6 ms·
Why the Apple phone will fail, and fail badly (2006)
- coldtea 3y ago>As customers start to realise that the competition offers better functionality at a lower price, by negotiating a better subsidy, sales will stagnate. After a year a new version will be launched, but it will lack the innovation of the first and quickly vanish. Any other great insights Bill Ray? >Mobile phones are not complex to use because of bad interface design, they are complex to use because they are complex devices with a myriad of features. Reminds me discussions about how "shells are fine" and couldn't possibly be much better.
- Liambp 3y agoGlad I dodged a bullet there by not buying Apple stock back in 2006'
- bonestamp2 3y agoYep, for those curious... it's only gone up 63x since then.
- Veliladon 3y agoThe second Apple debuted that smooth as fucking butter interface it was clear as day how badly behind people were at the time. Pre-iPhone the form of phones was incredible but the function was dogshit garbage. Small displays rendering everything in software and failing to hit 15fps on a good day because these poor little ARM chips were being abused to within an inch of their lives. If you were seriously lucky you might get blitting in hardware. Then iPhone comes in with a high spec ARM, a GPU, and Core Graphics. If I was Nokia/SE/Motorola I would have been shitting myself watching Steve demo the iPhone knowing that I'm at least five years behind now.
- karmakurtisaani 3y agoI once read an interview with Anssi Vanjoki, who was one of the top executives at Nokia. He said indeed that when he first held an iPhone he knew it was over for Nokia. If I remember correctly, Nokia had good tech for smart phones, but no vision or courage to drive the market in that direction. It was not a well-managed company.
- Veliladon 3y agoThat's the problem with being an established market leader. You're so terrified of blowing up your own market that you're afraid to disrupt with innovation.
- gumby 3y agoThis is the topic of the famous book “The Innovator’s Dilemma” (one of the three or four business books actually worth reading, and unfortunately also the source of the overused word “disruption” in business)
- snwt 3y agoCould you by any chance list the other books? Just finished reading The Innovator's Dilemma. Phenomenal read.
- gumby 3y agoTwo other important ones for entrepreneurs: - “Crossing the Chasm” in the end this book is really just a single drawing, but the text explains the problem: why early traction not only doesn’t imply future growth, but if misunderstood, can kill any future growth. Also very important for investors and people at big companies. - I really like the underrated “Mastering the Dynamics of Innovation” by Utterback. It’s kind of a complement to the other two, full of amazing market hacks to get a new product established. For example, 120 years ago, electric companies would put on demo sessions for the public, so the gas companies would send people with metal bars in their sleeves to short out the electrical systems (in a cloud of sparks of course!). So Edison (IIRC) got the clever idea to run the electric wiring through the gas conduit, both “for safety” and to take the gas out of service. We often don’t understand what the true characteristics and affordances of a new technology are — and neither do the customers. That’s what this book is about.
- rgoulter 3y agoI think the key part of his argument is: > Mobile phones are not complex to use because of bad interface design, they are complex to use because they are complex devices with a myriad of features. The fiercely competitive mobile phone business has driven interface development at an astounding rate: it has become de rigueur for every new handset to feature a revolutionary new interface mechanism. > Apple is extremely good at creating simple interfaces, and it is likely that the Apple phone will have a pleasing interface which is relatively easy to use and recognisably iPod branded, but it won't need to appeal to the iPod users, it will need to appeal to the network operators. e.g. adding a camera to the phone can justify an additional price to the phone. I'd say it's somewhat interesting this was wrong. IIRC, the touchscreen, mobile internet, and (walled-garden) app store allow for a shift from "phone + widgets" to "smartphone".
- bottlepalm 3y agoMatches the same prediction for Tesla - the hardware companies ‘will catch up’ to the software ones. Yes cars and phones are hardware, but that’s relatively easy compared to the software. In cars people think software is just infotainment, but it’s really hundreds of controllers all networked and often each written by different vendors. Tesla has brought most of them in house, and made them updateable. Enabling features like watching your dog safe and live in your car as you eat at a restaurant. Or turning down the cabin fan so the noise doesn’t interfere with a phone call. It’s funny in like 15 years, everyone who has tried a phone OS has failed except Android.
- zbrozek 3y agoIt's all just work, and different organizations are better at different flavors of work. Some have a broader range than others.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoI think the interesting thing with respect to Tesla, and which is why I disagree with your analysis, is that they are winning not because other car companies couldn't catch up to software, but because Tesla saw the writing on the wall early and caught up with hardware. Tesla has been slashing prices recently, and they can do that and still be profitable because, especially when it comes to batteries, they have some of the lowest production costs in the industry. This is the thing that is pretty shocking to me: Tesla has managed to build in a lower cost of hardware production, which everyone else said they were so bad at. In addition, Tesla was the only one with the foresight to build out their Supercharger network, and that is a huge competitive advantage for them. For disclosure, I despise Musk and will not by a Tesla, and I own a non-Tesla EV. I love my car, but most of the other charging networks (especially Electrify America) are downright dogshit compared to Superchargers - half the stations are randomly busted, their charging speeds max out at like 50 kW when they advertise 350 kW, etc. I think the thing that's instructive about both Tesla and Apple is they are winning because they control entire "ecosystems": software plus very-well integrated hardware. Despite all the complaints about Tesla's shitty QA (which seem totally valid IMO), this seems like a situation that should improve over time, while it will be really difficult for legacy car companies to match Tesla's costs when it comes to battery production.
- Zealotux 3y agoSo how did Apple manage with the issues mentioned in the article? Namely the subsidies to operators.
- bandergirl 3y agoI think they just demonstrated that buyers would easily drop hundreds of dollars on an Apple product. Steve Ballmer also famously scoffed at the price of the iPhone.[1] [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eywi0h_Y5_U
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- signal11 3y agoIn the US, they went for exclusivity. You could only buy iPhone on AT&T, and they committed to that for 4 years. In Europe, people buy phones SIM-free as well, so it wasn’t exclusive, but many networks offered subsidies — undoubtedly because of commercial arrangements.
- prewett 3y agoOne of the ways Apple managed the issues was by selling a handheld computer which could make phone calls, rather than selling a “phone”. If they’d sold something with the limited interface of a flip phone or iPod like the author expected them to, his prediction would probably have been more accurate.
- everdrive 3y agoThey did fail … for technologists. I don’t ever see “normal” people complaining about mobile phones. Some people love them, and have no sense that anyone could dislike them. I’m definitely not criticizing technologists here, either. I really hate mobile phones, but I’d have to be blind to see how much people enjoy them.
- esjeon 3y agoRead the article before jumping into roasting. The author is NOT criticizing iPhone - he's skeptical simply because, at the time, network operators dictated which manufacturers enter the mobile phone market or not. It was a highly controlled market, and Apple not only had to build a great phone, but also had to punch through that stupid business barrier. In the end, Apple did make it.
- bombcar 3y agoIirc Apple basically bribed Cingular I think to get a toe in the market, at the time Apple fans would go to great lengths to get things working (including installing FireWire to use iPods on windows) so it worked out. AT&T later bought Cingular.
- toastercat 3y agoWow, Cingular... that's a name I haven't heard in a long time.
- twoodfin 3y agoOther way around: Cingular bought AT&T Wireless and adopted the stronger brand. It wasn’t so much Apple bribing Cingular as it was Apple/Jobs selling Cingular on the strategy of using iPhone exclusivity as an accelerant for their plans to become a top tier mobile provider. It worked.
- zuhsetaqi 3y agoThat's only partly true. He said: > As customers start to realise that the competition offers better functionality at a lower price, by negotiating a better subsidy, sales will stagnate. After a year a new version will be launched, but it will lack the innovation of the first and quickly vanish.
- esjeon 3y agoHe's still on the same line - network operators will kill the innovation what-so-ever.
- indigoabstract 3y agoWhew, I'm so happy I've always been right in my predictions, unlike this poor fellow, who has probably been unemployed since this inexcusable prediction failure.
- charles_f 3y agoThat's why I only predict that things that should kill me, won't. If ever I am wrong I will not have to suffer the consequences. So far I've always been right. I am slowly coming to the conclusion that I am immortal.
- smugma 3y agoA commenter at the time wrote “Speculation for titillation.” That rightfully deserves scorn and ridicule. It’s relevant 15 years on for those predicting huge failures for nascent ideas and markets—-if you want to make a big statement for the future, back it up. If you predicted that Theranos was a total scam, you’d be vindicated. The jury is still out on Bitcoin, etc.
- indigoabstract 3y agoWell, when you engage in speculation about the future, you're bound to be wrong most of the time. We can have fun now at his lack of insight, but, it's been almost 17 years, so maybe he can be forgiven. We all make mistakes, but if we do it on the internet, it's going to be there forever, thanks to archive.org. So kids, let that be a lesson!
- throwaway2990 3y agoThe reader replies were good. https://www.theregister.com/2007/01/09/apple_iphone_letters/ https://www.theregister.com/2007/01/09/apple_iphone_letters/
- tail_exchange 3y agoReading these articles is always amusing. The iPhone became one of the most successful products in modern history. With that, doomer articles like these are bound to be used for decades as examples of how predictions can backfire catastrophically. No journalist wants to be known as the guy who predicted the iPhone would fail.
- pushcx 3y agoThe text is still online at the original site: https://www.theregister.com/2006/12/23/iphone_will_fail/ https://www.theregister.com/2006/12/23/iphone_will_fail/ The outlet's snarky responses to reader letters are also available: https://www.theregister.com/2007/01/09/apple_iphone_letters/ https://www.theregister.com/2007/01/09/apple_iphone_letters/
- dang 3y agoYes - we've changed the URL to that from https://web.archive.org/web/20070117233154/https://www.theregister.com/2006/12/23/iphone_will_fail/ https://web.archive.org/web/20070117233154/https://www.there... now. Thanks! Submitters: it's suitable to post archive links in comments but not as submissions—so please don't submit archive links unless you've googled around for a current rendition of the article and have satisfied yourself that there's really no other way.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hxii 3y agoThis didn't age well now, did it? I myself was quite hesitant about touchscreens back in the day, when I was debating whether I should buy myself a Motorola Milestone (Android 2.1) after seeing a HTC Dream at work, or whether to get a BlackBerry Storm (with the tactile screen) since I wasn't sure how good a touchscreen will be or even if Android will survive.
- gumby 3y ago> Some have suggested that Apple will simply set up their own Mobile Virtual Network Operator (MVNO) and just fund the subsidy… I was one who believed this up until the announcement. I grossly underestimated Jobs’ ability to negotiate/strong arm the carriers, who were and remain one of those industries who fear and proactively hate their customers. (Side point: I accidentally typed “nagotiate” which was autocorrected but surely is a word every parent could use)
- kmeisthax 3y agoJobs actually wasn't that good at negotiating - every carrier had rejected their strategy of "we just sell iPhones" rather than "we sell the Verizon $RANDOM_WORD powered by V-Cast". The carriers wanted to sell features piecemeal and control the user experience so they could extract more money out of you. The only company that bit was Cingular, aka "the new AT&T", because they bought AT&T Wireless and took that brand for themselves. Before that Apple was actually considering an Apple MVNO[0], which was a fairly popular business arrangement in 2006 for some reason. The cost of getting their control was a five year exclusivity deal with AT&T, which would turn out to be a huge pain in the ass for iPhone users as AT&T's network was not at all designed to handle everyone being able to use data at the push of a button. In fact, it makes me wonder if the carriers were deliberately designing their other phones to make it more of a pain in the ass to use data... [0] Mobile Virtual Network Operator. Basically any company that sells mobile service by renting out another company's network.
- beebeepka 3y agoI liked Ballmer's "500 dollars for a phone" reaction the most. He looked scared enough to the point of having something warm and moist in his underwear. Personally, I don't like iPhones very much but all I needed to know was observe other people. And many they were truly awed at the time. Even nvidia's APX 2500 looked like something wrapped in a hurry.
- tzs 3y agoThe iPad also had widespread predictions of failure. Early that year pretty much everyone had introduced tablet PCs and convertible PCs at CES. Apple had announced the iPad but it wasn't going to ship until April. Most major magazines, reviewers, bloggers, podcasters, and such had high praise for those tablets and convertibles, saying that they were going to change how we all worked with PCs, and said iPad was late to the party and was really just a bigger iPhone without the phone, and was fatally limited compared to the versatility of the PC tablets and especially the PC convertibles, and was sure to bomb. One of the few major podcasters who said it would succeed was Leo LaPorte. On one of his podcasts he said it would sell about 5 million in its first year, and everyone else on the show told him he was insane. It actually sold 5 million in around 4 months, and 20 million in its first year.
- tzs 3y agoThe link is currently timing out. Here's an alternate link that is currently working: https://www.theregister.com/2006/12/23/iphone_will_fail/ https://www.theregister.com/2006/12/23/iphone_will_fail/
- kmeisthax 3y ago>Mobile phones are not complex to use because of bad interface design, they are complex to use because they are complex devices with a myriad of features. I'm reminded of Linus Torvalds' rant about CVS[0] and SVN giving people brain damage. While this quote is obviously hyperbolic to the point of being offensive and demeaning, there's some truth to it. People whose only experience is with CVS and SVN might just assume that all version control has to be built in that weirdly clunky and centralized way. Likewise, people who have only ever used the garbage UIs on underpowered phones confused user hostility for essential complexity. [0] Concurrent Versions System, not the US drugstore that used to be called Consumer Value Stores
- dang 3y agoRelated: Why the Apple phone will fail, and fail badly (2006) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9051005 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9051005 - Feb 2015 (5 comments)
- sys_64738 3y agoBack then you could use what phones were available from your carrier. There was no such thing as BYOD. You had to have the carrier support the Apple device and that was only possible through the AT&T deal. Without that deal the iPhone would have died a quick death as it wouldn't be usable.