’re going to play ball” - bill is amended, Mets gets on board - bill is passed Canada: - parliament starts debating the draft of the bill - Meta says “we’d like some changes and we’ll stop doing Canadian news if we don’t negotiate this” - Parliament passes the bill as-is - Meta blocks Canadian news, as promised - Parliament goes on holidays - Media companies are sitting there going “oh noooooo not like this” as a significant amount of their traffic disappears When an insanely profitable multinational company says “if you do X, we will do Y” to the parliament of a country of 35-odd million people, that government has to be insane or incompetent to think “they’re bluffing. Let’s call their bluff and go on holidays”
- gmerc 3y agoImportant note on Australia - FB only made a deal with the biggest companies, Murdochs, who was using the government to apply the pressure. Independent publishers, etc got dropped like a hot stone.
- immibis 3y agoThey're saying Google derives a lot of revenue from having news and linking to news. So yes. Google can exit this market and stop deriving revenue from the work the newspapers do, or they can pay the newspapers for the work they do. Facebook, in particular, has been trying to strangle/EEE news outlets for many years now.
- cscurmudgeon 3y ago> Facebook, in particular, has been trying to strangle/EEE news outlets for many years now. By this logic, won't FB banning news be beneficial for the news outlets? Why the outrage then? Because news outlets have been deriving free traffic and revenue from Google/FB and want to rent seek on top of that.